Cornwall Island dispute

A 'devastating' border shutdown, a chaotic commute

A Mohawk flag has been draped over the abandoned Canadian border station just outside Cornwall on the Akwesasne territory.

Natives, Cornwallites unite against ’Public Enemy No. 1’ Peter Van Loan

Les Perreaux

Cornwall, Ont. — From Thursday's Globe and Mail

The waters around Cornwall Island are buzzing with motorboats, but these aren't pleasure cruises or the area's notorious smugglers.

The boats plying this part of the St. Lawrence River these days are mostly makeshift ferries hauling commuters across the U.S.-Canada border to the islands and mainland communities of the Akwesasne Reserve.

Long-standing animosity between Mohawks and border guards boiled over May 30, when natives protested the arming of customs agents. The guards fled their Cornwall Island post, saying they feared violence, and the federal government shut down the crossing. Cross-border travellers now must take long detours or navigate the St. Lawrence.

A month into the shutdown, there is little sign of tension between Mohawks and Cornwallites. If anything, they seem united against Public Safety Minister Peter Van Loan.

Mohawks filed an application last week asking the Federal Court to order the minister to reopen the border. They have allies among their neighbours.

“I think the minister could make one call and we'd be moving again, but he won't do it and I don't know why,” said Dennis Fortier, owner of a Cornwall trucking company. “He's washed his hands of it.”

With the tourist season under way, hotel and restaurant owners are bracing for a slow summer. Mohawks have also faced difficulties, with rerouted funeral processions, postponed medical care and disrupted garbage pickup.

It's barely 3 p.m. on a work day and Mr. Fortier is sweeping the shop floor and joking with idle truckers. Business is drying up.

Fearing a supply disruption, a U.S. ethanol plant cut orders for crop byproducts from Cornwall. Ten loads a week has been reduced to one.


Mr. Fortier's business is down about 20 per cent this month. He's losing about $5,000 a week in revenue. But he has sympathy for the Mohawk position.

“These are good people who are getting a bum rap in all of this,” Mr. Fortier said. “But the effect is quite devastating. People are getting afraid, thinking of contingency plans.”

A few kilometres south, in the middle of the St. Lawrence, Liz Sunday, a 62-year-old Mohawk grandmother, is making the complicated Akwesasne commute.

Instead of driving over the Seaway International Bridge, Ms. Sunday travels from her Quebec home into U.S. territory at the end of Ransom Road. Then she hops on a boat for a five-minute ride back into Canada. Without clearing customs, she hitches a ride to Cornwall General Hospital to visit her husband, Mitchell, who is recovering from a stroke.

Ms. Sunday embraces the voyage with grace. “I like this, you get to see people you haven't seen in a long time,” she said. “Maybe they should just leave [the border] closed.”

A dozen people on the boat say theirs is a principled fight.

“I'm sort of sick of this, but I don't see why the guards should have guns,” said Niiohontesha Jacobs, 23, U.S.-bound to pick up her two kids from preschool.

Mohawks warned 18 months ago they would not stand for Canadian customs agents carrying 9 mm pistols at the only border post on reserve land.

Akwesasne's outgoing Grand Chief Tim Thompson has called Mr. Van Loan a liar for Ottawa's claim substantive talks were held on the gun issue. A sign at the border post calls Mr. Van Loan Public Enemy No. 1.

Canadian Border Services Agency officials have met Mohawk leaders, but the minister has refused to intervene.

“He won't meet with the mayor of Cornwall, for God's sake,” said Chief Thompson, to be replaced as grand chief by Mike Mitchell next week. Mr. Mitchell says he “completely” shares Chief Thompson's view on the border.

Mr. Van Loan's office declined interview requests. A CBSA spokesperson said officials have met “more than 10 times” with Chief Thompson and a senior bureaucrat has met with Cornwall Mayor Bob Kilger.

At Cornwall City Hall, the tone is less hostile, but Mr. Kilger is looking past Mr. Van Loan and the CBSA for help.

“I'm starting to think someone like [Indian Affairs Minister] Chuck Strahl might be of more assistance. Someone a little more attuned to the history and sensitivities.”

The border post has triggered animosity for decades. Local traffic accounts for 70 per cent of the 4,000 annual crossings, most by Mohawks.

Mohawks say they have filed several human-rights complaints over guard mistreatment. One involves a young man subjected to a body-cavity search. Another is from a woman who says she was forced through an X-ray machine designed to scan trucks. The cases are unresolved.

“If you are a young Mohawk male driving a decent car, you will be searched,” Chief Thompson said. “There is systematic harassment and provocation. My feeling, bottom line, is they're racist. Not all of them, but there's always some in the bunch to ruin the apples.”

The behaviour of U.S. border guards is exemplary, he said.

But Canadian border guards have their own version of history after two decades of asking Ottawa to move the border post outside Mohawk territory.

The border post was the first to get bulletproof glass after it was shot up, according to Customs and Immigration Union president Ron Moran. Akwesasne's status as a Canada-U.S. smuggling hub adds to the tension. At the height of the tobacco-smuggling crackdown in the 1990s, guards were unnerved by red dots trained on them, apparently from laser-sighted weapons.

Mr. Moran says most of the 37 Cornwall Island agents have doctors' notes saying they cannot go back. And they definitely won't return without their weapons. “I think it's irreconcilable at this stage,” he said.

The union boss is one of the few defenders of Mr. Van Loan, saying events took an unpredictable turn. “If you had asked me on the Sunday before it happened, I wouldn't have thought they could close the office. Nobody paid enough attention to it to figure out it would get to this.”

The government is reviewing all options, but none of the potential answers is simple.

Cornwall merchants worry governments will build a new bridge outside the city to bypass the island.

The border guards and Mohawks suggest Canadian customs be moved to the U.S. side. Cornwall's mayor believes the move would face insurmountable legal hurdles.

If the crossing was placed on the Canadian mainland, Akwesasne's Cornwall Island would become Canadian territory in a customs no-man's land – hardly a winning formula for the fight against smuggling.





Commentary by the Ottawa Mens Centre


7/2/2009 9:37:40 AM
What the red necks of Canada need to understand is that Canadian Border Guards receive just Six weeks of training, and down on Cornwall Island, the local border guards have a VERY LONG HISTORY of harassment towards the locals, its not just harassment, its a seething pathological hatred that most Canadians will never see unless you just happen to get a Border Guard who takes a similar dislike to you.

Most Canadians just have a brief chat, and cross the border without anything noteworthy happening thousands of times and simply don't see what goes on locally.

Locally, its like gang warfare instigated by Canadian Border Guards that spend a great deal of time harassing the locals.

If you live in Toronto just imagine if you had to cross a border everytime you got on the 401 and had to go past poorly trained poorly educated louts with guns who have an intense dislike for you because you just happen to be "local", that's what it's like for many of the local residents who live on Cornwall Island.

Now, after generations of abuse of power and harassment, the Public Safety Minister Peter Van Loan decides, to give these same poorly trained poorly educated misfits, "guns" after a few days of firearms training.

Next time you cross a border, and seek Border Guard, with Firearm attached, just remember that he or she probably had just "six weeks" of training.

To put that in perspective, just imagine if Wallmart after six weeks of training, decided to give their greeters "firearms".

For this exercise in brilliance, or sheer stupidity, we can thank Public Safety Minister Peter Van Loan.

Now, how did he ever get to be, the Minister of "Public Safety"?