'There is nothing this system can do to prevent Nancy Tyler's murder': ex-husband's eerie message to former wife as he's sentenced to 70 years in jail

January 5, 2012 - 3:33PM


Threatened his wife ... Richard Shenkman, pictured here during an earlier court appearance. Photo: AP


A prominent former US advertising executive says he has hired an assassin to kill his ex-wife just before being sentenced to 70 years in prison for holding her hostage for more than 13 hours and burning down the Connecticut home they once shared.

Richard Shenkman, 62, was sentenced in Hartford Superior Court, where a jury convicted him in October of 10 charges, including kidnapping, arson, assault and threatening. He faced a potential of nearly 80 years in prison.

Shenkman and his ex-wife, Nancy Tyler, were in the middle of divorce-related court hearings when he abducted her from her office's parking garage in downtown Hartford on July 7, 2009, and forced her at gunpoint to drive about 14.5 kilometres to the home in South Windsor.

Kidnapped .. Nancy Tyler, sitting with prosecutor Vicki Melchiorre, addressed the court before Richard Shenkman was sentenced. Photo: AP

Authorities said Shenkman and Ms Tyler were due in court for a divorce-related hearing later that morning, and he was supposed to turn over the house to her or face jail time for contempt of court.

Ms Tyler testified that Shenkman threatened to kill her, fired a gun near her head and threatened to blow up the house. She escaped unharmed during a stand-off with police, and he was arrested after running out of the burning house.

During Wednesday's sentencing hearing, Shenkman told Judge Julia Dewey that he has hired an experienced killer to murder Ms Tyler. The judge had rejected a motion by Shenkman's attorney to delay sentencing for further psychological evaluation of his client.

"When Nancy Tyler's lifeless body is lying in the morgue ... I will have made my point," Shenkman said. "There is nothing this system can do to prevent Nancy Tyler's murder."

Shenkman is the brother of Mark Shenkman, founder and president of one of the nation's largest money management firms, Shenkman Capital Management.

Richard Shenkman's former advertising firm, Primedia, produced the Gayle King Show in 1997, starring Oprah Winfrey's best friend.

Shenkman wore an orange prison jumpsuit and his hands and legs were shackled. Judge Dewey rejected his request to have the handcuffs taken off for the hearing. He had also grown a full grey beard since he was convicted, and his shoulder-length hair, that was in a ponytail during the trial, was untied.

Defence attorney Hugh Keefe said Shenkman's remarks showed his client was mentally ill.

"I've never seen a defendant say things like that at sentencing," Mr Keefe said. "He demonstrated he was off the reservation big time."

Mr Keefe called the prison term "ridiculously stiff" and said he would appeal against the convictions.

Ms Tyler had urged the judge to impose the maximum prison sentence, saying Shenkman had terrorised her, her family and her friends for years. She begged the judge to "give us some peace".

"Mr Shenkman's campaign of destruction has been devastating," Ms Tyler said. She said after the hearing that she was not worried about the murder threats.

"I am very relieved and planning to go back to my life with my family and friends in safety," she said.

Prosecutor Vicki Melchiorre told the judge that Shenkman "will never stop trying to destroy" Ms Tyler, and she asked for the maximum sentence.

"He got exactly what he deserved," Ms Melchiorre said later. "I think he was pathetic. I think this was his last opportunity to terrorise her and he took it."

Judge Dewey called Shenkman a narcissistic and self-centred man who would do anything to get his way.

"You are never going to be rehabilitated," the judge said before announcing the sentence, which also included an order for Shenkman to pay $US100,000 restitution to Ms Tyler.

Shenkman had mounted an insanity defence, but Ms Tyler testified that her ex-husband often acted "crazy" to get his way.

Ms Tyler testified at the trial about her harrowing ordeal, saying Shenkman handcuffed himself to her, fired a handgun twice near her head, prepared a noose for her and claimed to have rigged the house with explosives as swarms of police surrounded the home.

Ms Tyler had called a friend on her mobile phone in concern over seeing Shenkman's minivan near her office and urged her to call police just before she was kidnapped.

Ms Tyler said Shenkman handcuffed her to an eyebolt in a basement wall at one point, and that she managed to unscrew the bolt and run outside when Shenkman went upstairs to check on police activity.

Shenkman talked on the phone to dispatchers and police officers several times during the ordeal. The jury listened to the recorded conversations, in which Shenkman sometimes sounded frantic, screamed, used profanity and several times counted down the seconds to his threatened killing of Ms Tyler.

Ms Tyler described how Shenkman became increasingly enraged at police during the ordeal for not meeting his demands, which included having a priest administer Ms Tyler last rites and having authorities fax over a marriage licence so he and Ms Tyler could get remarried.

Police testified that the nearly 15-hour stand-off ended when Shenkman came out of the burning home, which was uninsured at the time, and pointed a handgun at his own head.

Minutes later, officers shot Shenkman with rubber bullets and used a stun gun on him twice before subduing him and taking him into custody.

Shenkman and Ms Tyler married in 1993, and she filed for divorce in 2006. A judge approved the divorce in 2008, but court proceedings continued as Shenkman appealed.

He is also charged with burning down his and Ms Tyler's beachfront home in East Lyme in 2007 just before he was to hand it over to Ms Tyler as part of their divorce. He awaits trial on those charges.