Ottawa Men's Centre

 

Peter Roscoe's Research

 

                             Gender Bias in Family Law at the

                 Court of Appeal Ontario 2007

 

 

 

     

      Peter Karl Roscoe

 

    Apr 2006, Revised Sept 2007

 

 

 

 

Appendix B

 

 

 

Legend

 

 

 

Grounds                        (W) = Win            C = Custody             M = Mobility            CS = Child Support

of Appeal

 or Cross                        (L) = Lose            A = Access                O = Other                  SS = Spousal Support

  Appeal

                                                                   EQ = Equalization         

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B1 — Pre 1996 Cases

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

M v m

(w)

1992

Montgomery v. Montgomery (October 30)

   M

 (L)  A

 

 

(w)

1993

Elik v. Elik (February 2)

   M

 (L) CS, O

(W) SS

M v m

(w)

1993

Macedo v. Macedo (April 29)

   M

  (L) CS,O

 

M v m

nc

1994

Veneziale v. Veneziale (April 21)

   M

 (W) EQ    (L) CS

 

F v m

nc

1994

Wunsche v. Wunsche (April 25)

   M

 (W) EQ

 

M v m

nc

1994

Gleich v Kunde (March 25)

   M

 (W) SS, O    (L) CS

 

 

(w)

1995

MacGyver v. Richards (March 23)

   M

(L) M

 

M v m

(w) 4000

1993

Rumanek v. Rumanek (November 15)

   W

 (W) CS

 

M (f)v sr

nc

1994

Barakat v. Barakat (February 11)

   W

 (L) O

 

M v f

(m)

1994

Lougheed v. Sillett (June 30)

   W

 (L) C

(L) O

F  v m (m)

nc

1995

Mabraidopoulos v Mabraidopoulos (March 15)

  W

  (W) O

  (L) A, O

M v m

nc

1995

Lutz v. Lutz (March 30)

  W

(W) CS, EQ

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B2 — 1996 Cases

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

M v m

nc

1996

Balogh v Balogh (November 20)

   M

 (W) SS,EQ, O  (L) SS

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Boa v Boa (Novemeber 18)

   M

(L) EQ

 

 

(w)

1996

Boers v. Boers (December 3)

   M

 (L) SS,EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Campbell v. Campbell (February 15)

   M

 (L) CS, SS 

 

F v f

nc

1996

Cherry v Cherry (September 12)

   M

  (W) O

 

M v m

(w) 2500

1996

Duma v. Mathews (December 4)

   M

 (L) O

 

 

 

1996

Filipich v. Filipich (September 10)

   M

 (L) CS

 

M v m

nc

1996

Huisman v Huisman (June 14)

   M

 (W) SS,EQ

 

M v m

(w) 3000

1996

Jacobs v. Jacobs (February 23)

   M

 (L) O

 

M v m

nc

1996

Kennedy v. Kennedy (November 23)

   M

(W) EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1996

La Russo v La Russo (October 18)

   M

(L) M

 

 

(w)

1996

Maule-Ffinch v. Maule-Ffinch (May 7)

   M

 (L) SS, EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Meiorin v. Meiorin (January 17)

   M

 (L) CS, O

 

M v m

(w) 7000

1996

Merklinger v Merklinger (November 20)

   M

 (L)CS, SS, EQ

 

 

 

1996

Pollack v Pollack (May 7)

   M

(L) SS

 

 

nc

1996

Punzo v. Punzo (March 4)

   M

 (L) A

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Rozyle v. Rozyle (April 11)

   M

(L) EQ

 

 

 

1996

Taylor v. McWhirter (December 2)

   M

 (L) A

 

M v m

nc

1996

Williams v. Ellul (February 2)

   M

.(L) A

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Woodcock v. Woodcock (September 10)

   M

 (L) CS, SS

 

M v m

(w)

1996

Woodman v. Deremo (July 23)

  M

 (L) SS, EQ

 

F v m

(w) 6000

1996

Hamilton v Hamilton (July 23)

  M

(W)EQ  (L)CS, SS, EQ, O

 

Sr v M

(w)

1996

Maurici v. Maurici (August 9)

   W

(W) CS, EQ

 

 

nc

1996

Shefsky v. Shefsky (September 11)

   W

 (W) CS, SS

 

M v m

(w) 2500

1996

Kostello v Kostello (December 4)

   W

(W) O

 

 

nc

1996

Adams v Adams (November 19)

   W

(W) O

 

F v m

(w)

1996

Purcel v Purcel (June 28)

   W

  (W) SS       (L) O

 

M v m

(m)

1996

Nicholas v. Nicholas (June 13)

   W

(L) O

 

 

nc

1996

Benson v Krein (July 9)

  W

  (W) EQ

 (W) CS

M v m

(w)

1996

Keeping v Pacey (June 24)

   W

  (W) A

 

 

Appendix B3 — 1997 Cases

 

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

F v m

(m)

1997

Munro v. Munro (October 17)

   M

 (W) SS

 

F v m

(w)

1997

Politi v Politi (April 18)

   M

 (L) CS, EQ, O

 

 

 

1997

Layzell v. Layzell (December 8)

   M

 (L) C

 

M v f

(w)

1997

Best v. Best (October 3)

   M

 (L) SS, EQ, O

 

F v m

(w)

1997

Rarie v Rarie

   M

(W) EQ

 

F v f

(w)

1997

Therrien – Cliché v Cliché (April 1)

   M

 (L) O

 

F v f

nc

1997

Davidson v Davidson (March 4)

   M

 (W) EQ

(W) CS

M v m

(m)

1997

Van Bork v Van Bork (June 27)

   M

(W) EQ   (L) SS, O

 

F v m

(w)

1997

Tureck v. Tureck (November 9)

  M

(L) O

 

M v f

(w)

1997

Forler v Forler (April 7)

   W

(W) SS

 

M v f

(m)

1997

Roach v Roach (December 12)

   W

 (L) EQ, O

 

M v m

nc

1997

Crawford v Crawford

   W

(L) SS, EQ

 

M v f

(w)

1997

Forler v Forler (April 7)

   W

(W) SS

 

M v m

nc

1997

Sagoo v Sagoo (March 18)

   W

 (W) O

 

 

(w)

1997

Halliday v Halliday (December 24)

   W

(W)SS, O,   (L)EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1997

Trewin v Jones (February 7)

   W

  (W) SS

 

M v m

(m)

1997

Ligate v Richardson ( Jan 27)

  W

 (W) M

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix B4 — 1998 Cases

 

 

Sex of Lawyer ( wining / losing)

Cost Penalty (sex of wining appellant)

 

 

Sex.  of appellant

 Grounds of Appeal             .    ( Win/Lose )

Cross. Appeal.  (Win / Lose )

 

 

F v m

(w)

1998

Daoust v Leboeuf (January 14)

   M

 (L) C

(W)CS, O  (L)SS

M v m

(w)

1998

Francis v. Baker (March 10)

   M

 (L) CS, SS, O

 

F v m

(w)

1998

McCallum v McCallum (March 23)

   M

(W) O

 

M v m

(w)

1998

Valenti v. Valenti (May 22)

  M

(L) CS, SS, EQ, O

 

M v m

(w)

1998

Luckhurst v Luckhurst (June 4)

   M

 (L) M

 

Sr v m (m)

nc

1998

Melzack v. Germain (June 9)

  M

(L) CS

 

M v m

nc

1998

Brooks v. Brooks (June 25)

  M

(W) O

 

F v m

(w)

1998

Choquette v. Choquette (July 28)

   M

 (L) SS

 

 

(w) 5000

1998

Irwin v. Irwin (September 10)

   M

 (L) C, A

 

M v m

(w)

1998

Trotter v Trotter (October 29)

   M

 (L) EQ

 

 

(w)

1998

Cole v Cole (November 10)

   M

(L) EQ

 

M v m

(w)

1998

Rachiele v. Rachiele (December 1)

  M

(L) EQ

 

F v m (f)

nc

1998

Pivacet v Paul (Mach 13)

   W

(W) O      (L) SS

 

M v m

(w) 1500

1998

Burnett v Burnett (March 12)

   W

  (L) O

 

 

nc

1998

Walsh v. Walsh (July 20)

   W

 (L) C

 

F v f

(m)

1998

Follows v Follows (September 10)

   W

  (L) O

 

M v f (w)

(m)

1998

Appleyard v Appleyard (September 14)

   W