Joshua Boyle's trial opens with estranged spouse electing to lift
Caitlan Coleman, 1 of 2 alleged victims in case; publication ban
remains for 2nd victim
Joshua Boyle arrives for the start of his trial in Ottawa on Monday. The former
hostage is charged with 19 counts, including assault and uttering a threat to
cause death. (Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press)
The trial of former hostage Joshua Boyle, charged with
assault, sexual assault and other offences, began Monday with one of the
alleged victims, his estranged spouse, electing to lift the publication ban
that has shielded her identity for more than a year.
Boyle, 35, is facing 19 charges relating to two alleged
victims, with CaitlanColeman identified
as the victim for 17 of the charges. Coleman was Boyle's spouse when he was
arrested by Ottawa police on Jan. 1, 2018.
The identity of the second victim remains protected by a
court-ordered publication ban.
Boyle has pleaded not guilty to all charges and is currently
out on bail under house arrest.
Wearing a navy jacket, light pink shirt and black pants,
Boyle sat in the Ontario courtroom gallery between his parents, taking notes
on a small yellow pad of paper. His father, sitting to his right, also took
Coleman was not in court Monday. Crown lawyer
Meaghan Cunningham told court she is currently travelling to Canada, and
that her testimony is expected to begin Wednesday and continue for about
Boyle and Coleman were abducted while on a backpacking trip
in Afghanistan in 2012.
Their return to Canada in October 2017, alongside three
children they had during their five years in captivity in Afghanistan and
Pakistan, made international headlines. The family visited with Prime
Minister Justin Trudeau not long
after their return.
Defence to question Coleman's reliability
During her opening remarks, Cunningham told court the Crown
expects Coleman's reliability and credibility will be "vigorously
challenged" by Boyle's defence team.
The Crown expects the defence to argue that Coleman had not
behaved like someone who feared Boyle, but rather like a "consenting party."
The judge will likely be asked to rule on whether Coleman's
testimony accords with common sense and human experience, Cunningham told
court, and the Crown will argue that Coleman's years in captivity and in an
abusive relationship had a "profound effect" on her, making her experience
different than most and therefore more difficult to understand and assess.
Evidence will be heard about how police came to be involved
in the case, including a 911 call made in the early hours of Dec. 30, 2017.
Witnesses to be called by the Crown will include the officers
who responded to the 911 call, a forensic identification officer who took
part in a search warrant at the couple's home, a neighbour who made
observations about the family, Coleman's mother and two sisters, and a
Global Affairs Canada employee who accompanied the Boyle family on their
flight to Canada after years in captivity.
The Crown's first witness, registered social worker Deborah
Sinclair, testified in general terms Monday about abusive relationships and
how victims of abuse and trauma behave, citing a report she prepared for the
Cunningham told court Sinclair wasn't going to comment on
Boyle and Coleman or their relationship specifically.
Sinclair testified that abuse takes several forms: emotional,
psychological and physical, and that abusers often "groom" their victims
over time, gradually wearing them down to make them more compliant and adopt
the abuser's point of view.
It's hard for the average person to understand why someone
wouldn't walk away, Sinclair told court, but victims often feel powerless,
blame themselves and don't look at what's happening to them from a critical
point of view.
From left, defence lawyer Lawrence Greenspon, Ontario Court
Justice Peter Doody and Crown witness Deborah Sinclair at Boyle's
trial. (Courthouse sketch by Lauren Foster-MacLeod)
In captivity, both partners would have an increased dependency on each other,
there would be fewer options available to resist abuse, and the torture and
mistreatment of an abuser may make him more likely to redirect that trauma to
the victim, thereby giving him a sense of control, Sinclair testified.
During cross examination by defence lawyer Lawrence Greenspon,
Sinclair conceded she hasn't done formal, peer-reviewed research on how
prolonged captivity affects relationships, and that she therefore can't say
what effects five years of captivity might have on a relationship.
Sinclair also conceded she's not an expert in distinguishing whether a
victim's behaviour results from domestic abuse or prolonged captivity, and
admitted that her report doesn't make those distinctions.
Greenspon also emphasized that Sinclair works as an activist in the field of
violence against women, working to change social systems that prevent women
being protected and heard.
Arrested in 2018
Upon their return to Canada in 2017, the couple and their children went first
to Smiths Falls, Ont., where Boyle's parents live, then moved to Ottawa.
Boyle was arrested by Ottawa police on New Year's Day in 2018 and charged.
His eight-week trial by judge alone is being overseen by Judge Peter Doody of
the Ontario Court of Justice.
Boyle is being represented by Greenspon and Eric Granger, while Cunningham and
Jason Neubauer are handling the case for the Crown.
The 19 charges Boyle faces are:
- One count of sexual assault while threatening to use a
- One count of sexual assault with a weapon (ropes).
- One count of uttering a threat to cause death.
- Nine counts of assault.
- One count of assault with a weapon (a broomstick).
- Three counts of unlawful confinement.
- One count of administering a noxious substance (the antidepressant Trazodone).
- One count of public mischief (misleading a police officer into believing
that someone was suicidal and missing, causing the officer to start an
investigation, and thereby diverting suspicion away from Boyle).
- One count of criminal harassment.
Police allege the offences happened in Ottawa between Oct. 14, 2017, and Dec.
Commentary by the Ottawa Mens Centre
When the crown are desperate for a conviction when the Ottawa Police fabricate
evidence, they call upon the underbelly of the Crown Attorneys in Ottawa.
Jason Neubauer is what is known as a political prosecutor who is off the bottom
end of the ethics scale when it comes to Crown's.
is often called in when its a next to impossible case to win, its also often
accompanied by a corrupt judge who is known as a Rubber Stamp for the crown.
While I know nothing of Judge Peter Doody, when Jason Neaubauer and Cunningham
you can generally expect the verdict to be a forgone conclusion especially
when the judge allows a dubious extreme feminist to testify as a witness.
The Salem Witch Trials had more justice than this trial is going to get.