Superior Court Penalties

                                    Regions and Judges of Ontario

    Central South Ontario Judicial Region Summary

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

      Peter Karl Roscoe

 

               Nov  2008

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Central South Region  Penalties and Cost Penalties Summary

 

 

Contents

 

1   Sex of judge              M – Male          F - Female

2   Region                      Cs – Central South Region

 

      # p – number of penalties        # sr – number of penalties to self represented litigants

 

 

 

     Penalties Against Men

 

 

    Penalties Against Women

 

      Total

 

    Major

 

 

       Total

 

     Major

     Judge

 1

 2

 

 # p

# sr

 

 # p

# sr

 

 

 # p

# sr

 

 # p

# sr

 

 

Lafrenierre

F

Cs

 

   4

   1

 

   3

   1

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

McLaren

F

Cs

 

   2

   0

 

   1

   0

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Millanetti

F

Cs

 

   4

   0

 

   4

   0

 

 

   1

   1

 

   1

   1

Tucker

F

Cs

 

   5

   4

 

   3

   2

 

 

   2

   0

 

   0

   0

Walters

F

Cs

 

   4

   2

 

   2

   1

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Borkovich

M

Cs

 

   2

   0

 

   1

   0

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Cavarzan

M

Cs

 

   8

   0

 

   2

   0

 

 

   3

   0

 

   2

   0

Fedak

M

Cs

 

   2

   1

 

   1

   1

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Festeryga

M

Cs

 

   6

   1

 

   5

   1

 

 

   2

   0

 

   2

   0

Flynn

M

Cs

 

 15

   5

 

   9

   2

 

 

   6

   2

 

   3

   1

Glithero

M

Cs

 

   8

   3

 

   3

   0

 

 

   4

   1

 

   1

   0

Gordon D

M

Cs

 

 29

   6

 

 19

   5

 

 

   9

   0

 

   2

   0

Hambly

M

Cs

 

 27

   1

 

 16

   1

 

 

   5

   2

 

   1

   1

Harris

M

Cs

 

   3

   0

 

   1

   0

 

 

   1

   0

 

   0

   0

Henderson

M

Cs

 

 10

   2

 

   4

   0

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Lofchik

M

Cs

 

   3

   1

 

   3

   1

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Marshall

M

Cs

 

   2

   0

 

   2

   0

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Matheson

M

Cs

 

 13

   2

 

   9

   2

 

 

   2

   0

 

   0

   0

Mazza

M

Cs

 

   3

   1

 

   2

   1

 

 

   2

   0

 

   1

   0

Pazaratz

M

Cs

 

   1

   1

 

   0

   0

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Quinn

M

Cs

 

 11

   6

 

   9

   5

 

 

   5

   3

 

   1

   1

Reilly

M

Cs

 

   3

   1

 

   2

   1

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Sheppard

M

Cs

 

   2

   2

 

   2

   2

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Scime

M

Cs

 

   2

   0

 

   2

   0

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Sills

M

Cs

 

   5

   3

 

   3

   2

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Steinberg

M

Cs

 

   4

   1

 

   3

   0

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Taliano

M

Cs

 

   7

   1

 

   6

   1

 

 

   1

   0

 

   0

   0

Taylor

M

Cs

 

   1

   0

 

   1

   0

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

Turnbull

M

Cs

 

 16

   4

 

 10

   3

 

 

   4

   1

 

   2

   1

Whitten

M

Cs

 

   8

   1

 

   5

   1

 

 

   0

   0

 

   0

   0

 

Female Judges

  5

 

 

 19

  7

 

 13

 4

 

 

  3

  1

 

  1

  1

Male judges

25

 

 

192

 43

 

122

 29

 

 

 44

  9

 

15

  4

Total

30

 

 

211

 50

 

133

 33

 

 

 47

 10

 

16

  5

 

 

 

 

 

Central South Financial Data       ( in 1000 $’s )

 

 

 

Male Lump Sums                     missing 3

 

N = 13         Mean = 24.6       Total = 319.8

 

5.000 8.500 10.00 10.00 10.00 13.50 15.00 20.00 27.50 35.00 41.00 45.00 79.00

 

 

Male Imputed Income                missing 1

 

N = 25         Mean = 32.6       Total = 815.0

 

1.000 7.000 7.800 8.000 9.000 9.000 10.00 18.00 19.00 20.00 20.00 23.30 28.00 32.00 35.00 37.00 40.00 44.00 47.00 50.00 55.00 58.00 60.00 78.00 100.0

 

 

Male Cost Penalties

 

N = 90         Mean = 17.9       Total =1611.0

 

0.3000 0.5000 0.7000 0.7000 0.8000 0.8000 0.8000 1.000 1.000 1.100 1.200 1.500 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.100 2.400 2.600 2.800 3.000 3.000 3.100 3.200 3.500 3.500 3.800 4.000 4.100 4.500 4.500 5.000 5.000 5.800 5.900 5.900 5.900 6.000 6.400 6.400 6.800 6.900 7.000 7.400 7.400 7.500 7.800 8.000 8.500 8.500 8.500 8.700 9.400 10.00 10.00 10.30 10.60 11.00 12.50 12.50 13.40 13.60 14.30 14.50 15.00 15.00 15.00 15.00 15.70 17.90 18.90 19.50 20.30 20.60 22.00 22.50 23.90 32.00 34.30 39.00 40.00 44.70 46.00 50.00 58.70 75.00 90.00 103.4 112.4 144.6 150.0

 

 

 

 

 

Female Cost Penalties

 

N = 27         Mean = 24.3        Total = 655.0

 

0.1000 0.8000 1.500 2.000 2.400 2.500 3.000 3.000 5.200 5.300 6.400 9.000 9.500 9.500 10.00 13.60 15.00 16.00 31.00 32.00 32.00 35.00 35.00 40.70 45.50 89.00 200.0

 

 

 

Central South Case Summary

 

 

 

1)   Penalties Against Men

 

 

 

Contents

 

 

1  Sex of Judge                                               M – male                          F - female

 

2  Region                                Ce – central east                Cs – central south            Cw – central east

                                                 E – eastern                       Ne – north east                 Nw – north west

                                               Sw – south west                  T - Toronto

 

3  Sex of Mans Lawyer          M – male     F – female     L – lawyer     sr – self represented      ex – ex parte

 

4  Sex of Womans Lawyer     M – male     F – female     L – lawyer     sr – self represented      ex – ex parte

 

5  Major or Minor Penalty                               mj – major                      mn - minor

 

6  Type of Penalty                   C – contempt                         Cts – costs                           D – default

                                                Ep – exclusive possession of the family home            F – freezing assets

                                                Js – summary judgment          Ip – imputed income           L – lump sum

                                                Pr – prejudgment interest       Ro - restraining order     Sa - supervised access

                                                Sc – security                            St – striking pleadings

 

7  Amount of impution of yearly income, or total cost penalty, or lump sum          ( in 1000 $’s )

 

 

 

   Judge

 1

 2

3

4

                Case

  5

  6

  7

                 Description

 

 

Lafreniere

F

Cs

F

M

Fletcher v. McDonnell, 2005 CanLII 23108 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

2.0

2 K costs of interim motion reserverved for trial judge

Lafreniere

F

Cs

F

M

Fletcher v. McDonnell, 2005 CanLII 23108 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

45.0

 24 K lump sum paid, 21 K ordered for arrears of child support

Lafreniere

F

Cs

M

F

Fletcher v. McDonnell, 2005 CanLII 23108 (ON S.C.)

mj

Pr

 

Wife gets 9 years prejudgment interest on 57 K

Lafrenierre

F

Cs

sr

M

D.B. v. J.B., 2006 CanLII 726 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

9.0

Man claims 15 K imputed to 26 K

Mclaren

F

Cs

M

M

Caterini v. Zaccaria, 2002 CanLII 2772 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ip

1.0

Man s income drops. Minor 1 K imputation added to his claim instead of 9 K asked

McLaren

F

Cs

M

M

Patterson v. Patterson, 2007 CanLII 26288 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

144.6

Divorce action, wife successful on 4 out of 6 issues, wife asks 342 K and gets 144.6 K

Milanetti

F

Cs

M

M

Graham v. Graham, 2005 CanLII 23682 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

100.0

Man declares 100 K income and is imputed to 200 K, 10 K per month total interim support, 35 K interim disbursement to wife

Milanetti

F

Cs

M

F

Lowry v. Kushnir, 2007 CanLII 18146 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

3.0

Motion, wife asks 75 K in costs and gets 25 K, and wife gets 3 K in cost for case conference

Millanetti

F

Cs

M

F

Graham v. Graham, 2005 CanLII 23682 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

40.0

Wife gets 40 K costs

Millanetti

F

Cs

M

F

Graham v. Graham, 2005 CanLII 23682 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

Ep

 

Wife gets exclusive interim possession, 10 K per month combined support

Tucker

F

Cs

sr

M

Armstrong v. Armstrong, 2004 CanLII 12100 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

37.0

Man on disability imputed to 47 K per year, lump sum retroactive support

Tucker

F

Cs

sr

M

Armstrong v. Armstrong, 2004 CanLII 12100 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

 

Restraining order against man changed to mutual restraining order, access restored, contact at access allowed, retroactive lump sum for support, imputed income

Tucker

F

Cs

F

M

Danis v. Danis, 2004 CanLII 8245 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

47.0

Man is unemployed but imputed to 47 K

Tucker

F

Cs

sr

M

Gill v. Knack, 2007 CanLII 1332 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

3.5

Only remaining issue was Christmas access, 3.5 K costs

Tucker

F

Cs

sr

M

Siconolfi v. Siconolfi, 2007 CanLII 1327 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

7.0

Divorce action partially settled, wife asks 15.5 K gets  7 K

Walters

F

Cs

sr

 

Mindzak v. Turner, 2006 CanLII 9705 (ON S.C.)

 

mn

L

 

4 K retroactiver child support award to be paid $ 50 per month, supervised access changed to unsupervised

Walters

F

Cs

M

F

Royston v. Royston, 2003 CanLII 1978 (ON S.C.)

mn

Sc

 

Man must designate wife as beneficiary of insurance policy

Walters

F

Cs

sr

sr

T.P.S. v. K.E.S, 2007 CanLII 17382 (ON S.C.)

mj

F

 

Mans assets frozen, man violates order, wife abducts children

Walters

F

Cs

F

M

Wright v. Ingham, 2006 CanLII 591 (ON S.C.)

mj

Sa

 

Man gets interim supervised access, continued by Scott J, wife gets custody and access restored in agreement

Gordon

M

Cs

sr

M

A.P. v. G.P., 2006 CanLII 17600 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

17.9

Divorce action, 17.9 K costs

Borkovich

M

Cs

M

F

Bremer v. Bremer, 2005 CanLII 6387 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

15.0

15 K costs incurred by wife due to husbands intransience

Borkovitch

M

Cs

M

F

Bremer v. Bremer, 2004 CanLII 17346 (ON S.C.)

mn

Pr

 

Wife awarded prejudgment interest

Cavarzan

M

Cs

M

M

Kreutzer v. Corbeil, 2005 CanLII 6395 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ep

 

Wife gets exclusive possession, and pays occupancy rent

Cavarzan

M

Cs

M

M

R. v. R., 2000 CanLII 22425 (ON S.C.)

mn

Pr

 

Wife gets prejudgment interest on retroactive support, 20 K child support per month and 5 K spousal support

Cavarzan

M

Cs

M

M

Ruscinski v. Ruscinski, 2006 CanLII 19446 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ep

 

Wife gets exclusive possession of the matrimonial home, man pays spousal support

Cavarzan

M

Cs

M

M

Ruscinski v. Ruscinski, 2006 CanLII 9982 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ro

 

Restraining order for assault, 5 K damages, court denies permanent restraining order, supervised access changed to joint custody with primary residence with wife, 2.3 K per month total support, wife gets exclusive possession of home

Cavarzan

M

Cs

M

M

Ruscinski v. Ruscinski, 2006 CanLII 9982 (ON S.C.)

 

mn

Sa

 

 Domestic assault, supervised access, joint custody at trial, lump sum, imputed income, 2.4 K per month total support, non harassment order, 4 K damages for assault

Cavarzan

M

Cs

M

M

Tessarolo v Tessarolo, 2005 CanLII 25108 (ON S.C.)

mn

L

5.0

Lump sum 5 K compensatory support, life insurance as security

Cavarzan

M

Cs

M

M

Tessarolo v Tessarolo, 2005 CanLII 25108 (ON S.C.)

mn

Sc

 

Lump sum 5 K compensatory support, life insurance as security

Cavarzan

M

Cs

M

M

Tessarolo v. Tessarolo, 2005 CanLII 30882 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

10.0

Wife asks for 6 K, husband asks for 12 K, wife gets 10 K

Fedak

M

Cw

sr

sr

Edgar v. Sikora, 2004 CanLII 13394 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Man under restraining order not to see children

Fedak

M

Cs

M

M

Ragis v. Ragis, 2005 CanLII 18854 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

10.0

Divorce action, only issue left for trial was support, 10 K costs

Festeryga

M

Cs

sr

M

Armstrong v. Armstrong, 2004 CanLII 12100 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Restraining order for verbal arguments against man changed to mutual restraining order, access restored, contact at access allowed, retroactive support lump sum, imputed income

Festeryga

M

Cs

M

M

Keen v. Keen, 2007 CanLII 6919 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

3.5

3.5 K interim motion

Festeryga

M

Cs

M

M

Prince v. Prince, 2006 CanLII 27873 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ep

 

Wife gets long term exclusive possession for 6 more years, man pays child support but not spousal

Festeryga

M

Cs

F

F

S.P. v. F.R., 2006 CanLII 19948 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

20.3

Divorce action, wife asks 25 K and gets 20 .3 K, husband Asks  30.3 K

Festeryga

M

Cs

M

M

Sheppard v. Sheppard, 2005 CanLII 30878 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

 

Prejudgment interest awarded as lump sum, 8 K per month support, 1.2 million equalization to be paid in installments of 200 K

Festeryga

M

Cs

M

M

Sheppard v. Sheppard, 2005 CanLII 30878 (ON S.C.)

mj

Pr

 

Wife gets unstated prejudgment interest

Flynn

M

Cs

sr

F

Atkinson v. Atkinson, 2007 CanLII 14318 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

14.5

Divorce trial. 14.5 K

Flynn

M

Cs

L

L

Boddington v. Boddington, 2003 CanLII 45771 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

8.5

8.5 K costs of motion

Flynn

M

Cs

M

F

Claer v. Claer, 2006 CanLII 32612 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

5.0

Motion, wife asks 8.5 K gets 5 K

Flynn

M

Cs

sr

F

Cupolo v. Anzovino, 2003 CanLII 2091 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

1.0

1K for ex parte divorce, requested 11 K

Flynn

M

Cs

sr

F

Del Net v. Benger, 2003 CanLII 2096 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

6.8

Mother allowed to move with child, 6.8 K costs

Flynn

M

Cs

sr

L

Duquette v. Gregorio, 2006 CanLII 32615 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

2.4

2.4 Kcosts  for access motion

Flynn

M

Cs

M

M

Eberl v. Eberl, 2004 CanLII 10617 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

28.0

Man laid off from job is imputed to 28 K and it’s ordered no variations until his income exceeds 28 K, court refuses to impute income to wife, Man must pay spousal support and $ 500 per month in child support

Flynn

M

Cs

M

M

Johannesson v. Johannesson, 2003 CanLII 2141 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

2.1

Contempt access motion by husband, 2.1 K costs

Flynn

M

Cs

M

F

Lagos v. Lagos, 2006 CanLII 43492 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

6.9

Motion, 6.9 K costs

Flynn

M

Cs

M

F

McKinnon v. McKinnon, 2004 CanLII 34782 (ON S.C.)

mn

Sc

 

Husband must designate wife as beneficiary of his insurance policy

Flynn

M

Cs

M

F

McKinnon v. McKinnon, 2004 CanLII 47798 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

Cts

19.5

72 K retroactive support, 19.5 K costs

Flynn

M

Cs

L

M

Miner v. Miner, 2004 CanLII 5064 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

44.0

Man claims 117 K and is imputed to 161 K, 70 K support lump as part of agreement before guidelines came into effect

Flynn

M

Cs

M

M

Nittel v. Nittel, 2007 CanLII 14340 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

22.0

Divorce action 22 K

Flynn

M

Cs

sr

sr

Platonova v. Platonov, 2005 CanLII 2951 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

2.0

Divorce action, self represented wife gets 2 K costs against intrasient husband

Flynn

M

Cs

M

M

Vernon v. Vernon, 2006 CanLII 23266 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

15.0

Motion for support, wifes partial lawyers bill 47 K, 15 K costs

Glithero

M

Cs

L

L

Ashley v. Ashley, 2006 CanLII 32603 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

8.0

Support motion, 8 K costs

Glithero

M

Cs

M

M

Defoe v. Defoe, 2004 CanLII 5040 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

1.2

Divorce action, all but support settled on consent, wife gets 1.2 K

Glithero

M

Cs

M

F

Erb v. Erb, 2003 CanLII 2308 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

18.9

Divorce action, wife asks 23.8 K gets 18.9 K

Glithero

M

Cs

L

L

Harnum v. Harnum, 2005 CanLII 3231 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

12.5

12.6 K costs for 2 day trial

Glithero

M

Cs

sr

M

Hoddinott v. Hoddinott, 2002 CanLII 2791 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

13.6

Wife gets interim exclusive possession, man declares bankruptcy, 13.6 K costs for trial

Glithero

M

Cs

sr

M

Hoddinott v. Hoddinott, 2002 CanLII 2791 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ep

 

Wife gets interim exclusive possession, man declares bankruptcy, 13.6 K costs for trial

Glithero

M

Cs

L

L

Visneskie v. Visneskie, 2003 CanLII 2265 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ep

 

Wife gets exclusive possession

Glithero

M

Cs

L

L

Wood v. Wood, 2004 CanLII 14407 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

23.9

Wife gets 23.9 K for divorce action

Gordon D

M

Cs

sr

M

A.P. v. G.P., 2006 CanLII 9976 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

D

 

Failure to provide disclosure, default on ordered return of funds results in unequal division with man prohibited from claiming debts to wife in his bankruptcy

Gordon D

M

Cs

sr

M

A.P. v. G.P., 2006 CanLII 9976 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

Sc

 

Proceeds from home held in trust and disbursed to wife, life insurabce as security for support

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Alsafouti v. Alsafouti, 2005 CanLII 47755 (ON S.C.)

mj

D

 

FRO takes mans drivers license and the court refuses to hear motion for relief

Gordon D

M

Cs

sr

L

Bukvic v. Bukvic, 2007 CanLII 26600 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

12.5

12.5 K for motion for constructive trust and retroactive support from bankrupt husband

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Conway v. Conway, 2005 CanLII 14136 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

13.5

13.5 K lump sum for support, 6 K for equalization

Gordon D

M

Cs

F

M

Craig v. Craig, 2004 CanLII 5039 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

6.4

Husbands motion to terminate support, 6.4 K costs

Gordon D

M

Cs

M

F

F.J.N. v. J.L.N., 2004 CanLII 34783 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

15.0

Divorce action including mobility, wife asks 20.2 K gets 15 K

Gordon D

M

Cs

sr

M

H.1 v. H.2, 2004 CanLII 43947 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

5.9

1 day simple trial, 5.9 K costs

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Hunter v. Hunter, 2005 CanLII 22139 (ON S.C.)

mj

Pr

 

Wife gets prejudgment interest on 67 K equalization payment

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Kelly v. Kelly, 2002 CanLII 2700 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

3.2

Interim motion, wife asks 4.6 K and gets 3.2 K

Gordon D

M

Cs

M

M

Lee-Chin v. Lee-Chin, 2005 CanLII 47758 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

13.4

Several interim motions consolidated into one hearing, wife asks 29.9 K gets 13.4 K, husband asks 37.1 K

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Lindahl v. Lindahl, 2005 CanLII 34583 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ro

 

Mutual non harassment order, children live in home man and wife switch each week, wife moves to US and court allows her mobility while she has children

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

MacGregor v. MacGregor, 2002 CanLII 2752 (ON S.C.)

mn

Sa

 

Wife alleges husband has a drinking problem, access supervised by husbands mother

Gordon D

M

Cs

M

M

Mayer v. Mayer, 2003 CanLII 2177 (ON S.C.)

 

mn

Cts

4.5

Interim motion on parenting schedule, 4.5 K costs, mutual non depletion and harassment order on consent

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

O'Brien v. O'Brien, 2006 CanLII 11921 (ON S.C.)

mj

F

 

Non dissipation order against man kept in effect but charging or vesting order denied

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Picollo v. Picollo, 2004 CanLII 50314 (ON S.C.)

mj

F

 

Mutual non depletion and harassment order, wife gets support, wife get exclusive possession of home on consent

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Picollo v. Picollo, 2004 CanLII 50314 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ro

 

Neither oppose mutual non harassment and non depletion orders, older sons live with man, no custody or child support order, 3.2 K per month spousal support to wife

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Plotz v. Boehmer-Plotz, 2004 CanLII 34349 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

8.5

Support variation dismissed, 8.5 K costs

Gordon D

M

Cs

sr

M

Purves v. Purves, 2004 CanLII 6249 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Mutual restraining order, wife gets custody, fathers income imputed from 18 to 25 K per year, joint custody changed to sole custody to mother

Gordon D

M

Cs

sr

M

R.J.R.H. v. A.A.H., 2004 CanLII 34792 (ON S.C.)

mj

Sa

 

Fathers unsupervised access reduced to supervised

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Rothenburg v. Rothenburg, 2003 CanLII 2229 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

15.0

15 K lump sum for retroactive support, life insurance policy as security

Gordon D

M

Cs

M

M

Rothenburg v. Rothenburg, 2003 CanLII 2229 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

Sc

 

Secure life insurance in wifes name of almost 1 million for spousal of $ 4500 per month

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Scodras v. Scodras, 2005 CanLII 14146 (ON S.C.)

mn

Sc

 

50 K held from sale of home for wife uequal division claim

Gordon D

M

Cs

M

M

Sheikh v. Sheikh, 2005 CanLII 34589 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

150.0

Divorce action, wife wins mobility, asks 190 K and gets 150 K

Gordon D

M

Cs

M

L

Sheikh v. Sheikh, 2005 CanLII 34589 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

20.0

Man pays lump sum of 20 K for back support, equalization of 80 K and costs of 150 K, mother allowed to move to England with child

Gordon D

M

Cs

M

M

Stockie v. Stockie, 2003 CanLII 2353 (ON S.C.)

mj

Sc

 

42 K RRSP to be preserved and 100 K security deposit to the court

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Tughan v. Tughan, 2003 CanLII 2355 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

60.0

Man is unemployed and income is imputed to 60.6 K per year

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Wood v. Wood, 2002 CanLII 2717 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

5.9

5.9 K for motion

Gordon D

M

Cs

M

F

Woodland v. Woodland, 2005 CanLII 34591 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

10.0

Man claims 19 K income from compensation and is imputed to almost 30 K as underemployed, 45 K arrears reduced to 40 K arrears

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Brandon v. Brandon, 2003 CanLII 2069 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

0.7

Access motion to determine where children go to school, 0.7 K costs

Hambly

M

Cs

sr

M

Buck v. Buck, 2003 CanLII 2072 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

8.5

Unnecesary motion, 8.5 K costs, wife gets proceeds from sale of home as advance on equalization

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Cauchy-Eckardt v. Eckardt, 2004 CanLII 6225 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

7.4

Support motion, wife asks 8 K and gets 7.4 K

Hambly

M

Cs

L

L

Crewe v. Crewe, 2006 CanLII 3656 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

Sa

 

4 months interim supervised access continued by Sills J, 2 ½ hours every second Sunday

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Difrancesco v. Couto, 2001 CanLII 8613 (ON C.A.)

mj

Ip

9.0

Unemployed man imputed to 9 K and 40 K arrears rescind, arrears reinstated on appeal

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Eberl v. Eberl, 2004 CanLII 10617 (ON S.C.)

mj

F

 

Non dissipation order

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Fleming v. Fleming, 2005 CanLII 19832 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

0.8

Motion to vary access to unsupervised dismissed, 0.8 K costs

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Fleming v. Fleming, 2005 CanLII 19832 (ON S.C.)

mj

Sa

 

Motion to vary access to unsupervised dismissed, 0.8 K costs

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Fulmer v. Kaleo-Fulmer, 2002 CanLII 2719 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

2.6

2.6 K costs for custody variation motion, changed to sole custody to wife

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Gentle v. Gentle, 2007 CanLII 26606 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

3.8

Motion to vary support. 3.8 K costs

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Lane v. Lane, 2002 CanLII 2794 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ep

 

Wife gets interim exclusive possession and custody of children

Hambly

M

Cs

L

L

O'Connor v. O'Connor, 2004 CanLII 6232 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

1.1

Summary judgment on s.7 expenses and travel consent, 1.1 K costs

Hambly

M

Cs

L

L

O'Connor v. O'Connor, 2004 CanLII 6232 (ON S.C.)

mn

Js

 

Summary judgment on s.7 expenses and travel consent, 1.1 K costs

Hambly

M

Cs

L

L

Plotz v. Boehmer-Plotz, 2004 CanLII 34349 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

5.8

Support variation dismissed, 5.8 K costs, previous 15 K cost award unpaid, 27 K arrears

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Purvis v. Purvis, 2003 CanLII 18186 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

0.7

Interim motion $ 700 costs, man must pay equalization based on property evaluation 55 K above sale price

Hambly

M

Cs

M

F

R.W.L. v. K.A.L., 2003 CanLII 2168 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

5.9

Husband brings motion for  custody assessment and access, 5.9 K costs

Hambly

M

Cs

M

F

R.W.L. v. K.A.L., 2003 CanLII 2168 (ON S.C.)

mj

Sa

 

Access to be at wifes discretion

Hambly

M

Cs

M

L

R.W.L. v. K.A.L., l2003 CanLII 2453 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Man first charged with assault takes anger management, second charges, wife gets custody, third party child center exchanges, makes allegations to Childrens Aid, access cut and must take parenting class

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Reinhardt v. Reinhardt, 2004 CanLII 34788 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

58.7

Separation agreement varied, 58.7 K  costs

Hambly

M

Cs

L

L

Reinhardt v. Reinhardt, 2004 CanLII 34788 (ON S.C.)

mn

Pr

 

Wife gets 5 % on 10 K for 6 years and 3 months

Hambly

M

Cs

M

M

Reinhardt v. Reinhardt, 2004 CanLII 35095 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

79.0

79 K lump sum for retroactive support, separation agreement overturned, spousal support increased from $ 400 to 1.2 K per month

Hambly

M

Cs

F

M

Sanders v. Sanders, 2003 CanLII 2347 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

7.5

Divorce action, 7.5 K costs

Hambly

M

Cs

F

M

Sanders v. Sanders, 2003 CanLII 2347 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

18.0

Man claims 82 K income and is imputed to 100 K

Hambly

M

Cs

L

L

Smith v. Lennox, 2004 CanLII 51969 (ON S.C.)

mj

Sa

 

Mans supervised access at access center terminated and access at wifes discretion at a secure safe place

Hambly

M

Cs

M

F

Tzeng v. Tzeng, 2007 CanLII 17042 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

112.4

Wife gets 112.4 K costs in assault action against husband, 150 K damage award

Hambly

M

Cs

L

L

Von Feilitz v. Von Feilitz, 2002 CanLII 2821 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

0.8

0.8K for previous interim motion

Harris

M

Cs

M

M

Costa v. Costa, 2002 CanLII 2708 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

34.3

Divorce action, 5 day trial, wife asks 41.7 K and gets 34.3 K

Harris

M

Cs

L

L

Fahandezh v. Fahandezh Sadi, 2002 CanLII 2734 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ep

 

Wife gets exclusive possession

Harris

M

Cs

M

M

Leng v. Marini, 2006 CanLII 27872 (ON S.C.)

mn

D

 

Man must pay 6.7 K in previous costs

Henderson

M

Cs

M

M

Cianflone v. Cianflone, 2006 CanLII 37127 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

14.3

Divorce action no kids 14.3 K costs

Henderson

M

Cs

sr

M

Facchin v. Taylor, 2004 CanLII 33118 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

2.0

Appeal of support variance, 2 K costs

Henderson

M

Cs

M

M

Keen v. Keen, 2007 CanLII 6919 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

9.4

Divorce action settled on consent except support, 9.4 costs

Henderson

M

Cs

M

M

Little v. Little, 2002 CanLII 2797 (ON S.C.)

mj

Sc

 

Insurance for security, vesting order on house, 2.1 K per month spousal support, 20 K equalization

Henderson

M

Cs

sr

M

Longpre v. Skursky, 2005 CanLII 31301 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

0.3

Motion to vary support dismissed, $ 250 costs unless higher bill approved

Henderson

M

Cs

F

F

MacGregor v. Stone, 2004 CanLII 42944 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

50.0

Divorce trial, 50 K costs, 7.5 K costs of appeal

Henderson

M

Cs

M

M

Racz v. Racz, 2004 CanLII 39025 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

4.5

Divorce action settled on consent, 4.5 K costs

Henderson

M

Cs

M

M

Racz v. Racz, 2004 CanLII 39025 (ON S.C.)

mn

Pr

 

Wife gets $ 354 prejudgment interest and 4.5 K costs

Henderson

M

Cs

L

L

Sheikh v. Sheikh, 2005 CanLII 14151 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ep

 

Wife gets exclusive possession, $457 child support per month and $ 1500 spousal support

Henderson

M

Cs

M

M

Zeleny v. Zeleny, 2004 CanLII 5094 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

7.8

Wife agreed to pay lawyer $ 90 per hour but judge raises it to $ 195, 7.8 K for one motion

Lofchik

M

Cs

sr

M

DeMarco v. DeMarco, 2005 CanLII 6389 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Wife gets restraining order continued, pleadings struck

Lofchik

M

Cs

M

F

Galambos v. Towers, 2006 CanLII 29661 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

44.7

Divorce action no children, wife asks for 60.4 K and gets 44.7 K

Lofchik

M

Cs

M

F

Galambos-Towers v. Towers, 2005 CanLII 44386 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

20.0

Vague imputation of 20 K per year to underearning asset results in $ 200 per month spousal support, property equalization of 122 K to wife

Marshall

M

Cs

L

L

Goyal v. Singh, 2002 CanLII 2748 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

Sa

 

Father given supervised access, wife makes allegations and denies access, court orders investigation by Office of the Childrens Lawyer

Marshall

M

Cs

M

F

Mancuso v. Mancuso, 2004 CanLII 43770 (ON C.A.)

mj

Cts

32.0

Mans divorce trial costs lowered to 32 K on appeal, 10 K costs for appeal

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Chapin v. Chapin, 2003 CanLII 2080 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

0.8

Support variation, $ 750 costs

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Flewelling v. Flewelling, 2007 CanLII 16442 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

6.0

Motion unsuccessfully appealed 6 K costs

Matheson

M

Cs

F

M

Grant v. Grant, 2005 CanLII 47703 (ON S.C.)

mj

Js

 

Summary judgment on motion to vary support, man is unemployed, 53 K arrears, unstated costs

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Hines v. Hines, 2006 CanLII 28737 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

8.5

8.5 K spousal support lump sum

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Hines v. Hines, 2007 CanLII 2208 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

3.1

Support action,  3.1 K  costs

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Loy v. Loy, 2005 CanLII 27606 (ON S.C.)

mn

Sc

 

Life insurance policy against 8 K per month support

Matheson

M

Cs

sr

M

Majkut-Giammarco v. Giammarco, 2004 CanLII 34797 (ON S.C.)

mj

D

 

 Denied trial

Matheson

M

Cs

sr

M

Niro v. Niro, 2004 CanLII 5068 (ON S.C.)

mj

St

 

Husbands claim against his ex wife and lawyers for fraud is struck

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Parnell v. Viger, 2004 CanLII 27183 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

103.4

Divorce action with 9 days of trial involving constructive trust, 103.4 K costs

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Parnell v. Viger, 2004 CanLII 27183 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ep

 

Man uses false information to get exclusive possession at ex parte hearing, costs 103 K

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Parnell v. Viger, 2005 CanLII 8665 (ON C.A.)

 

mj

Sc

 

Equalization and costs secured against home, and house to be sold if man loses.

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Rawlins v. Rawlins, 2006 CanLII 28560 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

8.7

Variation, wife asks 25.7 K and gets 8.7 K 

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Richards v. Burch, 2003 CanLII 2223 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Mutual non harassment order, both charged with assault, charges against wife withdrawn, man signs peace bond, wife gets custody

Mazza

M

Cs

M

F

Barrick v. Barrick, 2006 CanLII 1317 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

8.0

Man goes bankrupt, claims 32 K, imputed to 40 K, Must pay 1 K per month spousal support

Mazza

M

Cs

M

M

Juvatopolos v. Juvatopolos, 2004 CanLII 34843 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ip

 

Man imputed to 50 K, wife underemployed and reduced from receiving 1.4 K to 1.2 K, then enters another relationship and support reduced to $ 400, wife mild

Mazza

M

Cs

M

sr

Reitsma v. Reitsma-Leadsom, 2005 CanLII 47609 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Man convicted of assault and then breach of probation, assault used as a reason for extending spousal support

Pazaratz

M

Cs

sr

F

Damian v. Damian, 2007 CanLII 18021 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

10.6

Divorce action, wife asks 15.2 K and gets 10.6 K

Quinn JW

M

Cs

sr

sr

Blaschuk v. Bridgewater, 2005 CanLII 28787 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

55.0

Man intentionally unemployed imputed to 55 K, wife imputed to 32 K, Man pays $ 800 per month in support, wife mild

Quinn JW

M

Cs

F

M

J.B. v. A.B., 2006 CanLII 12294 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

50.0

Man fired from job imputed to 50 K per year

Quinn JW

M

Cs

sr

M

J.L.C. v. S.B.L., 2006 CanLII 13759 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

46.0

Man accused of being abusive and threatening lawyer and assessor, court orders termination of access and restrictions on motions, 46 K costs

Quinn JW

M

Cs

sr

M

J.L.C. v. S.B.L., 2006 CanLII 13759 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Man accused of being abusive and threatening lawyer and assessor, court orders termination of access and restrictions on motions, 46 K costs

Quinn JW

M

Cs

sr

M

J.L.C. v. S.B.L., 2006 CanLII 13759 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

Sa

 

Unsupervised then a dozen motions on access before trial, supervised, more motions, access denied, must seek leave for more motions, mental illness, 46 K cost penalty wife makes allegations to Childrens Aid

Quinn JW

M

Cs

F

F

Logan v. Logan, 2004 CanLII 195 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

0.5

Interim motion for evidence, wife asks 1.5 K gets 0.5 K costs

Quinn JW

M

Cs

M

M

Plett v. Murphy, 2003 CanLII 2199 (ON S.C.)

mj

Js

 

Summary judgment on mans motion because his settled intention has already been ruled

Quinn JW

M

Cs

sr

sr

Scott v. Jolicoeur, 2005 CanLII 2058 (ON S.C.)

mn

C

 

Man gets 2 counts of contempt for harassment order, suspended sentence, ordered to say something nice about the other party on access

Quinn JW

M

Cs

sr

M

Taylor v. Taylor, 2004 CanLII 42952 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

10.0

10 K compensatory lump sum support, 19 K equalization

Quinn JW

M

Cs

sr

M

Taylor v. Taylor, 2004 CanLII 42952 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

Ro

 

Wife gets 2 restraining orders, man in jail for third breach misses trial, 19 K equalization, 10 K compensatory support

Quinn JW

M

Cs

M

M

Worthington v. Worthington, 2000 CanLII 22469 (ON S.C.)

mj

Sa

 

Supervised access changed to no access

Reilly

M

Cs

sr

sr

Mahood v. Mahood, 2005 CanLII 19841 (ON S.C.)

mj

Sa

 

Man given reasonable supervised access, complains of access denials, support increased

Reilly

M

Cs

M

F

Reid v. Mulder, 2005 CanLII 38108 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Man charged with assault takes peace bond, wife gets custody, wife moves to Fiji

Reilly

M

Cs

M

F

Reid v. Mulder, 2006 CanLII 9981 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

6.4

Divorce action, wife allowed to move to fiji with child, no costs for custody but 6.4 K for financial

Scime

M

Cs

M

F

Butsky-Plekan v. Plekan, 2005 CanLII 11194 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

10.0

10 K lump sum for spousal support arrears

Scime

M

Cs

M

F

Butsky-Plekan v. Plekan, 2005 CanLII 25103 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

75.0

Divorce, wife asks 117 K and gets 75 K, husband asks 306 K

Sheppard

M

Cs

sr

L

Bukvic v. Bukvic, 2007 CanLII 14323 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ep

 

Wife gets exclusive possession of home, non harassment order, interim custody

Sheppard

M

Cs

sr

L

Bukvic v. Bukvic, 2007 CanLII 14323 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Wife gets exclusive possession of home, non harassment order, interim custody

Sills

M

Cs

sr

M

Bolentiru v. Radulescu, 2004 CanLII 34775 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

20.6

Divorce action marriage declared invalid,  wife asks 45.4 K  gets 20.6 K

Sills

M

Cs

sr

M

Bolentiru v. Radulescu, 2004 CanLII 6239 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

27.5

15 K and 12.5 K for damages. Marriage declared invalid

Sills

M

Cs

M

sr

Demetriou v. Demetriou, 2006 CanLII 16364 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

7.0

$ 222 child support and $ 400 spousal support, man claims income of 18 K and is imputed to 25 K and wife makes 16.3 K

Sills

M

Cs

sr

M

Loebsack v. Loebsack, 2004 CanLII 16872 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

5.0

Divorce action, wife gets 5 K costs

Sills

M

Cs

M

M

Roseneck v. Gowling, 2002 CanLII 45128 (ON C.A.)

mn

Ep

 

Wife gets exclusive possession

Steinberg

M

Cs

sr

sr

Edgar v. Sikora, 2004 CanLII 13394 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

1.5

1.5 K costs of interim motion

Steinberg

M

Cs

sr

M

F.(J.) v. C.(V.) (No. 7), 2002 CanLII 46717 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

90.0

Divorce action with 73 day trial, wife asks 290 K and gets 90 K

Steinberg

M

Cs

M

M

Roach v. Kelly, 2003 CanLII 1991 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Man convicted of harassment, wife cuts his access to his child, man beats up wife’s boyfriend and is put in jail, restraining order access to child terminated.

Steinburg

M

Cs

M

M

Roach v. Kelly, 2003 CanLII 1991 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

Sa

 

Supervised access, criminal harassment and assault charges, jailed, access terminated by court order

Taliano

M

Cs

M

M

Chute v. Chute, 2006 CanLII 1915 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

32.0

Man claims 41 K income and is imputed to 73 K, variation denied, drivers license taken away

Taliano

M

Cs

M

sr

Ostap v. Ostap, 2003 CanLII 2193 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

D

 

Lump sum but less than requested. Court overrules separation agreement for default in payments

Taliano

M

Cs

M

sr

Ostap v. Ostap, 2003 CanLII 2193 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

40.0

Man claims 10 K income and is imputed to 50 K

Taliano

M

Cs

M

sr

Ostap v. Ostap, 2003 CanLII 2193 (ON S.C.)

 

mj

L

35.0

Lump sum of 35 K which is less than originally ordered. Court overrules separation agreement

Taliano

M

Cs

M

sr

Vanderzalm v. Vanderzalm, 2003 CanLII 2356 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

78.0

Man claims income of 61 K per year and is imputed to 139 K

Taliano

M

Cs

sr

F

Wiltshire v. Wiltshire, 2005 CanLII 370 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

41.0

41 K lump sum to be paid for arrears of support equalization and costs

Taliano

M

Cs

M

M

Zeoli v. Field, 2003 CanLII 2361 (ON S.C.)

 

mn

Sa

 

False allegations and criminal charges lead to supervised access, custody eventually reversed to father

Taylor

M

Cs

M

M

Martin v. Blanchard, 2007 CanLII 26611 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

15.7

Spousal support 2 day trial, 15.7 K

Turnbull

M

Cs

sr

F

Beal v. Beal, 2005 CanLII 30326 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

22.5

Wife gets 22. 5 K costs for divorce action which is roughly equal to what she owes husband for equalization

Turnbull

M

Cs

sr

F

Beal v. Beal, 2005 CanLII 30326 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

35.0

Man claims his company doesn’t make a profit and is imputed to 35 K, arrears 19 K, wife is unemployed and imputed to 19 K, $ 500 per month spousal support no children

Turnbull

M

Cs

sr

F

Beal v. Beal, 2005 CanLII 30326 (ON S.C.)

mn

Sc

 

Man must designate wife as beneficiary of pension benefits including death benefits

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

M

Hachey v. Hachey, 2007 CanLII 52987 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

3.0

Man claims 70 K income and is imputed to 90 K, wife claims 14 K per year and is imputed to 35 K, 1 K per month spousal support 0.7 K child support, 3 K costs of interim motion

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

M

Hachey v. Hachey, 2007 CanLII 52987 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

20.0

Man claims 70 K income and is imputed to 90 K

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

F

Kloosterman v. Kloosterman, 2006 CanLII 35629 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

2.8

Wife asks 45 K and gets 2.8 K in divorce action

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

F

Kloosterman v. Kloosterman, 2006 CanLII 9601 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ep

 

Wife gets exclusive possession, $ 250 per month spousal support, $ 839 per month child support

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

F

Mitton v. Mitton, 2007 CanLII 4323 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

7.4

Support motion, 7.4 K costs, 4 K retroactive support

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

M

Pasichnyk v. Pasichnyk, 2005 CanLII 30710 (ON S.C.)

mn

Pr

 

Wife gets unstated prejudgment interest on part of equalization

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

M

Pasichnyk v. Pasichnyk, 2005 CanLII 46745 (ON S.C.

mj

Cts

39.0

Divorce action, husband declares bankruptcy, 39 K costs, 30 K is related to support and survives bankruptcy.

Turnbull

M

Cs

sr

M

Perry v. Perry, 2007 CanLII 20982 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

11.0

11 K costs of support variation, 20 K arrears, 10 K s.7 arrears, husband declared bankruptcy, imputed income

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

F

S.D. v. R.D., 2006 CanLII 35978 (ON S.C.)

mj

Sa

 

Man accused of sexually abusing infant daughter first gets supervised access then access is terminated despite passing a lie detector

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

M

Vangroenigen v. Vangroenigen, 2005 CanLII 38896 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

19.0

Man declares 46 K but is imputed to 65 K for not working overtime

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

M

Vangroenigen v. Vangroenigen, 2005 CanLII 38896 (ON S.C.)

mj

L

10.0

10 K lump for final settlement of spousal support, intentionally unemployed due to not working overtime

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

F

Vangroenigen v. Vangroenigen, 2005 CanLII 38896 (ON S.C.)

mn

Sc

 

Mans share of home held as security for support, 10 K lump to settle spousal support, imputed income for not working overtime, man must designate children as beneficiary of life insurance policy

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

M

Young v. Staruck, 2006 CanLII 28111 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

4.1

Child support variation, 4.1 K

Whitten

M

Cs

sr

L

Bukvic v. Bukvic, 2007 CanLII 14323 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

58.0

Man is unemployed imputed vto former 58 K income $ 1650 per month support

Whitten

M

Cs

M

M

Drygala v. Pauli, 2002 CanLII 41868 (ON C.A.)

 

mj

Ip

23.3

Man is intentionally unemployed and has an income imputed to him, he declares 6.7 K and is imputed to 30 K, changed to 16.5 K on appeal

Whitten

M

Cs

M

M

Drygala v. Pauli, 2003 CanLII 48241 (ON C.A.)

 

mj

Cts

15.0

15 K costs of trial and 9.5 K costs of appeal, and 1.5 K costs of stay motion, all to be enforced by FRO, 6 K security for appeal

Whitten

M

Cs

M

M

Grant v. Stemmler, 2006 CanLII 9972 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

4.0

Interim motion 4 K costs

Whitten

M

Cs

F

M

Shamblaw v. Anger, 2005 CanLII 44380 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

1.0

Support determination 1 K costs

Whitten

M

Cs

M

M

Taylor v. Taylor, 2002 CanLII 44981 (ON C.A.)

 

mj

Cts

10.3

10.3 K costs 69 K arrears, 274 K equalization payment, upheld on appeal , 22.5 K costs of appeal

Whitten

M

Cs

M

M

Taylor v. Taylor, 2002 CanLII 41990 (ON C.A.)

mj

Pr

 

Prejudgment interest on 274 K equalization payment, upheld on appeal, 22.5 K costs of appeal

Whitten

M

Cs

M

M

Weismiller v. Jolkowski, 2000 CanLII 22518 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ip

7.8

Man imputed 7.8 K, 10 % of income for history of bonuses

 

 

 

 

2)   Penalties Against Women

 

 

 

Millanetti

F

Cs

M

sr

S.D. v. T.D., 2005 CanLII 23681 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

Restraining order, pleadings struck, ex parte motion, supervised access

Tucker

F

Cs

sr

M

Armstrong v. Armstrong, 2004 CanLII 12100 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ro

 

Restraining order against man changed to mutual restraining order, access restored, contact at access allowed, retroactive lump sum for support, imputed income

Tucker

F

Cs

M

F

St. Louis v. St. Louis, 2007 CanLII 11730 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

10.0

Divorce action, husband seeks 21 K gets 10 K

Cavarzan

M

Cs

M

M

Belanger v. Belanger, 2005 CanLII 30867 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

9.5

9.5 K costs of support variation against wife, husband has custody

Cavarzan

M

Cs

M

M

Collins v. Trimble, 2005 CanLII 25109 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ro

 

After separation wife charged with assault, man gets custody

Cavarzan

M

Cs

 

 

Kocsis v. Kocsis, 2002 CanLII 2716 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ep

 

Man gets exclusive possession provided he pays 50 K deposit on equalization, wife gets kids and support

Festeryga

M

Cs

M

F

Graham v. Kuntz, 2005 CanLII 44387 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

9.0

Support variation, 9 K costs

Festeryga

M

Cs

M

M

Harrington v. Harrington, 2007 CanLII 27754 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

89.0

Divorce action, husband asks 129 K gets 89 K

Flynn

M

Cs

M

F

Debruyn v. Debruyn, 2005 CanLII 11206 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

9.5

Divorce action, wife gets 9.5 K costs and her lawyer gets 5 K costs and can’t bill wife for trial time

Flynn

M

Cs

F

sr

Duquette v. Gregorio, 2006 CanLII 32615 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

2.4

Motion for expanded access, 2.4 K costs

Flynn

M

Cs

M

M

Miner v. Miner, 2004 CanLII 16229 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

16.0

Husband asks 58 K and gets 16 K in support variation

Flynn

M

Cs

F

M

Munro v. Munro, 2005 CanLII 22142 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

3.0

Interim motion, wife and lawyer don’t attend first motion, 3 K costs to wife, 1 K costs to wifes lawyer

Flynn

M

Cs

M

F

Rossi v. Rossi, 2005 CanLII 47780 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

35.0

3 day trial of support variation, 35 K cost penalty

Flynn

M

Cs

M

sr

S.D. v. T.D., 2005 CanLII 23681 (ON S.C.)

mj

St

 

Wife pleadings struck, uncontested trial, man gets custody, restraining order, 7.5 K costs

Glithero

M

Cs

F

M

Balaban v. Balaban, 2007 CanLII 7990 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

6.4

Husbands motion to terminate support, 6.4 K costs

Glithero

M

Cs

M

M

Cornaz v. Cornaz-Nikyuluw, 2005 CanLII 47770 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

31.0

Hague convention case to return child to husband, husband asks 62 K gets 31 K

Glithero

M

Cs

F

sr

Hoddinott v. Hoddinott, 2002 CanLII 2791 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

13.6

Divorce action 13.6 K costs

Glithero

M

Cs

M

M

Visneskie v. Visneskie, 2003 CanLII 2264 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

45.5

Divorce action, husband asks for 54.5 K and gets 45.5  K

Gordon  D

M

Cs

M

M

Takis v. Takis, 2003 CanLII 2256 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

32.0

Divorce action, husband asks 64 K and gets 32 K

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Lindahl v. Lindahl, 2005 CanLII 34583 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ro

 

Mutual non harassment order, children live in home man and wife switch each week, wife moves to US and court allows her mobility while she has children

Gordon D

M

Cs

M

M

O'Brien v. O'Brien, 2006 CanLII 32637 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

32.0

Interim motions, wife claims 115 K paid to lawyers, husband claims 60 K, 32 K costs

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Picollo v. Picollo, 2004 CanLII 50314 (ON S.C.)

mn

F

 

Mutual non depletion and harassment order, wife gets support

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Picollo v. Picollo, 2004 CanLII 50314 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ro

 

Neither oppose mutual non harassment and non depletion orders, older sons live with man, no custody or child support order, 3.2 K per month spousal support to wife

Gordon D

M

Cs

Sr

M

Purves v. Purves, 2004 CanLII 6249 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ro

 

Mutual restraining order, wife gets custody, fathers income imputed from 18 to 25 K per year

Gordon D

M

Cs

L

L

Scodras v. Scodras, 2005 CanLII 14146 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ip

45.0

Wife imputed to 42 K. Man has custody but pays wife $ 185 per month total support, minor

Gordon D

M

Cs

M

M

Scodras v. Scodras, 2005 CanLII 19785 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

3.0

Interim motion, 3 K costs

Gordon D

M

Cs

M

M

Stockie v. Stockie, 2003 CanLII 2352 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

2.0

Interim motion, 2 K costs

Hambly

M

Cs

 

 

Balaban v. Balaban, 2004 CanLII 47801 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ip

8.4

Wife imputed 8.4 K rental income, wife recieves 1.5 K per month support

Hambly

M

Cs

M

F

Bjornson v. Creighton, 2007 CanLII 14321 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

 

Interim motion, 1.5 K costs

Hambly

M

Cs

M

sr

Girard v. Girard, 2007 CanLII 28740 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

0.1

Interim access motion not needed, costs to husband $ 100

Hambly

M

Cs

M

sr

Hockey-Sweeney v. Sweeney, 2002 CanLII 2721 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

200.0

Divorce action, wife acts unreasonably, 200 K costs asnd 15 K costs of appeal, husband gets custody and must pay 5 K per month spousal support

Hambly

M

Cs

F

M

Tucker v. Tucker, 2002 CanLII 2761 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

5.2

Motion to vary support, 5.2 K costs

Harris

M

Cs

sr

M

Montemurro v. Shavalier, 2003 CanLII 43349 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

1.5

Interim motion, wifes lawyer doesn’t respond, 1.5 K costs

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Parnell v. Viger, 2004 CanLII 27183 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ep

 

Man uses false information to get exclusive possession at ex parte hearing, costs 103 K

Matheson

M

Cs

M

M

Richards v. Burch, 2003 CanLII 2223 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ro

 

Mutual non harassment order, both charged with assault, charges against wife withdrawn, man signs peace bond, wife gets custody

Mazza

M

Cs

M

M

Juvatopolos v. Juvatopolos, 2004 CanLII 34843 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ip

 

Man imputed to 50 K, wife underemployed and reduced from receiving 1.4 K to 1.2 K, then enters another relationship and support reduced to $ 400, wife mild

Mazza

M

Cs

F

M

Raguckas v. Raguckas, 2007 CanLII 2360 (ON S.C.)

mj

Cts

40.7

Divorce action, 40.7 K

Quinn JW

M

Cs

M

sr

Coletta v. Jones Coletta, 2003 CanLII 2412 (ON S.C.)

mj

C

 

Woman gets 30 days jail for selling farm her husband lived on, must pay the 22 K withheld to husband

Quinn JW

M

Cs

sr

sr

Blaschuk v. Bridgewater, 2005 CanLII 28787 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ip

32.0

Man intentionally unemployed imputed to 55 K, wife imputed to 32 K, Man pays $ 800 per month in support, wife mild

Quinn JW

M

Cs

M

sr

Coletta v. Jones Coletta, 2003 CanLII 2412 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

2.5

2.5 K costs for contempt motion

Quinn JW

M

Cs

M

F

Kassay v. Kassay, 2000 CanLII 22444 (ON S.C.)

mn

C

 

Wife found in contempt for denial of access, no consequences this time but jail if it happens again

Quinn JW

M

Cs

M

M

Riss v. Greenough, 2003 CanLII 2224 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

5.3

5.3 K for 2 motions

Taliano

M

Cs

M

F

Calvert v. Calvert, 2002 CanLII 2706 (ON S.C.)

mn

Ep

 

Man gets exclusive possession, he must pay wife $ 500 per month spousal support

Turnbull

M

Cs

sr

F

Beal v. Beal, 2005 CanLII 30326 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

19.0

Man claims his company doesn’t make a profit and is imputed to 35 K, arrears 19 K, wife is unemployed and imputed to 19 K, $ 500 per month spousal support no children

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

L

Bolduc v. Bolduc, 2006 CanLII 35976 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

15.0

Trial, husband claims 25 K gets 15 K

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

sr

Mizzau v. Barnes, 2006 CanLII 21596 (ON S.C.)

mj

Ip

6.0

Wife declares a 24 K income and is imputed to 30 K and must pay child support, some recission of arrears for period of unemployment

Turnbull

M

Cs

M

M

Smith v. Smith, 2007 CanLII 8024 (ON S.C.)

mn

Cts

0.8

Interim motion, 0.8 K costs