Ottawa Men's Centre

 

Peter Roscoe's Research

 

                             Gender Bias in Family Law at the

                 Court of Appeal Ontario 2007

 

 

 

     

      Peter Karl Roscoe

 

    Apr 2006, Revised Sept 2007

 

 

 

 

Appendix B

 

 

 

Legend

 

 

 

Grounds                        (W) = Win            C = Custody             M = Mobility            CS = Child Support

of Appeal

 or Cross                        (L) = Lose            A = Access                O = Other                  SS = Spousal Support

  Appeal

                                                                   EQ = Equalization         

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B1 — Pre 1996 Cases

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

M v m

(w)

1992

Montgomery v. Montgomery (October 30)

   M

 (L)  A

 

 

(w)

1993

Elik v. Elik (February 2)

   M

 (L) CS, O

(W) SS

M v m

(w)

1993

Macedo v. Macedo (April 29)

   M

  (L) CS,O

 

M v m

nc

1994

Veneziale v. Veneziale (April 21)

   M

 (W) EQ    (L) CS

 

F v m

nc

1994

Wunsche v. Wunsche (April 25)

   M

 (W) EQ

 

M v m

nc

1994

Gleich v Kunde (March 25)

   M

 (W) SS, O    (L) CS

 

 

(w)

1995

MacGyver v. Richards (March 23)

   M

(L) M

 

M v m

(w) 4000

1993

Rumanek v. Rumanek (November 15)

   W

 (W) CS

 

M (f)v sr

nc

1994

Barakat v. Barakat (February 11)

   W

 (L) O

 

M v f

(m)

1994

Lougheed v. Sillett (June 30)

   W

 (L) C

(L) O

F  v m (m)

nc

1995

Mabraidopoulos v Mabraidopoulos (March 15)

  W

  (W) O

  (L) A, O

M v m

nc

1995

Lutz v. Lutz (March 30)

  W

(W) CS, EQ

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B2 — 1996 Cases

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

M v m

nc

1996

Balogh v Balogh (November 20)

   M

 (W) SS,EQ, O  (L) SS

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Boa v Boa (Novemeber 18)

   M

(L) EQ

 

 

(w)

1996

Boers v. Boers (December 3)

   M

 (L) SS,EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Campbell v. Campbell (February 15)

   M

 (L) CS, SS 

 

F v f

nc

1996

Cherry v Cherry (September 12)

   M

  (W) O

 

M v m

(w) 2500

1996

Duma v. Mathews (December 4)

   M

 (L) O

 

 

 

1996

Filipich v. Filipich (September 10)

   M

 (L) CS

 

M v m

nc

1996

Huisman v Huisman (June 14)

   M

 (W) SS,EQ

 

M v m

(w) 3000

1996

Jacobs v. Jacobs (February 23)

   M

 (L) O

 

M v m

nc

1996

Kennedy v. Kennedy (November 23)

   M

(W) EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1996

La Russo v La Russo (October 18)

   M

(L) M

 

 

(w)

1996

Maule-Ffinch v. Maule-Ffinch (May 7)

   M

 (L) SS, EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Meiorin v. Meiorin (January 17)

   M

 (L) CS, O

 

M v m

(w) 7000

1996

Merklinger v Merklinger (November 20)

   M

 (L)CS, SS, EQ

 

 

 

1996

Pollack v Pollack (May 7)

   M

(L) SS

 

 

nc

1996

Punzo v. Punzo (March 4)

   M

 (L) A

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Rozyle v. Rozyle (April 11)

   M

(L) EQ

 

 

 

1996

Taylor v. McWhirter (December 2)

   M

 (L) A

 

M v m

nc

1996

Williams v. Ellul (February 2)

   M

.(L) A

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Woodcock v. Woodcock (September 10)

   M

 (L) CS, SS

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Woodman v. Deremo (July 23)

  M

 (L) SS, EQ

 

F v m

(w) 6000

1996

Hamilton v Hamilton (July 23)

  M

(W)EQ  (L)CS, SS, EQ, O

 

Sr v M

(w)

1996

Maurici v. Maurici (August 9)

   W

(W) CS, EQ

 

 

nc

1996

Shefsky v. Shefsky (September 11)

   W

 (W) CS, SS

 

M v m

(w) 2500

1996

Kostello v Kostello (December 4)

   W

(W) O

 

 

nc

1996

Adams v Adams (November 19)

   W

(W) O

 

F v m

(w)

1996

Purcel v Purcel (June 28)

   W

  (W) SS       (L) O

 

M v m

(m)

1996

Nicholas v. Nicholas (June 13)

   W

(L) O

 

 

nc

1996

Benson v Krein (July 9)

  W

  (W) EQ

 (W) CS

M v m

(w)

1996

Keeping v Pacey (June 24)

   W

  (W) A

 

 

Appendix B3 — 1997 Cases

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

F v m

(m)

1997

Munro v. Munro (October 17)

   M

 (W) SS

 

F v m

(w)

1997

Politi v Politi (April 18)

   M

 (L) CS, EQ, O

 

 

 

1997

Layzell v. Layzell (December 8)

   M

 (L) C

 

M v f

(w)

1997

Best v. Best (October 3)

   M

 (L) SS, EQ, O

 

F v m

(w)

1997

Rarie v Rarie

   M

(W) EQ

 

F v f

(w)

1997

Therrien – Clichι v Clichι (April 1)

   M

 (L) O

 

F v f

nc

1997

Davidson v Davidson (March 4)

   M

 (W) EQ

(W) CS

M v m

(m)

1997

Van Bork v Van Bork (June 27)

   M

(W) EQ   (L) SS, O

 

F v m

(w)

1997

Tureck v. Tureck (November 9)

  M

(L) O

 

M v f

(w)

1997

Forler v Forler (April 7)

   W

(W) SS

 

M v f

(m)

1997

Roach v Roach (December 12)

   W

 (L) EQ, O

 

M v m

nc

1997

Crawford v Crawford

   W

(L) SS, EQ

 

M v f

(w)

1997

Forler v Forler (April 7)

   W

(W) SS

 

M v m

nc

1997

Sagoo v Sagoo (March 18)

   W

 (W) O

 

 

(w)

1997

Halliday v Halliday (December 24)

   W

(W)SS, O,   (L)EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1997

Trewin v Jones (February 7)

   W

  (W) SS

 

M v m

(m)

1997

Ligate v Richardson ( Jan 27)

  W

 (W) M

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B4 — 1998 Cases

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

F v m

(w)

1998

Daoust v Leboeuf (January 14)

   M

 (L) C

(W)CS, O  (L)SS

M v m

(w)

1998

Francis v. Baker (March 10)

   M

 (L) CS, SS, O

 

F v m

(w)

1998

McCallum v McCallum (March 23)

   M

(W) O

 

M v m

(w)

1998

Valenti v. Valenti (May 22)

  M

(L) CS, SS, EQ, O

 

M v m

(w)

1998

Luckhurst v Luckhurst (June 4)

   M

 (L) M

 

Sr v m (m)

nc

1998

Melzack v. Germain (June 9)

  M

(L) CS

 

M v m

nc

1998

Brooks v. Brooks (June 25)

  M

(W) O

 

F v m

(w)

1998

Choquette v. Choquette (July 28)

   M

 (L) SS

 

 

(w) 5000

1998

Irwin v. Irwin (September 10)

   M

 (L) C, A

 

M v m

(w)

1998

Trotter v Trotter (October 29)

   M

 (L) EQ

 

 

(w)

1998

Cole v Cole (November 10)

   M

(L) EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1998

Rachiele v. Rachiele (December 1)

  M

(L) EQ

 

F v m (f)

nc

1998

Pivacet v Paul (Mach 13)

   W

(W) O      (L) SS

 

M v m

(w) 1500

1998

Burnett v Burnett (March 12)

   W

  (L) O

 

 

nc

1998

Walsh v. Walsh (July 20)

   W

 (L) C

 

F v f

(m)

1998

Follows v Follows (September 10)

   W

  (L) O

 

M v f (w)

(m)

1998

Appleyard v Appleyard (September 14)

   W

(W) EQ

 

M v m

(m)

1998

Debora v Debora (October 22)

   W

(L) EQ

 

F v m

nc

1998

Wood v Robertson (November 9)

   W

(W) O     (L) EQ

(L) O

F v f

 

1998

Pollastro v Pollastro (November 16)

   W

(W) M

 

F v m

(w)

1998

Bezanson v Falle (December 23)

   W

 (W) CS O

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B5 — 1999 Cases

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

M v m

(w)

1999

Mozzarello v Mazzarello (January 21)

M

(L) EQ

 

M v f

def

1999

Murphy v Murphy (January 29)

M

(W) EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1999

Pope v. Pope (February 3)

M

 (L) SS, EQ

 

F v m (m)

nc

1999

Gerstner v Borg (February 10)

M

 (W) O

 

M v m

(w)

1999

Chinneck v Chinneck (February 12)

 M

 (L)EQ, O

 

F v m

(w)

1999

Swanson v Swanson (February 16)

M

 (W) O

 

F v m

(w)

1999

Appiah v Appiah (February 22)

M

  (L) C, M

 

Sr v sr

nc

1999

Likeda v Jarrel (March 15)

M

(L) A

 

 

(w)

1999

Merikallio v. Merikallio (March 22)

M

 (L) CS

 

M v m

(m)

1999

Nahatchewitz v Natatchewitz (May 27)

M

(W) EQ      (L) O

 

M v m

(w)

1999

Dunlop v Dunlop (May 27)

M

(L) O

 

 

(m)

1999

Leopold v Leopold (June 14)

M

(W) SS

 

F v sr

(w)

1999

Bennet v Bennet (June 16)

 M

(L) O

 

M v m

(w)

1999

Losereit v Losereit (June 21)

M

  (W) SS

 

F v f

nc

1999

Doe v Doe (June 29)

M

(W) SS

 

Sr v m (m)

nc

1999

Lee v. Lee (August 5)

M

 (L) CS

 

M v f

(w) 4000

1999

Shortman v Shortman (Aug 6)

M

(L) SS EQ O

 

M v m

nc

1999

Vandepas v. Stephens (September 2)

M

(L) SS, CS

(L) SS, CS

M v m

(m)

1999

Sefton v Brasg (September 11) 

M

 (W) CS

 

F v m

(w)

1999

Andrews v. Andrews (September 29)

 M

 (L) CS, SS

 

F v f

 

1999

Finizio v Scoppio – Finizio (September 29)

M

 (W) M

 

 

 

1999

Irmie v Irmie (October 18)

M

 (W) SS

 

M v m

(w)

1999

Davids v Davids (October 22)

M

 (L) CS, SS, O

 

M v f

 

1999

Denis v Wilson (November 6)

M

  (W) CS

 

F v m

(w)

1999

Bogue v Bogue (November 16)

M

 (L) SS, O

 

Sr v m (m)

nc

1999

Kincartz v Kincartz

W

(W) SS

 

 M v m

(w) 2000 c

1999

Kardish v Kardish (Mar 1 1999)

W

(W) O

 

M v m

(w)

1999

 Bildy v Bildy (February 22)

W

  (W) CS, SS

 

F v m

(w)

1999

Pollastro v Pollastro (February 25)

 W

(W) C

 

Sr v m

(w)

1999

Gordon v Gordon (March 9)

W

(W) SS

 

F v sr

(w)

1999

Munn v Munn (March 11)

W

(W) CS, SS

 

 

(w)

1999

Babij v Babij (March 19)

 W

 (W) SS, EQ, O

 

M v M

nc

1999

McCord v Holek (March 26)

W

 (W) C, A

 

M v m

(w)

1999

Sherman v. Sherman (April 16)

W

 (W) CS, SS

 

M v m

(m)

1999

Brett v Brett (April 28)

W

  (L) CS, EQ, O

 

M v m

(w)

1999

Grundl v Lehner (May 6)

W

(L) O

(L) O

M v m

(m) 3500

1999

Brans v Brans (May 14)

   W

 (L) CS, O

 

M v m

nc

1999

Circelli v Circelli (May 19)

   W

 (W) C

 

M v m

(m) 1500

1999

Kraft v Kraft (June 7)

   W

 (W) EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1999

Miller v. Miller (June 9)

  W

(W) C

 

Sr v sr

nc

1999

Tremblay v Tremblay (July 6)

   W

(W) SS

 

 

(w) 2000

1999

Otterbein v Otterbein (Aug 6)

  W

(W) SS

 

M v m

(w)

1999

Novosel Novosel (September 21)

  W

(W) EQ

 

M v sr

(w)

1999

Teeple v Teeple (September 24)

  W

(W) SS

 

M v m

(m)

1999

Cole v Martin (September 30)

  W

(L) O

 

M v f

nc

1999

Giles v Villeneuve (October 5)

  W

  (L) CS

 

F v f

nc

1999

Rechsteiner v Kendall (October 25)

  W

 (W) M

 

F v m

(w)

1999

Hall v. Hall (October 28)

  W

 (W) SS   (L) CS

(L) O

M v f

(w) 1500

1999

Boston v Boston (November 3)

  W

(W) SS

 

M v m

(w)

1999

Simon v Simon (December 1)

  W

  (W) CS, SS, O

 

M v m

(m)

1999

Behrens v Stoodly (December 17)

  W

(L) SS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B6 — 2000 Cases

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

F v m

(w) 6000

2000

Leavoy v Leavoy (September 13)

  M

(L) O

 

F v m

(w)

2000

Tauber v Tauber (June 12)

  M

 (W) CS   (L) C, O

(W) SS, O

F v m (m)

nc

2000

Bates v Bates (June 19)

  M

(W) CS

 

F v m (m)

nc

2000

Nasser v Mayer Nasser (February 29)

  M

  (L) EQ

  (L) EQ

M v m

(w) 10000

2000

Johnson v Johnson (March 15)

  M

(L) O

(L) O

M v m

(w)

2000

Yackobeck v Hartwig (Aug 17)

M

(L) SS, EQ

 

M v m

nc

2000

Wasney v Wasney (April 27)

M

 (W) CS

 

M v m

(w) 3500

2000

Davignon v Davignon (February 25)

M

 (W) SS

 

M v m

 

2000

Krisko v Krisko (October 26)

  M

  (L) O

 

M v sr

(w)

2000

Lachapelle v. Lachapelle (November 15)

   M

. (L) C, CS, EQ, O

 

Sr v sr

nc

2000

Wheeler v Wheeler (December 20)

M

  (W) CS    (L) CS

 

M v m

(w)

2000

Lay v Lay ( Mar 17)

 W

(W) EQ

 

M v m

 

2000

Rhys – Jones v Rhys – Jones (April 20)

 W

(W) SS

 

M v m

(m) 11000

2000

Baldwin v Funston (May 3)

W

(L) SS

 

M v m

nc

2000

Rothgiesser v Rothgiesser (January 12)

W

 (W) SS

 

F (m) v m

nc

2000

Radcliffe v Radcliffe (June 2)

W

(L) SS

 

M (f) v sr

 

2000

Hurwitz v Barber (May 9)

W

  (L) A, O

(L) O

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B7 — 2001Cases

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

M v sr

(w) 4000

2001

Aristocrat v. Aristocrat (July 3)

  M

(L) O

 

F v m

(w)

2001

Manis v Manis (September 18)

   M

 (L) O

 

M v m

(w)

2001

Miglin v. Miglin (April 26)

   M

 (L) A, SS

(w) SS

M v m

(w)

2001

Milla v Milla (Mar 19)

   M

(L) O

 

F v m

(w) 3000

2001

Miranda v. Bossio (June 18)

   M

 (L) SS

 

M v m

(w)

2001

Stone v Stone (August 10)

  M

(L) EQ, O

 

M v m

(m)

2001

Wamsley v Wamsley (February 14)

  M

(W) EQ

 

M v m

nc

2001

Wreggitt v Belanger (December 10)

  M

 (W) A    (L) C

 

F v m

(w)

2001

Scanlon v Standish (Oct 12)

  M

(L) EQ

 

F v m (m)

nc

2001

Cole v Kew (Mar 6)

  M

 (L) C

 (L) EQ

M v m

(w)

2001

Coathup v Coathup (May 18)

   M

 (L) O

 

F v m

(m)

2001

Chertow v Chertow (May 10)

   M

(L) O

 

F v f

(w)

2001

Marson v. Marson (May 15)

   M

 (L) CS, O

 

M v m

(w)

2001

Stanghi v. Stanghi (May 24)

   M

 (L) CS, SS

 

F v m

(w)

2001

Bolt v Bolt (April 4)

   M

(L) O

(W) O

M v m

(w) 1000

2001

Hagen v Hagen (February 5)

   M

(L) O

 

F v m

(w)

2001

Lamarche v Crevier (November 9)

   M

(W)EQ   (L)CS, SS

 

M v m

nc

2001

Arvai v Arvai (February 20)

  M

 (W) EQ      (L( SS)

 

 

(w)

2001

Palombi v Palombi (March 19)

  M

 (L) CS, SS

 

F vm

(w) 17680

2001

Jones v Jones (Aug 16)

M

(L) EQ

 

M v m

(w)

2001

Birce v Birce ( October 10)

M

  (L) EQ, O

 

F vm

(w)

2001

Meiklejohn v Meiklejohn (October 10)

M

 (L) SS, EQ

 

M v m

(w)

2001

Adams v Adams (April 30)

  M

(W) O     (L)CS, SS, EQ

 

F v m

(w)

2001

Hauer v. Hauer (December 19)

 M

(L) SS

 

M v m

(w)

2001

Hutchinson v Hutchinson ( January 15)

 W

(W) EQ

 

M v m

(w)

2001

Scheel v Henkleman (January 16)

W

 (W) SS

 

F v m (m)

nc

2001

Maurici v Maurici (February 20)

W

 (W) SS    (L) EQ

 (L) SS

M v f

(m)

2001

Katsigiannis v Kottick Katsigiannis (April 3)

W

 (L) C

 

M v m

(m)

2001

Rosien v. McCulloch (May 8)

 W

.(L) O

 

F v m (m)

nc

2001

Ursano v Rochon (May 31)

W

 (L) C

 

M v m

(w)

2001

Difrancesco v Coutu (September 4)

W

(W) CS

 

M v m

nc

2001

Leeson v Leeson (September 24)

 W

(L) SS

 

M v f

(w)

2001

Maharaj v Maharaj (October 4)

W

  (W) O

 

F v m

(w)

2001

Cho v Cho (October 5)

W

 (W) CS

 

F v f

nc

2001

Wolf v Wales (December 13)

W

 (L) M

 

M v m

(w)

2001

Arnold v Washburn (December 19)

W

  (W) CS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B8 — 2002 Cases

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

M v m

 

2002

Drygala v Pauli (   )

M

(W) CS       (L) CS

 

M v m

nc

2002

Scott v. McKinley ( January 16)

M

(W) A

 

M v m

(w)

2002

Brown v Brown (February 27 )

M

 (W) O   (L) C, A, CS, SS, EQ

(W) CS

M v f

(w) 10000

2002

JS v TB (February 27)

M

(L) M

 

F v m

(w)

2002

Wright v Zavier (March 26)

M

 (L) CS

 

M v m

nc

2002

Kopaniak v McLellan (April 29)

M

  (W) O

  (L) CS

M v m

(w) 4500

2002

Sleiman v. Sleiman (May 7)

   M

 (W) O

 

M v m

(w) 6411

2002

Ball v Ball (May 7 )

   M

(L) O

 

 

 

2002

Slieman v Slieman (May 14)

   M

 (W) O

 

M v m

(w) 9000

2002

Klerides v Klerides (May 30)

M

 (W) CS, SS    (L) EQ

 

M v m

nc

2002

Hooper v Hooper (May 31)

M

 (W) O    (L) CS

 

F v f

(w) 3000

2002

Boucher v Boucher (June 9)

   M

(L) O

 

M v m

(w) 2500 c

2002

Collier v Tobar (June 19 )

M

(L) EQ

 

M v m

(w) 12000

2002

Sodhi v. Sodhi (June 19)

   M

  (L) CS, SS

(W) M

F v m

(w) 5000

2002

Kazdan v Kazdan (June 24)

M

  (L) M

 

M v m

(w) 22500

2002

Taylor v Taylor (July 8) 

   M

 (W) O

(W) CS

F v m

nc

2002

Louie v Lastman (September 17)

M

  (W) CS

 

M v f

nc

2002

Eager v Graves (October 15)

M

 (W) CS

 

M v m

(w) 4000

2002

Tennant v Tennant (November 15)

M

 (W) O       (L) O

 

M v m

(w) 24000

2002

Roseneck v Gowling (December 24)

   M

 (W) O

(L) SS

M v m

(w) 4500

2002

Scherer v Scherer (February 18)

   W

 (W) O

 

M v f

(w) 20000

2002

Johnson v Cleroux (February 25)

W

 (W) M, O

(L) C

M v m

(m) 4000

2002

Wright v Wright (February 28)

W

(L) O

 

F v m

nc

2002

Parks v. Barnes (March 7)

 W

 (W) C

 

M v m

(w)

2002

R v R (March 25)

W

  (W) CS

 

F v m

(w)

2002

Chan v Lam (March 26)

 W

 (W) EQ, O

 

F v sr

nc

2002

Turner v Viau (April 8)

W

 (L) O

 

Sr v sr

(m) 7500

2002

Goldenberg v. Wolf (May 22)

 W

 (L) C

 

M v m

(m) 7500

2002

Latcham v Latcham (May 29)

 W

 (L) O

 

M v m

(w) 4000

2002

Rushinko v Rushinko (June 21)

 W

  (W) M

 

M v m

(m)

2002

Butler v Kronby (July 3)

W

 (L) SS

 

M v m

(w) 2500

2002

Collier v Tobar (July 25)

W

  (W) EQ

 

M v m

(w) 10000

2002

Desramaux v Desramaux (August 28)

 W

 (W)SS       (L) CS

 

 

 

2002

Bjornson v Creighton (November 19)

 W

 (L) M

(L) C

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B9 — 2003 Cases

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

M v m

(w) 9500

2003

Drygala v Pauli (January 5)

M

(L) O

 

M v m

(m) 2500

2003

Sangster v. Sangster (January 15)

 M

 (W) O

 

M v m

(w) 150000

2003

Bosanc v. Bosanc (March 27)

 M

 (L) SS, EQ, O

 

 

 

2003

Allaire v. Allaire (March 28)

 M

 (W) CS      (L) SS

 

F v m

(w)

2003

Tauber v. Tauber (March 31)

 M

 (L) SS

 

M v m

(w) 12000

2003

Noble v Noble(April 2)

 M

(L) O

 

 

 

2003

Letkie v Letkie (April 6)

M

(W) EQ     (L) O

 

M v f

(m) 3000

2003

Wylie v Leclair (May 21)

M

 (W) O    (L) CS

 (W) O

 

(w) 6500

2003

Theodore V Parsons (May 21)

M

(L) O

 

F v m

(m) 5000

2003

Sabourin v Young (June 10) 

 M

 (W) M

 

F v m

(w) 6200

2003

Ballentine v Ballentine (June 27)

 M

 (L) SS, O

 

M v f

(w) 3000

2003

Durocher v Lauzon (July 7)

M

(W) SS   (L) A, O

 

F v m

(w) 35000

2003

Marinangeli v Marinangeli (July 11)

 M

 (W) CS    (L) CS, SS

 

F v m

(w) 12000

2003

Singer v Davilia – Singer (August 19)

M

 (L) M

 

M v m

(w) 5000

2003

Vandewal v. Vandewal (August 26)

M

(L) O

 

M v sr

nc

2003

McGeachy v. McGeachy (September 5)

 M

 (W) CS

(L) SS

M v m

(w) 15000

2003

Riel v Holland (October 8)

M

 (L) SS, CS, O

(L) SS

F v sr

nc

2003

Cada v Cada (October 9)

M

 (L) O

 

 

nc

2003

Contino v Leonelli – Contino (October 28)

 M

 (W) CS

(W) CS

M v m

(w) 10000

2003

Ernyes v Rachlin (November 6)

  M

  (L) CS

 

M v m

(w) 5000

2003

Macleod v Macleod (November 12)

 M

(L) EQ

 

M v m

nc

2003

Cox v. Down Stephen (November 20)

 M

 (L) C, A

 

F v m(m)

nc

2003

K(MS) v T(TL) (February)

 W

 (W) O

 

F v m

(w) 15000

2003

Eccles v Eccles (January 20)

W

(W) CS, O

 

M v F

(w) 15000

2003

Farrar v. Farrar (January 27)

 W

 (W) SS, EQ, O

 

M v m

(w) 11750

2003

Gabel v Gabel ( March 20)

W

 (W) SS, O

 

F v m

(w) 7000

2003

Hillmond v Letchford (March 25)

 W

(W) O

 

F v m

(w)

2003

Jabbaz v Mouammar (May 5)

W

 (W) M

 

 

(m) 500

2003

Toor v Toor (August 26)

W

 (L) O

 

F v f

(m) 1000

2003

Eintoss v Starkman (September 3)

 W

  (L) O

 

F v m

(m) 5000

2003

Ruster v Ruster (September 11)

W

(L) EQ

 

M (m)v sr

nc

2003

Vandenelsen v Merkley (September 15)

W

(L) O

 

F (m) v m

 

2003

CAM v DM (September 23)

W

 (W) A

 

M v f

(w) 10000

2003

Sydor v Sydor (October 2)

W

 (W) EQ

 

M v sr

nc

2003

Palmer v Palmer (November 12)

W

(W) SS

 

M v f (m)

nc

2003

Bell v Cormier (November 21)

W

 (W) O

 

M v sr

(m) 2500

2003

Racine v Racine (December 5)

  W

 (W) EQ

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B10 — 2004 Cases

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

F v f

(w) 4500

2004

Babchishin v Nicholson (January 8)

M

 (L) C

 

M v sr

(w) 3000

2004

Cormier v Boudreau ( January 8

M

 (L) CS, SS, EQ

 

 

 

2004

Hartman v Frantel (January 12)

M

(L) O

 

F v m (m)

nc

2004

Walsh v Walsh (February 2)

M

 (W) SS

 

M v f

(w) 125000

2004

Cade v Rotstein (February 4)

M

 (L) C, M, CS, SS

 

M v m

(w) 12000

2004

Hildinger v Carrol (February 5)

M

(W) A      (L) C

 

F v m

(w) 4500

2004

Dieter v Sampson (March 11)

M

 (L) CS

 

Sr v sr

nc

2004

Felte v Felte (April 14)

M

(L) SS, EQ

 

F v f

(w) 18000

2004

Jardine v Jardine (June 3)

M

 (L) SS, EQ

 

M v m

(w) 12000

2004

Simpkins v Simpkins (June 15)

M

 (L) SS

 

F v m

(w) 4000

2004

Evans v Evans (June 18)

M

(L) O

 

F v sr

(w) 5000

2004

McHugh v McHugh (June 25)

M

 (L) EQ

 

F v m

(w) 8000

2004

Gholizadeh v Shadou (June 29)

M

(L) SS, O

 

F v M

(w) 10000

2004

Roscoe v Roscoe (July 9)

M

 (L) C, A, CS, EQ, O

 

M v m

(w) 5500

2004

Kusnir v Lowry (July 19)

   M

(L) O

 

M v m

(w) 5000

2004

Birmingham v Ferguson (July 21)

   M

(W) EQ   (L) SS, O

 

 

 

2004

Korutowska – Wooff v Wooff (August 4)

   M

 (L) C

 

M v sr

(w) 6000

2004

AEM v JEM (September 10)

  M

  (L) C, A, CS, SS, EQ

 

 

 

2004

KCD v SAF (September 13)

   M

 (L) C

 

F v m

(w) 15000

2004

Beaumont v Beaumont (September 15)

  M

 (L) O

 

M v sr

(w) 4000

2004

Aristocrat v Aristocrat (September 17)

  M

 (L) O

 

 

 

2004

Elliot v Elliot (September 27)

  M

 ( L) SS,   (W) CS

 

F v f

(w) 10000

2004

Trendle v. Trendle (October 24)

  M

(L) EQ, O

 

F v m

(w) 10000

2004

Starr v Starr (November12)

  M

 (L) CS, SS

 

M v sr

(w) 1000

2004

Osovetsky v Osovetsky (November 26)

   M

 (L) CS

 

F v m

(w) 10000

2004

 Mancuso v Mancuso (November 29)

   M

 (L) A, EQ, O

 

F v sr

nc

2004

Brown v Ferguson (November 30)

   M

 (L) CS, SS

 

M v m

(w) 17000

2004

Brophy v Brophy(December 4)

  M

 (L) SS, O

 

M v m

(m) 8794

2004

Marks v Tokarewicz (January 15)

W

 (L) SS

 

F v f

nc

2004

Mancini v Mancini (February 2)

W

 (W) O

 

Sr v sr

nc

2004

Lafreniere v Lafreniere (March 3)

  W

 (L) O

 

 

 

2004

Dabrian v Dabrian (March 8)

  W

  (W) O

 

M v m

nc

2004

Boudreau v Boudreau (April 14)

  W

(L) O

 

M v f (f)

nc

2004

Sladden v Sladden (April 26)

  W

(L) O

 

M v f

(w) 9000

2004

Kelly v Kelly (May 7)

  W

 (W) SS, EQ

 

 

nc

2004

Pipitone v Pipitone (July 7)

  W

  (L) O

 

M v m

(w) 6250

2004

Arella v Scobak (July 15)

  W

 (W) SS

 

M v m

(m) 2500

2004

Miner v Miner (August 13)

  W

 (W) O        (L) CS

 

F v f

(m) 5000

2004

Visneskie v Visneskie (August 23)

  W

 (L) A, SS

 

M v m

nc

2004

Horner v Horner (October 21)

  W

 (W) CS, SS

(W) SS

 

(m) 7500

2004

Danylkiw v Danylkiw (November 2)

  W

  (L) SS, EQ

 

M v m

(m) 15000

2004

Hockey – Sweeny v Sweeny (November 2)

  W

 (W) SS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B11 — 2005 Cases

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

F v m

(w)

2005

Dumyn v Dumyn (Apri 15)

  M

 (L) O

 

M v m

nc

2005

Pirner v Pirnir (January 6)

  M

 (L) CS

(L) SS

M v m

(w) 10000

2005

Greenberg v Daniels (January 17)

  M

 (L) SS

 

Sr v m

(w) 600

2005

Marcus v. Marcus (January 18)

  M

(L) O

 

 

 

2005

Hartman v Hartman (January 19)

  M

(L) O

 

Sr v sr

(w)

2005

Lampron v Lampron (January 20)

 M

 (L) EQ, O

 

M v m

(w) 5000

2005

Campbell v Szoke (January 24)

  M

 (L) SS

 

M v sr

(w) 2000

2005

Kalla v Kalla (February 16)

  M

 (L) CS, EQ, O

 

F (m) v m

nc

2005

Froom v Froom (February 16)

  M

 (W) CS

 

 

(w) 8500

2005

Vaccaro v Vaccaro (February 18)

  M

(L) EQ

 

F v f

(w) 4500

2005

Bremer v Bremer (February 21)

  M

 (W) SS O   (L) SS, EQ

 

M v f

(w) 3500

2005

Sugars v Sugas (March 21)

  M

  (L) CS

 

M v m

(w) 15000

2005

Parnell v Vigor (March 30)

  M

  (L) O

 

M v m

(m)

2005

Archer v Archer (April 22)

  M

  (W) SS

 

F v m

(w) 5000

2005

Chertow v Chertow (April 29)

M

(W) CS

 

M v m

 

2005

Park v Thompson (May 2)

M

 (W) CS

 

M v m

(w) 3000

2005

Cotter v Wasmund (May 13)

   M

 (L) C

 

M (m) v sr

nc

2005

Taylor v Taylor (May 19)

  M

  (W) SS

 

F v m

(w) 20000

2005

Kusnir v Lowry (May 25)

M

(L) SS, EQ, O

 

M v m

(w) 7000

2005

Carew v. Carew (July 4)

  M

(L) CS

 

M v sr

(w) 5000

2005

Garvey v Chiarelli (July5)

   M

 (L) C, A, CS, O

(L) CS

M v m

(w)

2005

Sydor v. Sydor (July 8)

  M

(L) C, CS, SS, EQ

 

 

 

2005

Murray v Murray (August 29)

  M

 (W) SS

 

M v m

(w) 10000

2005

McGouran v Connelly (September 9)

M

(L) CS

(W)CS

F v m (w)

nc

2005

Grifth v Bootsma (September 20)

M

(W) A, CS, O   (L) C

 

F v m

(w) 10000

2005

Krisko v Krisko (September 23)

 M

 (L) A

 

F v f

(w) 7500

2005

Macgergor v Stone (October 12)

  M

 (L) O

 

M v m

nc

2005

Lewi v Lewi (October 25)

  M

 (W) CS     (L) SS

(L) CS

F v m

(w) 5000

2005

Haunert Faga v Faga (October 27)

M

(W) O

 

M v m

(w) 8500

2005

Jahangiri-Mavaneh v. Taheri-Zengekani

  W

(W) O

 

F v m (w)

nc

2005

Goeldner v Goeldner (January 13)

W

(W) SS    (L) O

 

M v m

(m) 8000

2005

Zomparelli v Zomparwlli (January 31)

W

(L) CS, O

 

F v m

(w) 10000

2005

Kaplanis v Kaplanis (January 31)

   W

 (W) C

(L) EQ

F v f

nc

2005

Ladisa v Ladisa (January 31)

   W

 (W)CS,SS    (L) C

 

M v m

(w) 5000

2005

Bhandari v Bhandari (February 9)

  W

 (W) A

 

M v sr

nc

2005

Sharpe v Waterhouse (February 11)

 W

 (W) CS

 

F v m

(w) 12000

2005

 Mackinnon v Mackinnon(April 26)

   W

 (W) CS, SS

 

M v sr

 

2005

Coady v Boyle (May 11)

W

(L) O

 

 

(m) 8000

2005

Zomparelli v Zomparelli (May 12)

   W

 (L) SS, O

 

F v m

(w)

2005

Tierney – Hynes v Hynes (June 28)

W

 (W)  SS

 

F v f

nc

2005

Segal v Segal (July 4)

W

 (W) C, A, O

 

Sr v sr

nc

2005

Montague v Montague (August 30)

  W

 (W) O

 

 

 

2005

McDougal v McDougal (October 7)

   W

(W) SS

 

F v m

(w) 3500

2005

Brentnall v Brentnall (October 24)

  W

 (W) SS

 

 

 

2005

Bubovitch v Bubovitch (October 26)

   W

(W) O

 

F v m

(m) 7500

2005

Pike v Cook (October 26)

W

(L) C

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B12 — 2006 Cases Examined

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

M v m

(w) 70000

2006

Debora v. Debora

  M

(L)SS, EQ    (W) O

(L) O

M v sr

(w) 4000

2006

Stancheff v. Stancheff (January 11)

  M

(L) SS, O

 

 

 

2006

Kukanova v Kukanova (January 10)

  M

(L) SS

 

M v sr

(w) 4500

2006

Pirner v Pirner (January 12)

  M

(L) C

 

M v m

(m)

2006

Griffin v Obrien (January 13)

  M

 (W) O

 

F v m

(m) 15000

2006

Dickie v Dickie (January 13)

  M

 (W) O

 

F v m (m)

nc

2006

Jordan v Jordan (January 17)

  M

 (W) O

 

M v f

(m) 500

2006

Bradley v Bradley (January 30)

  M

(W) O

 

F v f

(w) 3000

2006

Merkand v Merkand (February 8)

  M

 (L) A

 

M v m

(w)

2006

Mergelas v Mergelas (February 17)

  M

 (L) EQ

 

M v F

(w) 25000

2006

Martin v. Martin (February 23)

  M

(L) SS, O

 

M v m

(w) 2500

2006

Tannahill v. Tannahill (February 24)

  M

(L) SS

 

F v sr

(w) 960

2006

Dhanna v Dhanna (March 8)

  M

 (L) O

 

M v f

(m) 6000

2006

Davis v Morris (March 21)

  M

 (W) O

 

F v m (m)

nc

2006

Trick v Trick (March 31)

  M

(W) O   (L)CS, .SS

 

M v m

(w) 5000

2006

Ng v Yam (April 6)

  M

(L) O

 

 

(w) 7500

2006

Caldwell v Caldwell (April 13)

  M

(L) O

 

F v sr

(w) 5567

2006

Cianciusi v Cianciusi ( May 18)

  M

(W) A    (L)

 

F (m) v Sr

nc

2006

Cole v Danylkiw (May 18)

  M

(W) O     (L) C, A

 

M (m) v sr

nc

2006

Dalgleish v Dalgleish (May 30)

  M

 (W) O

 

 

(w) 60000

2006

Lynch v. Segal (June 7)

  M

(L) O

 

F v m

(m) 7500

2006

Bodnar v Blackman (June 14)

  M

(W) CS

 

Sr v m (m)

nc

2006

Brumwell v Brumwell (June 15)

  M

(L) CS

 

M v m

(m) 25000

2006

Ross v Ross (June 16)

  M

(W) EQ

 

F v m (m)

nc

2006

Walters v Walters (June 28)

  M

(W) EQ

 

F v m

(w) 15000

2006

Lawson v. Lawson (July 21

  M

(W) CS, SS, EQ

 

M v m

(w) 35000

2006

Wildman v. Wildman (August 30)

  M

(W) O      (L) SS, EQ

 

M v m

(w) 6042

2006

Desjardins v Bart (September 15)

  M

(L) CS

 

M v m

(m) 20000

2006

Strobele v Strobele (September 20)

  M

(W) EQ

 

 

nc

2006

Armstrong v Armstrong (September 25)

  M

(L) O

 

Sr v sr

nc

2006

Higgins v Higgins (September 26)

  M

(W) SS

 

M v m

(w) 15000

2006

Belittchenko v Belittchenko (September 27)

  M

(L) O

 

M v m

(w) 5500

2006

Cook v Sacco (October 18)

  M

(L) C, CS, SS

 

M (m)v sr

nc

2006

Pitts v Desilva (November 10)

  M

(W) O

 

Sr v sr

nc

2006

Peters v Murray (December 1)

  M

 (L) O

 

M v m

(w) 3500

2006

Shea v Fraser (December 5)

  M

(W) EQ       (L) CS

 

M v f

(w) 4000

2006

Labbe v. Labbe (December 6)

  M

(L) O

 

F v sr

(w) 5000

2006

Abosh v White ( December7)

  M

(L) O

 

F v m

(w) 1000

2006

Beeching v Beeching (December 12)

  M

(L) M

 

M v m

(m) 1500

2006

Demarco v Demarco (December 14)

  M

(W) O

 

F v m

(w) 14000

2006

Warren v Gilbert (December 18)

  M

(W) CS     (L) O

 

F v sr

(w) 10000

2006

Galeana v Dubail (December 21)

  M

 (W) SS

 

F v m (m)

nc

2006

Schnarr v Schnarr (January 9)

  W

(W) O

 

M v m

(m) 6000

2006

Ursic v Ursic (February 6)

  W

(W) CS     (L) C

 

M v m

nc

2006

Kallaba v Bylykashi (February 14)

  W

 (W) O    (L) SS

 

F v m

(w) 2000

2006

Joshi v Joshi (February 22)

  W

 (W) O

 

M v sr

(w) 1000

2006

Sasseville v Sasseville ( Apr4)

  W

(W) SS

 

M v m

(w) 10000

2006

Linett v Linett ( April 5)

  W

 (L) O

 

F v m

(w) 2000

2006

Rogerson v Tessaro (April 28)

   W

(L) C

 

M v sr

(w) 10000

2006

Roy v Roy (May 8)

  W

(W) C       (L) A

 

M v m

nc

2006

Jones v Jones (July 18)

   W

(L) O

 

M v m

 

2006

Dubourdieu v Dubourdieu (July 20)

   W

(W) CS, SS, EQ

 

 

 

2006

Mouldry v Mouldry (September 8)

W

(W) C, O

 

M v m

(m) 10000

2006

Wong v Wong (September 13)

   W

(L) O

 

F v f

(w)

2006

Ierullo v Ierullo (September 20)

  W

 (W) SS

 

M v m

(m) 4000

2006

Lapkin v Lapkin (September 25)

W

(L) O

 

M v f

(m) 10000

2006

Raaymakers v. Green (November 16)

  W

(W) O        (L) SS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B13 — 2007 Cases

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

F v m

(w) 5000

2007

Neil v Boudreau (January 17)

M

(L) CS, SS

 

F v m

(w) 8000

2007

Marchese v Marchese (January 18)

M

 (L) O

 

F v m

(w) 3000

2007

Morin v Muir (February 2)

M

(L) C, CS, O

 

 

 

2007

Siros v Siros (February 2)

M

(W)EQ   (L)CS, SS

 

F v f

(w) 3500

2007

Reid v Saliba (February 7)

M

 (L) EQ

 

M v f

(w) 6000

2007

Jackson v Graczyk (February 9)

M

 (L) CS

 

F v m

(w) 15000

2007

Bishop v. Bishop (March 13)

M

(L) O

 

F v m (m)

nc

2007

Okmyansky v Okmyansky (March 16)

M

(W) SS     (L) O

 

M v sr

(w) 5000

2007

Singha v. Singh (March 16)

M

(W) SS     (L) EQ, O

 

Sr v sr

nc

2007

McGoey v McGoey (March 19)

M

(W) SS

 

F v m (f)

nc

2007

Somerville v Somerville (March 26)

M

(W) C

 

Sr v sr

(w) 1621

2007

Laurin v Martin (April 5)

M

(L) O

 

Sr v sr

(w)

2007

Higgins v. Higgins (April 20)

M

(L) CS, O

 

F v m

(w) 6000

2007

Loit v Gove (May 8)

M

(L) SS, O

 

Sr v sr

(w)

2007

Klerides v Klerides (May 17)

M

(L) EQ

 

M v m

(m) 5000

2007

Frankum v Frankum (June 5)

M

 (W) A

 

Sr v sr

(w) 2888

2007

Maphangoh v Maphangoh (June 11)

M

(L) SS, O

 

M v m

(w) 8000

2007

Fendelet v Dohey (June 21)

M

(L) CS, SS

 

F v sr

(w) 7500

2007

Roscoe v Roscoe (June 29)

M

(L) CS, O

 

F v m

(w) 3959

2007

Tsaros v Tsaros (July 2)

M

(L) CS

 

F v m

(w) 7500

2007

Isakhani v Al Saggaf (July 3)

M

(L) C

 

M v m

(m) 2500

2007

Burisch v Gosal (August 16)

M

 (W) CS

 

Sr v m (w)

nc

2007

Moyer v Keleman (January 12)

W

(L) O

 

M v m

nc

2007

Bak v Dobel (January 12)

W

(L) CS

 

M v sr

(m)

2007

Mastrobuono v. Mastrobuono (January 19)

W

(L) CS, SS, O

 

F v m

(m) 5000

2007

Weinrib v Bake (January 25)

W

(L) O

 

M v f

(w) 17500

2007

Czieslik v Ayuso (Mar 2)

 W

(W) EQ

 

M v sr

(m) 3500

2007

Walsh v Walsh (March 19)

W

 (W) CS      (L) SS

 

F v m

(m) 2500

2007

Josephson v Hanna (May 15)

W

(L) O

 

F v m

(m) 7500

2007

Wedig v Gaukel (June 26)

W

(L) M

 

Sr v sr

nc

2007

Spears v Haugen (August 16)

W

(L) O

 

M v m

(w) 5000

2007

Hanna v Hanna (October 7)

W

(W) O