December 9, 2015
The Ontario government should make it mandatory for all children’s aid societies to collect and make public race-based data on kids in their care.
By the numbers
• 2,155: The number of children in the care of the Toronto Children Aid Society of Toronto in 2013-14.
• 47 per cent: The proportion of black children in the care of the Toronto society with parents born in Caribbean countries.
• 20 per cent: The proportion of black children in the care of the Toronto society with parents born in Africa.
• 45 per cent: The proportion of black children who spent more than 12 months in the care of the Toronto society in the 2008 fiscal year.
• 20 per cent: The proportion of white children who spent more than 12 months in the Toronto society's care.
• 42 per
cent: Proportion of children in the care of the Children's Aid Society of
Toronto in 2013 who were black or have one parent who is black
• 8 per cent: Proportion of people under 18 in Toronto who are black
The recommendation — along with a call for an African-Canadian society to support Toronto-area black families — is included in a position paper by the Black Community Action Network (BCAN) of Peel. It will be released Wednesday morning at a Brampton conference of Peel community leaders and children’s aid society officials.
“The collection and dissemination of that data is critical to be able to assess whether the kinds of services that we have available are effective, to hold some of these agencies accountable for the kinds of services they are delivering,” Dr. Julian Hasford, the paper’s author and a community psychologist, said in an interview.
“I don’t think that we’re going to be able to make informed and effective decisions with respect to system change without that information.”
The group also wants the Peel Children’s Aid Society to follow the lead of the Children’s Aid Society of Toronto and report publicly on the proportion of children in care — and the number of families involved with the society — who are black. The Toronto society took the step this year after the Toronto Star revealed last December-that 41per cent of children in care are black children. The city’s under-18 black youth population, meanwhile, is 8.2 per cent.
Rav Bains, CEO of the Peel society, is scheduled to speak at Wednesday’s launch of the report.
The report, which examined what little is known about the overrepresentation of black children and society-involved families in Ontario, also recommends:
The Peel society establish a committee aimed at reducing the overrepresentation of black children in care and the number of black families involved with the society.
Identifying an agency that can serve, by the end of 2016, as an “initial point of contact or referral” for black children and families identified as at “risk of child welfare involvement.”
The Peel society, Peel police, Peel District School Board, Region of Peel government and service agencies adopt an “anti-oppression/anti-racism” approach that includes an “explicit anti-black-racism lens” for responding to racial disparities.
More investment at all levels of government in programs that support vulnerable families of all backgrounds.
The report also says the new African-Canadian agency “should adopt an Afrocentric approach and focus on supporting strong and healthy families, rather than removing children from the home.”
“It’s important that we create settings that are culturally responsive,” Hasford told the Star, “and it’s very clear that a lot of families that have been involved in the child welfare system, including a lot of racialized staff who also work within the system, feel that those kinds of settings aren’t necessarily sensitive to the community’s needs.
“Having said that, we recognize that mainstream staff within mainstream agencies do a lot of hard work. There are families that have benefitted from those services.”
The report highlights an existing program at Peel children’s aid, called The Village, which connects black youth in care and those who have recently left care with black mentor workers, as an example of muchneeded and successful intervention programs — and calls for more like it.
That program involved Kike Ojo, the Peel society’s diversity and antioppression manager, who is now on leave and working with the Ontario Association of Children’s Aid Societies to develop a provincial guidebook for societies to follow when dealing with black children and families. Sophia Brown Ramsay, BCAN’s program manager, acknowledged there is frustration in the community with the lack of movement in the child protection system but said that the paper and recommendations are not about assigning blame.
An ongoing Star investigation into Ontario’s child protection system that began last December found black children in care were overrepresented province-wide.
The Star found poverty and issues of neglect were driving factors for all children who come into care. With black families, racial bias and cultural misunderstanding on the part of society workers and those doing the referral — schools and police being two of the largest — are also part of the equation, say advocates and black leaders.
Being a newcomer to Canada and unfamiliar with the powers of children’s aid societies can also lead to negative initial interactions with society workers, who are often young, white and terrified of making a headline-worthy mistake.
After that, things can quickly escalate to apprehension of children.
Commentary by the Ottawa Mens Centre
Hardly anyone in Ontario is not aware that the Children's Aid Societys of Ontario are unaccountable and generally act for mothers regardless of the facts or circumstances unless of course, the father happens to fit one of their politically correct groups and the mother does not.
Child Protection in Ontario is the Gestapo, the secret police of the Ontario Government's Gender Superiority program that is designed to provide unlimited litigation support for mothers while depriving fathers of any legal rights.
The Children's Aid Society of Ottawa is one of the worst examples of criminal behaviour and of Judges in Ottawa who rubber stamp anything the CAS want.
Ottawa Mens Centre