Superior Court Cost Penalties

                                 

 

  Peter Karl Roscoe

 

            Aug  2007

 

 

 

                                                      Contents

 

 

                                                                                                                                                           page

 

 

Introduction                                                                                                                                          1

 

Cost Decision Outcomes                                                                                                                      1

 

Cost Penalties                                                                                                                                        1

 

Representation                                                                                                                                      6

 

Sex of Judge                                                                                                                                          9

 

Conclusions                                                                                                                                         10

 

 

Appendixes                                                                                                                                          11

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                                                                Introduction

 

 

 

This study examines 404 cases where rulings on cost penalties were made in divorce related cases by the Ontario Superior Court. All cases between husband and wife where a monetary figure is given were included. In a small number of cases cost penalties were given out for several previous hearings, so the number of cases does not correspond with the number of wins. Some cases were missing information so could not be used in particular segments. The cases used for this study have been taken from the first half of the Canlii database. 10,500 cases were available on Canlii under the search term ‘ costs ‘. Most cases used in this study cames from the first third of the database. Subsequent listings typically only requested cost submissions from the parties. 

 

 

 

 

 

                                                     Cost Decision Outcomes

 

 

 

Total Wins

Female Wins

% Female Wins

Male Wins

% Male Wins

Divided Success

% Divided Success

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 409

 264

  64.5

   87

   21.3

    58

   14.1

 

 

 

It can be concluded that females win (64.5/21.3) 3 times for every time a man wins, as determined by judicial decisions on costs.

 

 

 

 

Discrimination Index = % Female Wins - % Male Wins

 

                                    = 64.5 – 21.3

 

                                    = 43.2 %

 

 

 

 

 

 

                                                               Cost Penalties

 

 

 

 

Cost Penalties Against Women = (13.7 + 15 + 10 + 3.5 + 4 + 2.5 + 3 + 12 + 5 + 8.5 + 14 + 5.8 + 18 + 9.5 + .                                                      1 + 2 + 22.5 + 3.5 + 89 + 9.5 + 2.4 + 16 +  3 + 35 + 16 + 60 + 6.4 + 31 + .                                                      13.6 + 45.5 + 32 + 3 + 2 + 32 + 1.5 + 0.1 + 200 + 1.5 + 2 + 7.5 + 40.7 + .       ..                                                     47 + 1.5 + 28 + 5 + 82.8 + 10 + 2 + 67 + 3.5 + 73.4 + 27.9 + 20 + 15 + 3 .                                                      + 12 + 15 + 0.8 + 2.7 + 2.7 + 211 + 7.5 + 5.8 + 5 + 0.6 + 10 + 20 + 6 + 7 .                                                      + 0.3 + 0.8 + 48 + 4.3 + 3 + 4.8 + 32.5 + 5.5 + 1.5 + 8 + 4.2 + 0.6 + 1.5 + .                                                      252.9 + 3 + 6.3 + 10 + 0.2 ) / 87

 

 

                                                      = 1883.1 / 87

 

                                                      = 21.6 K

 

 

 

 

 

 

Cost Penalties Against Men = ( 9.4 + 10 + 25.5 + 9 + 20 + 11.1 + 4.5 + 3 + 4 + 22.5 + 3.8 + 12 + 5 + 2,225 .                                                + 1.2 + 3 + 10.9 + 7.2 + 3.5 + 12 + 4 + 8 + 18 + 2 + 9.6 + 24.4 + 4.7 + 8 + .                 ..                                                3.5 + 10 + 15 + 40 + 36.9 + 1 + 9 + 4 + 40 + 4.5 + 10 + 2.5 + 5.2 + 6 + 2.1 .      ..                                               + 99 + 20 + 2.5 + 13.5 + 15 + 85.8 + 2.5 + 17 + 14.1 + 1.4 + 16 + 10 + 1.5 + .                                                 70 + 5 + 2 + 25 + 10 + 6.5 + 25 + 95 + 4.3 + 49 + 1.8 + 29.6 + 12.1 + 7.5 + .     ..                                                144.6 + 42.8 + 28.7 + 9.7 + 11 + 7 + 4 + 84.9 + 997.7 + 19.5 + 3 + 16.5 + ..           ..                                                1.5 + 9 + 1.5 + 3.5 + 7 + 183.8 + 9.2 + 9.5 + 34 + 8.2 + 19.5 + 15 + 10.5 + ..         ..                                                10 + 12 + 25 + 3.5 + 35 + 48 + 38 + 0.9 + 14 + 15 + 1.5 + 1.5 + 2.1 + 85 + 2 ..                                               + 1.8 + 10 + 36 + 23 + 5 + 4 + 15 + 15 + 2.3 + 12 .4 + 4.5 + 7 + 12 + 10.3 + …                                              10 + 6.6 + 45.9 + 10 + 20 + 14.5 + 8.5 + 5 + 1 + 2.1 + 6.9 + 2 + 15 + 3.4 + …                                              72 + 22 + 6.5 + 1.5 + 3.5 + 2.5 + 5 + 10 + 9 + 5.5 + 8 + 1.2 + 17.9 + 12.6 + ..                                                17.9 + 15 + 5.9 + 4.6 + 13.4 + 4.5 + 6.5 + 150 + 6.6 + 2.6 + 3.8 + 5.9 + ……                                          112.4 + 0.7 + 8.9 + 0.8 + 58.7 + 7.5 + 7.4 + 34.3 + 2.1 + 9.4 + 0.3 + 62 + ….                                              4.5 + 7.8 + 14.3 + 15 + 4.7 + 89.6 + 12.4 + 6 + 6 + 44.7 + 10 + 34 + 31.5 + ..                                                 0.7 + 6 + 3.1 + 103.4 + 8.7 + 12 + 31 + 33.8 + 3.5 + 35 + 1.3 + 75 + 6.5 + …                                               7.5 + 3.8 + 18 + 10.6 + 20 + 16 + 16.2 + 12 + 15.5 + 320 + 7.3 + 3 + 39.5 + ..                                                 3 + 31.4 + 8.5 + 3.5 + 8.5 + 5 + 8.5 + 3.8 + 4 + 1 + 10 + 49 + 0.5 + 5.7 + 4 …                                               + 22.5 + 5.8 + 6.4 + 50.7 + 5 + 3 + 75 + 10.8 + 117 + 60.9 + 7 + 6 + 2.3 + 2 ..                                                 + 20.6 + 5 + 15.8 + 3.3 + 48.6 + 8 + 90 + 12.8 + 4.3 + 15.7 + 4.7 + 3.5 + ….                                              15.7 + 4.5 + 8.5 + 7.4 + 30 + 4.1 + 36.4 + 6.4 ) / 264

 

                                                  = 8329.9 / 264

 

                                                   = 31.6 K

 

 

 

 

It can be concluded that on average females pay 31.6 % lower cost penalties than men

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Cost Penalties in Divorce Actions

 

 

For the purposes of this portion of the study divorce actions mean fully contested divorces that culminated in a trial of the issues. Cases where the parties came to agreement and only minor deliberation of a single issue remained, have been excluded. Costs of previous interim hearings may be included in the total penalty. 82 cases where a male had to pay a females lawyers costs could be found, and there were 28 cases where a female had to pay for a males lawyer. The results are as follows

 

 

 

 

 

Cost Penalties Against Women = ( 10 + 32.5 + 8 + 252.9 + 10 + 12 + 8.5 + 22 + 89 + 9 + 60 + 13.6 + 45.5 + ….                                             32 + 200 + 40.7 + 7.5 + 49.6 + 82.8 + 27.5 + 67 + 54.6 + 15 + 211 ) / 28

 

                                               = 1287 / 28

 

                                                = 45.9 K

 

 

 

 

Cost Penalties Against Men = ( 9 + 20 + 4.5 + 22.5 + 12 + 2250 + 24.4 + 15 + 36.9 + 40 + 10 + 20 + 85.8 + …                                              70 + 25 + 77 + 95 + 49 + 29.6 + 7.5 + 144.6 + 42 + 28.7 + 9.7 + 11 + 84.9 + …                                              997 + 19.5 + 7 + 183.8 + 25 + 35 + 48 + 38 + 85 + 36 + 15 + 12 + 20.3 + …..                                            14.5 + 2 + 22 + 9 + 17.9 + 12.6 + 17.9 + 15 + 5.9 + 150 + 7.5 + 34.3 + 62 + ….                                             14.3 + 89.6 + 90 + 44.7 + 34 + 31.5 + 103 + 12 + 31 + 33.8 + 75 + 3.8 + ……                                          18.0 + 10.6 + 7.3 + 39.5 + 31.4 + 8.5 + 5 + 49 + 5.7 + 6.4 + 50.7 + 10.8 + …                                              75 + 20.6 + 5 + 3.3 + 48.6 + 8.5 + 30 + 34.6 ) / 82

 

                                              = 6290.8 / 82

 

                                               = 76.7 K

 

 

 

 

It can be concluded that on average females pay 40.2 % lower cost penalties on overall divorce actions than men

 

 

 

 

 

Cost Penalties in Interim Motions

 

80 cases could be found that were clearly interim motion. In 53 men had to pay the costs of their spouses lawyer and in 27 women had to pay costs. The results are as follows.

 

 

 

Cost Penalties Against Women = (5.8 + 0.65 + 0.3 + 0.75 + 1.5 + 0.15 + 15 + 3 + 1 + 2 + 3 + 3.5 + 3 + 2 + …                                                  1.5+ 1.5 + 5.0 + 3.5 + 9.3 + 9.3 + 9.3 + 0.8 ) / 27

 

                                                    = 123.23 / 27

 

                                                     = 4.5 K

 

 

 

 

Cost Penalties Against Men = ( 3.8 + 1.2 + 3.5 + 12 2.5 + 5.5 + 4.7 + 3.5 + 5.2 + 6 + 2.1 + 93.4 + 15 + 2.5 …                                             + 1.4 + 5.3 + 5.3 + 5.3 + 5 + 2 + 1.8 + 7 + 3 + 1.5 + 9.2 + 1.5 + 2.1 + 2.0 + …                                              7.6 + 7.6 + 7.6 + 5 + 2.3 + 10 + 6.9 + 6.5 + 2.5 + 5.5 + 4.6 + 13.4 + 4.5 + ….                                             6.6 + 5.9 + 4.7 + 1.3 + 7.5 + 15.5 + 3 + 3 + 3.8 + 0.5 + 5 + 3 + 0.75 + 3 + ….                                             2.3 + 2.0 ) / 53

 

                                               = 361.75 / 53

 

                                               = 6.8 K

 

 

 

 

It can be concluded that on average females pay 33.8 % lower interim cost penalties than men

 

 

 

 

 

 

Cost Penalties in Post Divorce Support Variations

 

 

53 cases could be found that were post divorce support variations. In 42 men had to pay the costs of their spouses lawyer and in 11 women had to pay costs. The results are as follows.

 

 

 

Cost Penalties Against Women = ( 5 + 4.8 + 5.5 + 3.5 + 4 + 2.5 + 9 + 16 + 32 + 6.4 + 5.1 ) / 11

 

                                                   = 93.8 / 11

 

                                                    = 8.5 K

 

 

 

 

Cost Penalties Against Men = ( 11.1 + 3 + 4 + 5 + 18 + 10 + 9.6 + 40 + 1 + 2.5 + 13.5 + 17 + 14.1 + 25 + …                                               9.5 + 8.2 + 12 + 12.4 + 7 + 6.6 + 45.9 + 15 + 72 + 1.5 + 3.5 + 8 + 3.8 + 7.4 …                                             + 0.25 + 15.0 + 12.4 + 6 +  0.75 + 3.1 + 8.7 + 6.5 + 4 + 5.8 + 4.3 + 15.7 + ….                                              4.1 + 6.4 ) / 42

 

                                               = 479.6 / 42

 

                                               = 11.4 K

 

 

 

 

It can be concluded that on average females pay 25.4 % lower cost penalties on post divorce support variations than men

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                                                      Representation

 

 

 

Analysis of representation omits cases of divided success and focuses on cases where the judge has made a decision who the won and who lost. In 5 cases where a male won the sex of his lawyer could not be determined. In 17 cases where a female won the sex of her lawyer could not be determined. Those cases have also been omitted.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Total Cases

Male Lawyer

% Male Lawyer

Female Lawyer

% Female Lawyer

Self Represented

% Self Represented

Male Litigants

334

207

62.0

56

16.8

70

21.2

Female Litigants

334

192

57.5

125

37.4

16

5.1

 

 

 

 

Outcomes by Representation

 

 

 

 

 

Total Cases

Male Lawyer

% Male Lawyer

Female Lawyer

% Female Lawyer

Self Represented

% Self Represented

Male Wins

84

57

67.8

25

29.7

2

2.4

Male Losses

250

151

60.4

31

12.4

68

27.2

Female Wins

250

141

56.4

105

42.0

4

1.6

Female Losses

84

51

60.7

20

23.8

13

15.4

 

 

 

 

 

 

Male Representation

 

 

 

Total Cases

Wins

% Wins

Male Lawyer

207

57

27.5

Female Lawyer

56

25

44.6

 

 

 

It can be concluded that a male has a ( 44.6 – 27.5 ) 17.1 % greater chance of winning if he hires a female lawyer than if he hires a male lawyer for family actions in Superior Court

 

 

 

 

 

Female Representation

 

 

 

Total Cases

Wins

% Wins

Male Lawyer

192

141

73.4

Female Lawyer

125

105

84.0

 

 

It can be concluded that a female has a ( 84.0 – 73.4 ) 10.6 % greater chance of winning if she hires a female lawyer than if she hires a male lawyer for family actions in Superior Court

 

 

 

 

Self Represented Litigants

 

 

The database contained 87 cases where a litigant won or lost, which were contested by one or more self represented parties. The following table reproduces the results.

 

 

 

 

Total Cases

Wins

% Wins

Male Litigant

70

2

2.9

Female Litigant

17

4

23.5

Total

87

6

6.9

 

 

 

 

It can be concluded that self represented litigants have a 6.9 % chance of winning in Superior Court family actions. Female self represented parties are (23.5/2.9) 8.1 times more likely to win than males

 

 

 

 

 

 

Self Represented Litigants VS Lawyers

 

 

The data for self represented parties included 4 cases which had 2 self represented litigants. In these cases a self represented party necessarily had to be the winner. In 3 of the 4 cases a female litigant won, so female self represented parties won 3 to 1 compared to men.. To determine a self represented persons odds if opposed by a lawyer those cases must be omitted. The following table reproduces those results.

 

 

 

 

Total Cases

Wins

% Wins

Male Litigant

69

1

1.5

Female Litigant

14

1

7.1

Total

83

2

2.4

 

 

 

It can be concluded that self represented litigants have a 2.4 % chance of winning in Superior Court family actions when the opposing party is a lawyer Female self represented parties are (7.1/1.5) 4.7 times more likely to win than males

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                                                   Sex of the Judge

 

 

 

 

 

 

Male Judge

Female Judge

Male Wins

         61

          24

Female Wins

       171

          90

Divided Success

         29

          18

Total

       261

        133

 

 

 

 

 

Discrimination Index for a Male Judge = % Female Wins - % Male Wins

 

                                                                = (171/261 x 100) – (61/261 x 100)

 

                                                                = 65.5 – 23.4

 

                                                                 = 42.1 %

 

 

 

 

 

Discrimination Index for a Female Judge = % Female Wins - % Male Wins

 

                                                                   = (90/133 x 100) – ( 24/133 x 100)

 

                                                                    = 67.7 – 18.0

 

                                                                    = 49.7

 

 

 

 

 

 

It can be concluded that males are 7.6 % more likely to win when appearing before a male judge than if the case is heard by a female judge.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                                                             Conclusions

 

 

 

Total Wins

Female Wins

% Female Wins

Male Wins

% Male Wins

Divided Success

% Divided Success

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 409

 264

  64.5

   87

   21.3

    58

   14.2

 

 

From 404 cases containing record of 409 cost penalties it can be concluded  women won  43.2 % more often than men

 

 

 

 

Average Cost Penalty

Divorce Action Cost Penalty

Interim Cost Penalty

Support Variation Cost Penalty

 

 

 

 

 

Male Litigant Wins

     21. 6 K

       45.9 K

        4.5 K

          8.5 K

Female Litigant Wins

     31.6 K

       76.7 K

        6.8 K

         11.4 K

 

 

From 404 cases containing record of 409 cost penalties it can be concluded  women pay 31.6 % lower cost penalties than men. The range varies for different actions from 25.4 % lower for support variations to 40.1 % lower for overall divorce awards.

 

 

 

 

Female With a Female Lawyer

Female with a Male Lawyer

Female Self Represented

 

 

 

 

Male with a Female Lawyer  % Wins

          21.4 

          53.3

          100.0

Male with a Male Lawyer  % Wins

          21.0

          27.6

             83.3

Male Self Represented  % Wins

           0.0

            2.6

             25.0

 

 

From a varying number of representation combinations in cases where one or the other litigant won, it can be seen that men have the highest odds when they have a female lawyer and the lowest odds when they are self represented. Women also have the highest odds when they have a female lawyer and the lowest odds self represented

 

 

 

 

Male Judge

Female Judge

 

 

 

Male % Wins

       23.4

        18.0

Female % Wins

       65.5

        67.7

Divided Success

        11.1

        14.3

Total

     100.0

      100.0

 

 

From 261 cases where a litigant appeared before a male judge it can be concluded women won 42.1 % more often than men. From 133 cases where a litigant appeared before a female judge, women won 49.7 % more often than men.

 

Appendix 1 Males Winning Cost Penalties

 

 

 

 

Winners sex

Lawyers sex

 

                  Case

Judges sex

    Judge

Costs

 

       Description and amount

 

m

F v m

 

Bourque v. Haney, 2003 CanLII 2068 (ON S.C.)

 

Blair

Full and partial

Husband wins interim motion to stop wife moving with children, asks 6.9 K gets 5.8 K

m

F v f

E

O'Connor v. O'Connor, 2007 CanLII 8930 (ON S.C.)

F

Blishen

Partial

Motion to vary support, husband claims 19.8 K and gets 5 K, wife claims 8.4 K

m

M v m

Ce

Costabile v. Costabile, 2004 CanLII 42935 (ON S.C.)

F

Boyko

Partial

Interim motion, $ 650 costs

m

F v f

E

Ladisa v. Ladisa, 2004 CanLII 15138 (ON S.C.)

F

DeSousa

Partial

Divorce action, wife claims 35 K costs, husband claims 28 K and gets 10 K

m

M v m

E

Marks v. Tokarewicz, 2003 CanLII 1995 (ON S.C.)

F

DeSousa

Partial

20K costs

m

M v f

E

Sloss v. Forget, 2005 CanLII 4843 (ON S.C.)

F

DeSousa

Partial

Motion for mobility and support, 6 K costs

m

F v m

E

Viertelhausen v. Burbridge, 2006 CanLII 11238 (ON S.C.)

F

DeSousa

Partial

Support trial, 7 K costs

m

M v f

Ce

Merkand v. Merkand, 2006 CanLII 33420 (ON S.C.)

F

Ferguson

Partial

Interim motion on access   variation, 0.3 K  costs

m

M v sr

T

Dagorne v. Cormack, 2007 CanLII 28223 (ON S.C.)

F

Herman

Partial

Interim motion, 0.75 K cost penalty, secomnd interim 0.75 cost penalty, wife hasn’t paid  first penalty

m

F v m

T

A.J.K. v. S.L.M., 2003 CanLII 2409 (ON S.C.)

F

Karakatsanis

Full

Wife gets 48 K cost penalty on custody access action.

m

F v m

T

Bespaly v. Bespaly, 2003 CanLII 2287 (ON S.C.)

F

Macdonald

Partial

Contempt motion for arrears, 4.25 K cost including 0.75 K for cost submissions

m

F v m

E

D.W. v. C.O, 2006 CanLII 16361 (ON S.C.)

F

Mackinnon

Partial

Child Support Application, 3 K costs

m

M v m

E

Zadegan v. Zadegan, 2005 CanLII 48697 (ON S.C.)

F

Mackinnon

Partial

Motion  to vary support, husband gets  4.8 K

m

M v m

Sw

Al-Mutter v. Al-Ekabi, 2003 CanLII 1945 (ON S.C.)

F

Marshman

Partial

Divorce action, 15 day trial, wife must pay 32.5 K and her lawwyer 5 K in costs

m

F v m

Sw

Bowcock v. Bowcock, 2005 CanLII 18193 (ON S.C.)

F

Marshman

Partial

Husband must call motion to terminate support because of wifes actions, asks for 6.8 K gets 5.5 K

m

F v f

Sw

Miller v. Miller, 2005 CanLII 463 (ON S.C.)

F

Marshman

Partial

Wife motion for supervised access fails 1.5 K costs

m

M v m

Sw

Verscheure v. Verscheure, 2006 CanLII 13238 (ON S.C.)

F

Marshman

Partial

Divorce, husband gets 8 K costs

m

M v m

Nw

Kuluski v. Adams, 2002 CanLII 2684 (ON S.C.)

F

Pierce

Partial

Husband wins interim motion to stop wife moving with children, 4.2 K

m

M v m

Ce

Costabile v. Costabile, 2004 CanLII 42935 (ON S.C.)

F

Rodgers

Partial

Interim motion, $ 675 costs

m

M v m

E

Craig v. Craig, 2005 CanLII 50263 (ON S.C.)

F

Rutherford

Partial

Contempt motion for disclosure dismissed, 1.5 K costs

m

M v m

Cw

A.F. v. I.V., 2006 CanLII 32619 (ON S.C.)

F

Snowie

Partial

Divorce action lasting 11 years where wife made numerous false allegations, 252.9 K cosdts

m

M v sr

Cw

Euteneier v. Euteneier, 2007 CanLII 9609 (ON S.C.)

F

Snowie

Partial

Husband asks 18.9 K and gets 6.3 K, wife declared as vextacious litigant on summary judgement

m

M v f

Cs

St. Louis v. St. Louis, 2007 CanLII 11730 (ON S.C.)

F

Tucker

Partial

Divorce action, husband seeks 21 K gets 10 K

m

M v m

Cw

Lanfrey v. Lanfrey, 2003 CanLII 2326 (ON S.C.)

F

Wein

Partial

Interim motion, $ 150, wife has not paid 6 K costs under appeal

m

 

Cw

Stanley v. Stanley, 2003 CanLII 2351 (ON S.C.)

F

Wein

Partial

Husband gets wifes action stayed 13.7 K costs

m

M v f

Cs

Heath v. Heath, 2006 CanLII 19458 (ON S.C.)

F

Wildman

Full

Contempt motion, wife empties house with moving van against direct court order, 15 K costs

m

M v f

Cs

L.K. v. T.G., 2007 CanLII 10411 (ON S.C.)

F

Wildman

Partial

Husband wins motion for unsupervised access, claims 20 K and gets 10 K

m

M v m

 

Gartley v. Church, 2002 CanLII 2727 (ON S.C.)

M

Aston

Partial

Motion to adjust support overpayment, Husband is partially successful and claims 27 K and gets 3.5 K, wife claims 25 K

m

M v m

 

Sharpe v. Ebers, 2002 CanLII 2725 (ON S.C.)

M

Aston

Partial

Support variation, 4 K costs

m

M v f

Cw

J.P.S.V. v. M.V., 2006 CanLII 10530 (ON S.C.)

M

Bellighem

Partial

Support variation, 2.5 K costs

m

 

Cw

Smolders v. Smolders, 2003 CanLII 2246 (ON S.C.)

M

Bellighem

Partial

Interim motion  to set support, 3 K  costs

m

M v sr

Cw

Murphy v. Murphy, 2003 CanLII 2186 (ON S.C.)

M

Bellinghem

Partial

Divorce action, husband has 40 K costs and gets 12 K

m

M v m

T

Walker v. Walker, 2006 CanLII 20095 (ON S.C.)

M

C Campbell

Partial

Husband gets 5 K

m

 

Sw

Broz v. Broz, 1998 CanLII 14477 (ON S.C.)

M

Campbell

Partial

Wife obstructs access gets 8.5 K cost penalty offset against husbands 6.4 K equalization and retroactive support, claims costs of 20 K

m

M v m

Sw

Cumpson v. Templeton, 2005 CanLII 50010 (ON S.C.)

M

Campbell

Partial

Husband wins custody and mobility trial, 14 K costs

m

M v m

Sw

MacRae v. Simpson, 2003 CanLII 2307 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Campbell

Partial

Half day motion, husband asks 27.8 K and gets 5.8 K

m

M v m

Sw

Snih v. Snih, 2007 CanLII 20774 (ON S.C.)

M

Campbell

Partial

Wife loses custody action, husband claims 30 K and gets 18 K

m

M v m

CS

Belanger v. Belanger, 2005 CanLII 30867 (ON S.C.)

M

Cavarzan

Partial

9.5 K against wife, husband has custody

m

F v m

E

Guénette v. Brisebois, 2004 CanLII 33294 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Charbonneau

Partial

Husband  gets interim custody, divided success,3 motions 1 K coststo  be paid by wife

m

 

Sw

Moore v. Riley, 2005 CanLII 24928 (ON S.C.)

M

Cusinato

Partial

Husband gets increased access, 2 K costs for interim motion

m

F v sr

Ne

Levesque v. Little, 2007 CanLII 1910 (ON S.C.)

M

Del Frate

Partial

Divorce action, husband asks 53.2 K and gets 22.5 K

m

M v m

Ne

Ansara v. Ansara, 2007 CanLII 6235 (ON S.C.)

M

Del Frate

Partial

Interim motion on acces and support, 3 K costs deferred to trial

m

M v m

Ce

Ross v. Pishalski, 2005 CanLII 9678 (ON S.C.)

M

Ditomaso

Partial

Motion to determine jurisdiction, 3.5 Kcosts

m

M v f

Cs

Graham v. Kuntz, 2005 CanLII 44387 (ON S.C.)

M

Festeryga

Partial

Support variation, 9 K costs

m

M v m

Cs

Harrington v. Harrington, 2007 CanLII 27754 (ON S.C.)

M

Festeryga

Partial

Divorce action, husband asks 129 K gets 89 K

m

M v f

Cs

Debruyn v. Debruyn, 2005 CanLII 11206 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Full and partial

Divorce action, wife gets 9.5 K costs and her lawyer gets 5 K costs and can’t bill wife for trial time

m

F v sr

Cs

Duquette v. Gregorio, 2006 CanLII 32615 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

Motion for expanded access, 2.4 K costs

m

M v m

Cs

Miner v. Miner, 2004 CanLII 16229 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Full

Husband asks 58 K and gets 16 K in support variation

m

F  v m

Cs

Munro v. Munro, 2005 CanLII 22142 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

Interim motion, wife and lawyer don’t attend forst motion, 3 K costs to wife, 1 K costs to wifes lawyer

m

M v f

Cs

Rossi v. Rossi, 2005 CanLII 47780 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

3 day trial of support variation, 35 K cost penalty

m

M v f

Ce

Hill v. Hill, 2005 CanLII 3476 (ON S.C.)

M

Glass

Partial

Motion to enforce a separation agreement, husband claims 21 K gets 16 K

m

F v m

Ce

McKenzie v. McKenzie, 2002 CanLII 2803 (ON S.C.)

M

Glass

Partial and full

Divorce action, 6o K  costs

m

F v m

Cs

Balaban v. Balaban, 2007 CanLII 7990 (ON S.C.)

M

Glithero

Full

Husbands motion to terminate support, 6.4 K costs

m

M v m

Cs

Cornaz v. Cornaz-Nikyuluw, 2005 CanLII 47770 (ON S.C.)

M

Glithero

Partial

Hague convention case to return child to husband, husband asks 62 K gets 31 K

m

F v sr

Cs

Hoddinott v. Hoddinott, 2002 CanLII 2791 (ON S.C.)

M

Glithero

Partial

Divorce action 13.6 K costs

m

M v m

Cs

Visneskie v. Visneskie, 2003 CanLII 2264 (ON S.C.)

M

Glithero

Partial

Divorce action, husband asks for 54.5 K and gets 45.5  K

m

M v m

Cs

O'Brien v. O'Brien, 2006 CanLII 32637 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Partial

Interim motions, wife claims 115 K paid to lawyers, husband claims 60 K, 32 K costs

m

M v m

Cs

Scodras v. Scodras, 2005 CanLII 19785 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Partial

Interim motion, 3 K costs

m

M v m

Cs

Stockie v. Stockie, 2003 CanLII 2352 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Partial

Interim motion, 2 K costs

m

M v m

Cs

Takis v. Takis, 2003 CanLII 2256 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Partial

Divorce action, husband asks 64 K and gets 32 K

m

M v f

Cs

Bjornson v. Creighton, 2007 CanLII 14321 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Partial

Motion, 1.5 K

m

M v sr

Cs

Girard v. Girard, 2007 CanLII 28740 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Partial

Access  motion and police not needed,  costs to husband $ 100

m

M v sr

Cs

Hockey-Sweeney v. Sweeney, 2002 CanLII 2721 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Partial

Divorce action, wife acts unreasonably,  200 K  costs

m

F v m

Cs

Tucker v. Tucker, 2002 CanLII 2761 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Partial

Motion to vary support, 5.1 K costs

m

Sr v m

Cs

Montemurro v. Shavalier, 2003 CanLII 43349 (ON S.C.)

M

Harris

Partial

Interim motion, wifes lawyer doesn’t respond, 1.5 K costs

m

M v m

Ce

Tavernier v. Tavernier, 2004 CanLII 5089 (ON S.C.)

M

Howden

Partial

Wife wins motion but is censred for actions, 2 K costs

m

M v m

Ne

Borsos v. Borsos, 2006 CanLII 31201 (ON S.C.)

M

Loukidelis

Partial

Divorce sction, husband asks 47.1 K  and gets 7.5 K

m

F v m

 

Raguckas v. Raguckas, 2007 CanLII 2360 (ON S.C.)

M

Mazza

Partial

Divorce action, 40.7 K

m

F v m

Nw

Goeldner v. Goeldner, 2004 CanLII 14348 (ON S.C.)

M

McCartney

Partial

Divorce action no children, costs 47 K plus 2.6 K prejudgement interest

m

F v m

Nw

Hensel v. Hensel, 2006 CanLII 40672 (ON S.C.)

M

McCartney

Partial

Interim motion for daycare, 1.5 K costs

m

Fv sr

Nw

Jones v. Cole, 2007 CanLII 21956 (ON S.C.)

M

Mccartney

Partial

Wifes motion for custody fails, husband asks for 76 K and gets 28 K

m

F v sr

Nw

St. James v. St. James, 2006 CanLII 31618 (ON S.C.)

M

McCartney

Partial

Interim motion, 5 K costs

m

M v f

Cw

Philip v. Philip, 2006 CanLII 39319 (ON S.C.)

M

Oconnor

Partial

Divorce action, 10 day trial, husband claims 182.5 K and gets 82.8  K costs, includes 16.3 K offset for interim cost penalty man got but hasn’t paid

m

F v sr

Ce

Church v. Church, 2003 CanLII 2084 (ON S.C.)

M

Perkins

Partial

2 motions, 10 K costs

m

M v f

Ce

Savoie v. Richard, 2004 CanLII 47793 (ON S.C.)

M

Perkins

Partial

Motion, husband asks for  6.8 K gets 2 K

m

Sr v sr

Nw

L.J.J.C. v. V.S.C., 2006 CanLII 21777 (ON S.C.)

M

Platana

Partial

Husband claims 50 K for divorce and gets 27.5 K, wife claims 91 K

m

M v sr

Nw

Coady v. Boyle, 2004 CanLII 15122 (ON S.C.)

M

Platana

Full

Divorce action, wife makes fraud claim, husband asks 102 K gets 67 K

m

 

Sw

Coletta v. Jones Coletta, 2003 CanLII 2412 (ON S.C.)

M

Quinn

Partial

 

m

M v f

Nw

Elieff v. Elieff, 2007 CanLII 15787 (ON S.C.)

M

Shaw

Partial

Wife withdraws interim motion, 3.5 K costs for unheard motion

m

F v m

Cw

X.M. v. S.A.M., 2007 CanLII 23596 (ON S.C.)

M

Sproat

Full and Partial

18.8 K costs for trial, 54.6 K for divorce

m

 

Nw

Gale v. Gale, 2006 CanLII 40788 (ON S.C.)

M

Stach

Partial and full

Interim motions in 3 courts, 27.9 K

m

M v m

Ce

Caldwell v. Caldwell, 2007 CanLII 8918 (ON S.C.)

M

Timm

Full

Motion for support against wife who hasn’t paid, 20 K costs

m

M v f

Ce

Mercieca v. Merciera, 2003 CanLII 2184 (ON S.C.)

M

Timms

Partial

Divorce action, 15 K costs

m

F v m

Cw

Finucan v. Finucan, 2006 CanLII 30590 (ON S.C.)

M

Tulloch

Partial

Motion, 3 K costs

m

M v m

Cw

Sincovich v. Sincovich, 2005 CanLII 33591 (ON S.C.)

M

Tulloch

Partial

Husband successful in custody support application, claims 45 K gets 12 K costs

m

 

Cs

Bolduc v. Bolduc, 2006 CanLII 35976 (ON S.C.)

M

Turnbull

Partial

Trial, husband claims 25 K gets 15 K

m

M v m

Cs

Smith v. Smith, 2007 CanLII 8024 (ON S.C.)

M

Turnbull

Partial

Interim motion, 0.8 K costs

m

M v f

Sw

Marshall v. Marshall, 2004 CanLII 4015 (ON S.C.)

M

Vogelsang

Partial

Custody and access motion, 2.7 K costs

m

M v f

Sw

Marshall v. Marshall, 2004 CanLII 4874 (ON S.C.)

M

Vogelsang

Partial

Motion to change principle residence during school  term, 2.7 K

m

M v m

Ne

Feng v. Philips, 2006 CanLII 13769 (ON S.C.)

M

Whalen

Partial

Divorce action, 5 ˝ years to get to trial, 211 K costs

m

M v m

Ce

S.M.G. v. M.J.J.G., 2006 CanLII 16 (ON S.C.)

M

Wood

Partial

Custody variance, husband asks 50 K gets 7.5 K

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix 2    Females Winning Cost Penalties

 

 

 

 

Winners sex

Lawyers sex

 

                  Case

Judges sex

  Judge

Costs

 

     Description and Amount

 

w

L v sr

 

Sloan v. Sloan, 2003 CanLII 2245 (ON S.C.)

 

Laforme

Partial

Wife asks 34 K for motion, gets 10 K

w

F v m

 

Lowry v. Kushnir, 2007 CanLII 18146 (ON S.C.)

 

Milanetti

Partial

Motion, wife asks 75 K in costs and gets 25 K, and wife gets 3 K in cost for case conference

w

F v sr

 

Maratib v. Zafar, 2005 CanLII 19844 (ON S.C.)

 

Zelinski

Partial

Divorce action, wife 60 % successful, 4.5 K costs

w

M v m

E

Scherr v. Scherr, 2004 CanLII 889 (ON S.C.)

F

Aiken

Partial

Support motion, 3 K costs

w

M v sr

E

Doherty v. Wilcox, 2007 CanLII 5527 (ON S.C.)

F

Aitken

Partial

Support  variation, divided success, wife asks 8.3  K and gets 4 K

w

F v sr

E

Hamilton v. Hamilton, 2005 CanLII 47744 (ON S.C.)

F

Aitken

Partial

Motion for  prejudgemenet interest on equalization, 5 K costs

w

F v sr

E

Jonas v. Jonas, 2003 CanLII 1967 (ON S.C.)

F

Aitken

Full

Divorce action 2 day trial, husbands pleadings struck, 22.5 K costs

w

M v m

E

Seguin v. Masterson, 2004 CanLII 196 (ON S.C.)

F

Aitken

Partial

Interim motion, wife asks 5.9 K and gets 3.8 K

w

M   v sr

E

Sleiman v. Sleiman, 2003 CanLII 1983 (ON S.C.)

F

Aitken

Partial

Wife asks 95.1 K for divorce action And gets 12 K for post appeal motion

w

F v sr

E

Stoate v. Stoate, 2005 CanLII 25768 (ON S.C.)

F

Aitken

Partial

Motion to vary support, wife asks for 8.7 K  and gets 5 K costs

w

 

T

Debora v. Debora, 2005 CanLII 7671 (ON S.C.)

F

Backhouse

Full

Wife asks for 2.6 million and gets 2.25 million for divorce

w

M v sr

 

Hollowell v. Hollowell, 2003 CanLII 2316 (ON S.C.)

F

Bain

Partial

Interim motion to change support, husband does not show up, 1.2 K costs

w

M v m

 

McLellan v. McIntyre, 2003 CanLII 2330 (ON S.C.)

F

Bain

Partial

Motion settled on consent  but 3 K costs to wife

w

F v m

Cw

Mantella v. Mantella, 2005 CanLII 26320 (ON S.C.)

F

Baltman

Partial

Motion toset aside separatrion  agreement, wife asks 31.5 K and gets 10.9 K

w

M v m

Cw

Martins v. Martins, 2006 CanLII 24242 (ON S.C.)

F

Baltman

Partial

Motion to set arrears, wife claims 13.6 K and gets 7.2 K costs

w

M v f

 

Bourque v. Haney, 2003 CanLII 2068 (ON S.C.)

F

Blair

Partial

Wife keeps interim custody despite being ordered back to Ontario, asks 4.1 K gets 3.5 K

w

M v m

E

Biddle v. Biddle, 2005 CanLII 7660 (ON S.C.)

F

Blishen

Partial

Wife claims 19.5 K for interim support motion and gets 12 K

w

M v f

E

Hackett v. Leung, 2005 CanLII 42254 (ON S.C.)

F

Blishen

Partial

Motion, Wife claims 8.4 K and gets 4 K

w

M v m

E

N.L. v. J.C., 2005 CanLII 4838 (ON S.C.)

F

Blishen

Partial

Interim motion  to strike pleadings, 2.5 K costs,  precvious interim motion for  custody 5.5 K costs

w

F v m

E

Piskor v. Piskor, 2004 CanLII 5023 (ON S.C.)

F

Blishen

Full

Support variation, 18 K costs

w

M v m

E

Stratton v. Kangas, 2002 CanLII 46690 (ON S.C.)

F

Blishen

Partial

Wife sucessful on 2 out of 3 issues, 3.5 K partial indemnity asked and gets 2 K

w

M v m

E

Zlater v. Hartwick, 2007 CanLII 30664 (ON S.C.)

F

Blishen

Full

Motion for university expense, 9.6 K costs, ruling better than offer  to settle

w

M  v m

Ce

Lascala v. Lascala, 2004 CanLII 5013 (ON S.C.)

F

Boyko

Partial

Divorce action, husbands pleadings struck, husband asks 100K, wife gets 24.4 K

w

F v m

T

Parker v. Parker, 2004 CanLII 14179 (ON S.C.)

F

Croll

Partial

Interim motion  for  custody and  support, wife gets 4.7 K

w

F v f

E

A.D. v. M.J., 2006 CanLII 37515 (ON S.C.)

F

DeSousa

Partial

Motion, wife found in contempt, 8 K costs

w

F v m

E

Dahdouh v. Dahdouh, 2003 CanLII 1920 (ON S.C.)

F

DeSousa

Partial

Interim motion for possession of home and leave to appeal, 3.5 K

w

F v sr

E

Hinke v. Lake, 2007 CanLII 8635 (ON S.C.)

F

DeSousa

Partial

Man achieves substancial success on motion to vary but wife goven 10 K costs

w

F v m

E

M.I. v. J.R., 2005 CanLII 7663 (ON S.C.)

F

DeSousa

Partial

Divorce action, wife allowed to move to Japan, 15 K costs

w

F v sr

E

Martin v. Martin, 2007 CanLII 8638 (ON S.C.)

F

DeSousa

Full

Support variation,40 K costs

w

F v sr

E

P.R. v. K.R., 2003 CanLII 1918 (ON S.C.)

F

Desousa

Full

Divorce action, pleadings struck, uncontested trial, 36.9 K costs

w

M v m

E

Surrette v. Johnson, 2003 CanLII 2282 (ON S.C.)

F

DeSousa

Partial

Support variation, divided success, 1 K costs

w

M v sr

E

Szivi v. Schwilgin, 2003 CanLII 2036 (ON S.C.)

F

Desousa

Partial

Motion for leave to appeal, 9 K costs

w

 

Ce

Critch v. Critch, 2005 CanLII 16630 (ON S.C.)

F

Eberhard

Partial

Motion, 4 K costs

w

F v sr

Ce

Di Manno v. Di Manno, 2002 CanLII 2673 (ON S.C.)

F

Eberhard

Partial

Divorce action, wife asks 58 K gets 40 K

w

M v sr

Ce

Ernyes v. Rachlin, 2004 CanLII 47867 (ON S.C.)

F

Eberhard

Partial

Contempt motion, 4.5 K costs

w

F v sr

Ce

Pratt v. Pratt, 2003 CanLII 2201 (ON S.C.)

F

Eberhard

Partial

Divorce action, husband given supervised access to children, divided success, 10 K costs

w

M v sr

Ce

Stancheff v. Stancheff, 2006 CanLII 22144 (ON S.C.)

F

Eberhard

Partial

Variation, 2.5  K costs

w

M v f

Ce

Dorion v. Merkley, 2006 CanLII 38357 (ON S.C.)

F

Ferguson

Partial

Husband loses interim motion 5.2 K costs

w

M v m

Ce

Jackson v. Jackson, 2005 CanLII 6371 (ON S.C.)

F

Ferguson

Partial

6 K costs for interim motions to vary support

w

F v m

Ce

Merkand v. Merkand, 2006 CanLII 33420 (ON S.C.)

F

Ferguson

Partial

Interim motion on access   variation,  2.1 K  costs

w

M v m

T

Paech v. Paech, 2004 CanLII 47780 (ON S.C.)

F

Greer

Full

Interim motion to determine support, wife asks 99 K gets

w

M v m

T

Adamson v. Steed, 2007 CanLII 1328 (ON S.C.)

F

Herman

Partial

3 day trial, wife asks 47.5 K gets 20 K

w

M v m

T

Altobello v. Altobello, 2006 CanLII 44265 (ON S.C.)

F

Herman

Partial

Motion, 2.5 K  costs

w

F v m

T

D'Costa v. D'Costa, 2005 CanLII 56207 (ON S.C.)

F

Herman

Partial

Support  variation, wife asks for 19.3 K and gets 13.5 K

w

M v m

T

David v. McCain, 2006 CanLII 9302 (ON S.C.)

F

Karakatsanis

Partial

Interim motion for custody access, wife asks 20 K  and gets 15 K, husband asks 40  K and gets increased access

w

F v m

T

Fox v. Fox, 2006 CanLII 21065 (ON S.C.)

F

Karakatsanis

Partial

Divorce action with a 10 day trial, wife asks 200 K gets 85.8 K

w

F v m

T

Matanovic v. Matanovic, 2005 CanLII 47788 (ON S.C.)

F

Karakatsanis

Partial

Interim motion, wife asks 10.3 Kand gets 2.5 K

w

M v m

T

Meikle v. Meikle, 2003 CanLII 2032 (ON S.C.)

F

Karakatsanis

Partial

Support variaton,  17 K costs

w

M v sr

 

Rose v. Rose, 2004 CanLII 17755 (ON S.C.)

F

Katarynych

Partial

Motion to vary child support  dismissed, 14.1 K costs

w

M v m

Ce

Coscarella v. Coscarella, 2000 CanLII 20376 (ON S.C.)

F

Lack

Partial

Interim motion, wife asks 2.6 K and gets 1.4 K, no costs for either side in divorce action

w

Mv m

 

DeBora v. DeBora, 2003 CanLII 2216 (ON S.C.)

F

Lang, Benotto, Zelinski

Partial

3 Interim motions, wife gets16 K costs

w

Sr v m

T

O'Brien v. O'Brien, 2003 CanLII 1931 (ON S.C.)

F

Lax

Partial

Self represented wife gets 10 K costs for application

w

F v m

T

Emamghorashi v. Nateghi, 2003 CanLII 2306 (ON S.C.)

F

Macdonald

Partial

Husband gets default of over  13 Kin costs penalties set  aside but  gets cost penalty  of 1.5 K

w

M v m

T

H.1 v. H.2, 2004 CanLII 43947 (ON S.C.)

F

Macdonald

Partial

Divorce action, 70 K cost

w

F v m

T

Nichele v. Nichele, 2003 CanLII 1901 (ON S.C.)

F

Macdonald

Partial

Preliminary hearing in motion to  vary support oirder, 5 K costs, man is allowed to proceed

w

F v m

E

Dahdouh v. Dahdouh, 2003 CanLII 2041 (ON S.C.)

F

Mackinnon

Partial

Interim motions, 2 K  costs

w

M v m

E

Guy v. Tulloch, 2004 CanLII 15397 (ON S.C.)

F

Mackinnon

Partial

Divorce action, wife asks 35 K and gets 25  K

w

M v f

E

Likins v. MacKenzie, 2004 CanLII 15767 (ON S.C.)

F

Mackinnon

Partial

Divorce action. Arbitrators cost award of 110 K reduced to 67 K, 10 K costs

w

M v sr

E

N.(D.) v. E.(T.), 2000 CanLII 21156 (ON S.C.)

F

Mackinnon

Full

Wife win trial of custody and gets 6.5 K costs, asks for 10 K

w

M v m

E

Shamess v. Berry, 2006 CanLII 42606 (ON S.C.)

F

Mackinnon

Partial

Support variation, wife asks 38 K gets 25 K plus prejudgement interest

w

M v f

E

F. v. V., 2002 CanLII 2767 (ON S.C.)

F

Mackinon

Partial

Divorce action,  wife asks for 158 K   and gets  95 K

w

M v m

E

Silver v. Mercer, 2003 CanLII 2039 (ON S.C.)

F

Makinnon

Partial

Wife gets 4.3 K for motion to set support

w

M v m

Sw

MacKinnon v. MacKinnon, 2004 CanLII 8945 (ON S.C.)

F

Marshman

partial

Wife gets 49 K in 6 day trial

w

F v f

Sw

Dale v. Dale, 2003 CanLII 2006 (ON S.C.)

F

Marshman

Partial

Wife gets 1.8 K in costs from interim motion

w

M v m

Sw

Deelstra v. Van Osch, 2003 CanLII 2007 (ON S.C.)

F

Marshman

Full

Divorce action, 4 day trial, wife gets custody 29.6 K

w

M v m

Sw

Giguere v. Giguere, 2004 CanLII 5004 (ON S.C.)

F

Marshman

Partial

Trial of support, 12.1 K costs

w

F v f

Sw

Morrison v. Morrison, 2003 CanLII 1950 (ON S.C.)

F

Marshman

Full

Divorce action, 7.5 K costs

w

M m

Cs

Patterson v. Patterson, 2007 CanLII 26288 (ON S.C.)

F

McLaren

Partial

Divorce action, wife successful on 4 out of 6 issues, wife asks 342 K and gets 144.6 K

w

M v m

Ce

David v. David, 2005 CanLII 10541 (ON S.C.)

F

Olah

Partial

Divorce trial, wife gets 42 K

w

F v m

Ce

Denby v. Denby, 2003 CanLII 2097 (ON S.C.)

F

Olah

Full

Divorve action, 4 day trial,  28.7 K costs

w

M v sr

E

Fequet v. Petelka Fequet, 2003 CanLII 2200 (ON S.C.)

F

Polowin

Partial

Divorce action, husband asks for 21 K and  wife gets 9.7 K

w

F v sr

Ce

Romanenko v. Stolarsky, 2005 CanLII 9677 (ON S.C.)

F

Rogers

 

Uncontested trial, husbands pleadings strck, 11 K costs

w

M v sr

Ce

Shamli v. Shamli, 2004 CanLII 45956 (ON S.C.)

F

Rogers

Full

Interims motions to  strike pleadings, 7 K costs

w

F v m

T

Gardiman v. Brown, 2006 CanLII 40789 (ON S.C.)

F

Sachs

Partial

Motion for access and crossmotion for support, 4 K costs

w

F v m

Ce

Beaumont v. Beaumont, 2006 CanLII 20528 (ON S.C.)

F

Scott

Partial

Divorce action, 84.9 K costs, and 3 K costs to apportion award.

w

F v m

Cw

Lowry v. Kushnir, 2007 CanLII 18146 (ON S.C.)

F

Snowie

Partial

Divorce action, 997.7 K costs, appealrd to the court of Appeal, 20 K more costs

w

F v f

Cw

Reid v. Reid, 2005 CanLII 2743 (ON S.C.)

F

Snowie

Partial

Divorce action, wife spends 62 K and gets 19.5 K

w

M v m

Cw

Walsh v. Walsh, 2003 CanLII 2268 (ON S.C.)

F

Snowie

Partial

Interim motion, wife aks 4.5 K  gets 3 K

w

M v f

T

Dickie v. Dickie, 2007 CanLII 15236 (ON S.C.)

F

Stewart

Full

Contempt motion, 16.5 K

w

M v m

T

Qi v. Fung, 2006 CanLII 16366 (ON S.C.)

F

Stewart

Partial

Motion for child support, husbands income imputed to  40 K, 1.5 K costs

w

M v m

E

Lakhani v. Lakhani, 2003 CanLII 2160 (ON S.C.)

F

Toscano Roccano

Partial

9 K to wife for motion

w

M v sr

E

Cunningham v. Lefebvre, 2006 CanLII 5602 (ON S.C.)

F

Toscano Romano

Partial

Interim motion, 1.5 K costs

w

M v sr

Cs

Gill v. Knack, 2007 CanLII 1332 (ON S.C.)

F

Tucker

Partial

Only remaining issue was Christmas access, 3.5 K costs

w

M v sr

Cs

Siconolfi v. Siconolfi, 2007 CanLII 1327 (ON S.C.)

F

Tucker

Partial

Divorce action partially settled, wife asks 15.5 K gets  7 K

w

F v m

Cw

Islam v. Rahman, 2006 CanLII 22137 (ON S.C.)

F

Van Melle

 

Divorce action, 183.8  K

w

M v m

Cw

Chaudhry v. Chaudhry, 2003 CanLII 2005 (ON S.C.)

F

Wein

Partial

Interim  motion, wife asks 46 K gets 9.2 K

w

M v f

Cw

McLean v. Vassel, 2004 CanLII 33012 (ON S.C.)

F

Wein

Partial

9.5 K for support variation, requested 88 K

w

F v m

Cw

Ramcharitar v. Ramcharitar, 2003 CanLII 1997 (ON S.C.)

F

Wein

Partial

Wife asks for 55 K partial or 98 K full and gets 34 K, post divorce action for custody access.

w

 

Cw

S.R.S. v. A.H.H., 2004 CanLII 5038 (ON S.C.)

 

F

Wein

Full

Husband unemployed  and retraining, 8.2 K cost penalty

w

F v sr

Cw

Wentzell v. Schumacher, 2004 CanLII 4032 (ON S.C.)

F

Wein

Fulll

Trial cancelled due to agreement but husband gets 19.5 K costs for contempt motion withdrawn at last moment.

w

F v  sr

Ce

Domb v. Domb, 2002 CanLII 2661 (ON S.C.)

F

Wildman

Full

Mans pleadings struck when self represented for notpaying cost award,15 K

w

F v f

Ce

Smith v. Smith, 2007 CanLII 22662 (ON S.C.)

F

Wildman

Full

Wies motion for summary judgement fails, 10.5 K costs

w

M v m

 

Delellis v. Delellis and Delellis, 2005 CanLII 36447 (ON S.C.)

M

Aston

Partial

Family claim including constructive trust, wife and child win 50 K and 10 K cost, claim 45 K costs

w

M v m

 

Marshall v. Marshall, 2002 CanLII 2724 (ON S.C.)

M

Aston

Partial

Support claim, husband spends 20 K, and is given 12 K

w

M v m

 

Osmar v. Osmar, 2000 CanLII 20380 (ON S.C.)

M

Aston

Partial ( 85 % )

 Wife asks for 33 K and gets 25 K for trial

w

F v m

E

Fleming v. Lamb, 2004 CanLII 5001 (ON S.C.)

M

Belch

Partial

Wife asks 11 K and gets 3.5 K for supoort / income determination motion

w

M v m

E

McCaw v. McCaw, 2007 CanLII 6920 (ON S.C.)

M

Belch

Partial

Divorce action, wife asks 69 K gets 35 K

w

F v m

Cw

J.D.K v. K.W.B.K, 2005 CanLII 38100 (ON S.C.)

M

Bellegham

Partial

Divorce action, wife asks 73 K gets 48 K

w

F v m

Cw

Peters v. Peters, 2003 CanLII 2198 (ON S.C.)

M

Belleghem

Partial

Divorce action, divided success wife gets at least 38 K costs

w

F v  sr

Cw

Schmidt v. Seidel, 2004 CanLII 17443 (ON S.C.)

M

Bellighem

Partial

Custody variation. Joint custody changed to sole custody to  wife, $ 850 costs

w

F v m

T

Feher v. Healey, 2006 CanLII 33312 (ON S.C.)

M

Belobaba

Partial

Husband sues wife over transfer of home  and loses, wife asks for 26 K and gets 14 K

w

F v m

Cs

Bremer v. Bremer, 2005 CanLII 6387 (ON S.C.)

M

Borkovich

 

15 K costs incurred by wife due to husbands intransience

w

 

Ce

Lyons v. Tuffner, 2007 CanLII 30665 (ON S.C.)

M

Brown

Partial

Interim motion, 1.5 K cosys

w

M v m

 

Biggin v. Maloney, 2006 CanLII 7511 (ON S.C.)

M

Campbell

Partial

Simple case, 1.5 K costs

w

F v f

 

Brennan v. Brennan, 2002 CanLII 2742 (ON S.C.)

M

Campbell

Partial

Interim motion,both parties claim to have spent over 30 K, 2.1 K costs

w

F v f

 

Dababneh v. Dababneh, 2004 CanLII 5858 (ON S.C.)

M

Campbell

Full

Divorce action,  wife gets 85 K

w

F v m

 

Waywell v. Waywell, 2004 CanLII 7577 (ON S.C.)

M

Campbell

Partial

Wife asks 30 K for interim support relief and gets 2 K

w

M v sr

 

Ficca v. Ficca, 2004 CanLII 6226 (ON S.C.)

M

Campbell

Partial

Motion to change access, 1.8 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Tessarolo v. Tessarolo, 2005 CanLII 30882 (ON S.C.)

M

Cavarzan

Partial

Wife asks for 6 K, husband asks for 12 K, wife gets 10 K

w

 

E

Poirier v. Poirier, 2006 CanLII 2188 (ON S.C.)

M

Charboneau

Partial

Divorce, 36 K costs

w

F v m

T

Kordic v. Bernachi, 2006 CanLII 38875 (ON S.C.)

M

Clark

Partial and full

2 motions and a case conference, 23 K in costs

w

M v f

T

Molitor v. Andreou, 2006 CanLII 3481 (ON S.C.)

M

Clark

Partial

Interim support motion, husband ordered to pay 5.3  K  per month support, 5 Kcosts

w

M v m

T

Babb v. Downer, 2005 CanLII 6047 (ON S.C.)

M

Clarke

Partial

Costs of motion 4 K

w

F v m

T

Copp v. Copp, 2004 CanLII 34077 (ON S.C.)

M

Clarke

Partial

Divorce Action, 15 K costs

w

M v m

Cw

Mantella v. Mantella, 2006 CanLII 17337 (ON S.C.)

M

Corbett

Partial on wife and full on lawyer

Man sues wifes divorce lawyer, 14 K plus 1 K for cost submission to wife, 22 K plus 1 K cost submission to lawyer

w

F v m

Sw

Dias v. Dias, 2005 CanLII 41541 (ON S.C.)

M

Cusinato

Partial

Interim motion on sale of property, 2.3 K costs

w

F v m

Sw

Kauric v. Kauric, 2006 CanLII 31729 (ON S.C.)

M

Cusinato

Partial

Support variation, 12.4 K

w

M v m

Sw

Simpson v. Simpson, 2006 CanLII 819 (ON S.C.)

M

Cusinato

Partial

All issues settled prior to trial except spousal support, 4.5 K costs

w

F v m

Cs

Jordan v. Stewart, 2007 CanLII 11716 (ON S.C.)

M

Czurtin

Partial

Motion tovary support,  wife asks 13.5 K and gets 7 K

w

Mm v

Sw

Holmes v. Holmes, 2005 CanLII 5488 (ON S.C.)

M

Desotti

Partial

Divorce action with 3  day  trial, wife gets 12 K, husband asks45 K

w

F v f

Ce

Margie v. Akogyeram, 2006 CanLII 16369 (ON S.C.)

M

DiTomaso

Full

Default for not abiding by court order to sell home, pleadings struck, 10.3 K costs

w

F v m

Ce

Martin (Shore) v. Shore, 2004 CanLII 5060 (ON S.C.)

M

Ditomaso

Partial

I0 K costs to husband for questioning at which wife refused to answer, previous 6.9 K costs for security motion

w

M v m

Ce

Martin-Shore v. Shore, 2004 CanLII 17019 (ON S.C.)

M

Ditomaso

Partial

Wife gets husbands motion to vary support stayed and gets 6.6 K costs for motion

w

M v sr

Ce

Ojo v. Ojo, 2005 CanLII 9674 (ON S.C.)

M

DiTomaso

Partial

Motion to stay support and arrears and security, 45.9 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Ragis v. Ragis, 2005 CanLII 18854 (ON S.C.)

M

Fedak

Partial

Divorce action, only issue left for trial was support, 10 K costs

w

F v f

Cs

S.P. v. F.R., 2006 CanLII 19948 (ON S.C.)

M

Festeryga

Partial

Divorce action, wife asks 25 K and gets 20 .3 K, husband Asks  30.3 K

w

F v sr

Cs

Atkinson v. Atkinson, 2007 CanLII 14318 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

Divorce trial. 14.5 K

w

 

Cs

Boddington v. Boddington, 2003 CanLII 45771 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Full

8.5 K

w

F v m

Cs

Claer v. Claer, 2006 CanLII 32612 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

Motion, wife asks 8.5 K gets 5 K

w

F v sr

Cs

Cupolo v. Anzovino, 2003 CanLII 2091 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

1K for ex parte divorce, requested 11 K

w

M v m

Cs

Johannesson v. Johannesson, 2003 CanLII 2141 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

Contempt access motion by husband, 2.1 K costs

w

F v m

Cs

Lagos v. Lagos, 2006 CanLII 43492 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

Motion, 6.9 K costs

w

Sr v sr

Cs

Platonova v. Platonov, 2005 CanLII 2951 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

Divorce action, self represented wife gets 2 K costs against iuntrasient husband

w

M v m

Cs

Vernon v. Vernon, 2006 CanLII 23266 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

Motion for support, wifes partial lawyers bill 47 K, 15 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Wrixon v. Wrixon, 2006 CanLII 43499 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

Motion, 3.4 K costs

w

F v m

Cs

McKinnon v. McKinnon, 2004 CanLII 47798 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Flynn

Partial

72 K costs in action involving retroactive support

w

M v  m

Cs

Nittel v. Nittel, 2007 CanLII 14340 (ON S.C.)

M

Flynn

Partial

Divorce action 22 K

w

F v m

Cw

Bradley v. Bradley, 2003 CanLII 28218 (ON S.C.)

M

Fragomeni

Partial

Wife gets 6.5 K for interim motion

w

F v m

Cw

Collin v. Collin, 2005 CanLII 48919 (ON S.C.)

M

Fragomeni

Partial

Support variation, divided success, wife gets 1.5 K costs

w

M v m

Cw

Elder v. Elder, 2006 CanLII 3276 (ON S.C.)

M

Fragomeni

Partial

Motion to vary support, husband asks 10.3 K and wife gets 3.5 K

w

M v m

Cw

Flewelling v. Flewelling, 2007 CanLII 16442 (ON S.C.)

M

Fragomeni

Partial

Interim motion, 2,5 K costs

w

F v m

Cw

Lowe v. Lowe, 2006 CanLII 3280 (ON S.C.)

M

Fragomeni

Partial

Motion, 6 K costs

w

F v sr

Cw

Trick v. Trick, 2005 CanLII 48923 (ON S.C.)

M

Fragomeni

Partial

Wifes motion for husbands non compliance, 10 K costs

w

F v m

Ce

Kirby v. Chappell, 2003 CanLII 1990 (ON S.C.)

M

Glass

Full

Divorce action with trial, 9 K costs

w

 

Ce

Wood v. Wood, 2002 CanLII 2717 (ON S.C.)

M

Glass

Partial

Interim motion, wife claims 7.7 K and gets 5.5 K, husband claims 8.2 K

w

 

Cs

Ashley v. Ashley, 2006 CanLII 32603 (ON S.C.)

M

Glithero

Partial

Support motion, 8 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Defoe v. Defoe, 2004 CanLII 5040 (ON S.C.)

M

Glithero

Partial

Divorce action, all but support settled on consent, wife gets 1.2 K

w

F v m

Cs

Erb v. Erb, 2003 CanLII 2308 (ON S.C.)

M

Glithero

Partial

Divorce action, wife asks 23.8 K gets 17.9 K

w

 

Cs

Harnum v. Harnum, 2005 CanLII 3231 (ON S.C.)

M

Glithero

Partial

12.6 K costs for 2 day trial

w

M v sr

Cs

A.P. v. G.P., 2006 CanLII 17600 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Full

Divorce action, 17.9 K costs

w

F v m

Cs

F.J.N. v. J.L.N., 2004 CanLII 34783 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Partial

Divorce action including mobility, wife asks 20.2 K gets 15 K

w

M v f

Cs

Craig v. Craig, 2004 CanLII 5039 (ON S.C.)

M,

Gordon

Full

Husbands motion to terminate support, 6.4 K costs

w

M v sr

Cs

H.1 v. H.2, 2004 CanLII 43947 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Partial

1 day simple trial, 5.9 K costs

w

 

Cs

Kelly v. Kelly, 2002 CanLII 2700 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Partial

Interim motion, wife asks 4.6 K

w

M v m

Cs

Lee-Chin v. Lee-Chin, 2005 CanLII 47758 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Partial

Several interim motions consolidated into one hearing, wife asks 29.9 K gets 13.4 K, husband asks 37.1 K

w

M v m

Cs

Mayer v. Mayer, 2003 CanLII 2177 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Gordon

Partial

Interim motion on parenting schedule, 4.5 K costs

w

 

Cs

Plotz v. Boehmer-Plotz, 2004 CanLII 34349 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Partial

Trial; of support, 6.5 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Sheikh v. Sheikh, 2005 CanLII 34589 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Partial

Divorce action, wife wins mobility, asks 190 K and gets 150 K

w

F v m

Nw

Norland v. Norland, 2007 CanLII 20786 (ON S.C.)

M

GP Smith

Partial

Wife gets 6.6 K for interim motion

w

M v m

Cs

Fulmer v. Kaleo-Fulmer, 2002 CanLII 2719 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Partial

2.6 K

w

M v m

Cs

Gentle v. Gentle, 2007 CanLII 26606 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Partial

Motion to vary support. 3.8 K costs

w

F v m

Cs

R.W.L. v. K.A.L., 2003 CanLII 2168 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Partial

Husband brings motion for  custody assessment and access, 5.9 K costs

w

F v m

Cs

Tzeng v. Tzeng, 2007 CanLII 17042 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Partial

Wife gets 112.4 K costs in assault action against husband, 150 K damage award

w

M v m

Cs

Brandon v. Brandon, 2003 CanLII 2069 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Partial

Access motion to determine where children gotoscholl, 0.7 K costs

w

M v sr

Cs

Buck v. Buck, 2003 CanLII 2072 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Full

Unnecesary motion, 8.9 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Fleming v. Fleming, 2005 CanLII 19832 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Partial

Motion to vary access to unsupervised, 0.8 K costs

w

 

Cs

Reid v. Warren, 2003 CanLII 2221 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Full

Interim motion for disclosure

w

M v m

Cs

Reinhardt v. Reinhardt, 2004 CanLII 34788 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Full

Separation agreement varied, 58.7 K  costs

w

M v f

Cs

Sanders v. Sanders, 2003 CanLII 2347 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Partial

Divorce action, 7.5 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Cauchy-Eckardt v. Eckardt, 2004 CanLII 6225 (ON S.C.)

M

Hamby

Partial

Support motion, wife asks 8 K and gets 7.4 K

w

M v m

Cs

Costa v. Costa, 2002 CanLII 2708 (ON S.C.)

M

Harris

Partial

Divorce action, 5 day trial, wife asks 41.7 K and gets 34.3 K

w

M v sr

Cs

Facchin v. Taylor, 2004 CanLII 33118 (ON S.C.)

M

Henderson

Partial

Appeal of support variance, 2 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Keen v. Keen, 2007 CanLII 6919 (ON S.C.)

M

Henderson

Partial

Divorce action settled on consent except support, 9.4 costs

w

M v sr

Cs

Longpre v. Skursky, 2005 CanLII 31301 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Henderson

Partial

Motion to vary support dismissed, $ 250 costs unless higher bill approved

w

F v  f

Cs

MacGregor v. Stone, 2004 CanLII 42944 (ON S.C.)

M

Henderson

Partial

Divorce action with 10 day  trial, 62 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Racz v. Racz, 2004 CanLII 39025 (ON S.C.)

M

Henderson

Partial

Divorce action settled on consent, 4.5 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Zeleny v. Zeleny, 2004 CanLII 5094 (ON S.C.)

M

Henderson

Partial rate raised from agreement

Wife agreed to pay lawyer $ 90 per hour but judge raises it to $ 195, 7.8 K for one motion

w

M v m

Cs

Cianflone v. Cianflone, 2006 CanLII 37127 (ON S.C.)

M

Henderson

Partial

Divorce action no kids 14.3 K costs

w

M v m

Ce

Manning v. Manning, 2004 CanLII 33295 (ON S.C.)

M

Howden

Partial

Support variation, 15.K

w

F v m

Ce

Millard v. Cargoe, 2004 CanLII 15955 (ON S.C.)

M

Howden

Partial

Interim motion to vary support, 4.7 K costs

w

M v m

Ce

Naidoo v. Naidoo, 2004 CanLII 886 (ON S.C.)

M

Howden

Full

Divorce action, 89.6 K costs

w

F v m

Ce

Sloan v. Sloan, 2006 CanLII 38366 (ON S.C.)

M

Howden

Partial

Support variation, 12.4 costs

w

F v m

Cw

Finch v. Finch, 2003 CanLII 9776 (ON S.C.)

M

Kruzick

Partial

Support variation, wife asks for 23 K and gets 6 K

w

 

Cw

Hutchinson v. Hutchinson, 2002 CanLII 2792 (ON S.C.)

M

Langdon

Partial

Motion to change jurisdiction, 6 K costs

w

F v m

Cs

Galambos v. Towers, 2006 CanLII 29661 (ON S.C.)

M

Lofchik

Partial

Divorce action no children, wife asks for 60.4 K andgets 44.7K

w

M v m

Ne

Bevacqua v. Bevacqua, 2003 CanLII 1936 (ON S.C.)

M

Loukidelis

Partial

Appeal, 10 K costs

w

M v m

Cw

Fancett v. Deprato, 2006 CanLII 2402 (ON S.C.)

M

Mackenzie

Partial and full

Wife asks ror 68 K and gets 34 K for divorce action

w

M v f

Cw

Irwin v. Irwin, 2006 CanLII 5451 (ON S.C.)

M

Mackenzie

Partial

Divorce action, wife claims 47 K and gets 31.5 K, husband claims 42 K

w

M v m

Cs

Chapin v. Chapin, 2003 CanLII 2080 (ON S.C.)

M

Matheson

Partial

Support variation, $ 750 costs

w

M v m

Cs

Flewelling v. Flewelling, 2007 CanLII 16442 (ON S.C.)

M

Matheson

Partial

Motion unsuccessfully appealed, 6 K costs

w

M v f

Cs

Hines v. Hines, 2007 CanLII 2208 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Matheson

Partial

Support action,  3.1 K  costs

w

M v m

Cs

Parnell v. Viger, 2004 CanLII 27183 (ON S.C.)

M

Matheson

Partial and full

Divorce action with 9 days of trial involving constructive trust, 103.4 K costs

w

M v  m

Cs

Rawlins v. Rawlins, 2006 CanLII 28560 (ON S.C.)

M

Matheson

Partial

Variation, wife asks 25.7 K and gets 8.7 K 

w

M v sr

Nw

Almgren v. Almgren, 2006 CanLII 7502 (ON S.C.)

M

Mccartney

Partial

Divorce action, all that was left for triasl was support, wife asks 18.6 and gets 12 K

w

F v sr

Nw

Bolt v. Bolt, 2006 CanLII 8876 (ON S.C.)

M

McCartney

Partial and full

Divorce action, husbands pleadings struck, wife asks 45.5 K and gets 31 K

w

Mv f

Sw

Aunger v. Aunger, 2005 CanLII 9665 (ON S.C.)

M

McDonald

partial

33.8 K for trial

w

M v sr

Ne

Rose v. Rose, 2004 CanLII 17755 (ON S.C.)

M

O’Neil

Partial

Application to vary custody and support dismissed, 3.5 K costs

w

F v m

Ne

Hart v. Hart, 2003 CanLII 2130 (ON S.C.)

M

O’Neill

Partial

Trial of support, wife claims 43 K gets 3.5 K, husband also claims over 40  K costs

w

F v m

Ne

Borden v. Racicot, 2003 CanLII 2065 (ON S.C.)

M

ONeil

Partial

Interim motion, 1.3 K costs

w

F v m

T

Narayan v. Padathe, 2006 CanLII 19943 (ON S.C.)

M

Paisley

Full

Divorce  action, 75 K costs

w

M v sr

E

Fisher v. Green, 2003 CanLII 2120 (ON S.C.)

M

Panet

Partial

Wifes motion for retroactive support, wife claims 44 K gets 6.5 K

w

M v sr

E

Marie Cunningham v. Charles LeFebvre, 2004 CanLII 54630 (ON S.C.)

M

Panet

Partial

Interim motion, 7.5 K costs

w

F v m

E

Meredith v. Meredith, 2002 CanLII 2807 (ON S.C.)

M

Panet

Partial

Divorce action, divided success, wife gets 3.8 K

w

M v f

Ne

Walker v. Rutledge, 2003 CanLII 2358 (ON S.C.)

M

Pardu

Partial

Divorce action, 18 K costs

w

F v  sr

Cs

Damian v. Damian, 2007 CanLII 18021 (ON S.C.)

M

Pazaratz

Partial

Divorce action, wife asks 15.2 K and gets 10.6 K

w

F v m

Ce

Bemrose v. Fetter, 2006 CanLII 8201 (ON S.C.)

M

Perkins

Partial

Motion for support variation

w

F v sr

Ce

Cabral v. Cabral, 2005 CanLII 21872 (ON S.C.)

M

Perkins

Partial

Custody and access variation, wife gets husbands access terminated, 20 K costs

w

M v m

Ce

Costabile v. Costabile, 2004 CanLII 42934 (ON S.C.)

M

Perkins

Full

Wife gets husbands answer struck, 16 K costs

w

M v m

Ce

Davis v. Davis, 2004 CanLII 19156 (ON S.C.)

M

Perkins

Partial

Dividided success in application, husband pays 15K and 1.2 K for costs ruling

w

F v sr

Ce

Domb v. Domb, 2002 CanLII 45568 (ON S.C.)

M

Perkins

Full

Husbands pleadings struck, 12 K costs for motion

w

M v m

Ce

Elieff v. Elieff, 2007 CanLII 15787 (ON S.C.)

M

Perkins

Partial

Interims motions, wife claims 20 K gets 15.5 K

w

 

Ce

S.(C.) v. S.(M.), 2007 CanLII 20279 (ON S.C.)

M

Perkins

Full

Husband denied access to child must pay 320 K costs

w

F v f

Ce

Sedore v. Sedore, 2006 CanLII 2622 (ON S.C.)

M

Perkins

Partial

Divorce action, 7.3 K costs

w

F v f

Ce

Visconti v. Visconti, 2006 CanLII 2626 (ON S.C.)

M

Perkins

Partial

Wife gets 3 K on consent motion regarding setting husbands income

w

F v m

Nw

Kimpton v. Kimpton, 2003 CanLII 2147 (ON S.C.)

M

Pierce

Partial

Divorce action, wife claims 61 K gets 39.5

w

F v m

Nw

Lord v. Haner-Lord, 2003 CanLII 2174 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Pierce

Partial

Interim motion for access, husband more successful but wife in weaker financial situation wife asks for 4.6 K and gets 3 K, husband asks for 5.6 K

w

F v sr

Nw

M.C.J. v. J.J.J., 2006 CanLII 23936 (ON S.C.)

M

Pierce

Full

Divorce action, 31.4 K costs

w

M v sr

 

Korczynski v. Korczynski, 2007 CanLII 16631 (ON S.C.)

M

Pierce

Partial

Divorce action, wife claims 32.3 K and gets 9 K

w

Sr v sr

Nw

Bauer v. Bauer, 2006 CanLII 28731 (ON S.C.)

M

Platana

Partial

Divorce action, wife gets 8.5 K

w

F v sr

Nw

Bauer v. Bauer, 2007 CanLII 16624 (ON S.C.)

M

Platana

Partial

Husband makes failed motion for contempt, 3.5 K costs

w

M v sr

Nw

Pysznyj v. Pysznyj, 2007 CanLII 16639 (ON S.C.)

M

Platana

Partial

Trial of support, wife asks 9.8 K and gets 8.5 K

w

M v m

Nw

Topetto v. Topetto, 2003 CanLII 1984 (ON S.C.)

M

Platana

Partial

Divorce action primarily negotiated between parties, wife asks 9.4 K gets 5 K

w

M v sr

E

Dunklin v. Dunklin, 2006 CanLII 15761 (ON S.C.)

M

Power

Partial

Wife claims 16.5 K and gets 8.5 K for motion

w

M v m

E

Graff v. Graff, 2002 CanLII 2788 (ON S.C.)

M

Power

Partial

Interim motion, 3.8 K costs

w

F v m

E

Jonas v. Da Silva, 2003 CanLII 38129 (ON S.C.)

M

Power

Partial

Garnishment hearing, 4 K costs

w

Sr v sr

E

McLean v. Vallance, 2006 CanLII 28910 (ON S.C.)

M

Power

Partial

Wife claims 4.9 K and gets 1 K

w

F v sr

E

P.R. v. K.R., 2006 CanLII 1676 (ON S.C.)

M

Power

Full

Support variation, 10 K costs

w

F v m

E

Martin v. Martin, 2005 CanLII 11809 (ON S.C.)

M

Power

Partial

Dsivorce action, wife asks 165 K and gets 49 K

w

F v f

Cs

Logan v. Logan, 2004 CanLII 195 (ON S.C.)

M

Quinn

Partial

Interim motion for evidence, wife asks 1.5 K gets 0.5 K

w

M v m

E

Butler v. Poelstra, 2006 CanLII 41661 (ON S.C.)

 

M

R Smith

Partial

Divorce action, wife asks 16.3 K and gets 5.7 K

w

M v f

E

Fournier v. Burton, 2006 CanLII 42370 (ON S.C.)

M

R Smith

Partial

Husband loses motion to have support terminated, 4 K

w

F v m

E

Lindsay v. Lindsay, 2003 CanLII 2170 (ON S.C.)

M

R Smith

Partial

Trial on mobility,  22.5 K costs

w

F v sr

E

Trevisanutto v. Crnkovic, 2005 CanLII 19789 (ON S.C.)

M

R Smith

Partial

Motion to vary support, 5.8 K costs

w

F v m

Cs

Reid v. Mulder, 2006 CanLII 9981 (ON S.C.)

M

Reilly

Partial

Divorce action, wife allowed to move to fiji with child, no costs for custody but 6.4 K for financial

w

M v sr

E

Davis v. Davis, 2004 CanLII 32470 (ON S.C.)

M

Roy

Full

Divorce action, wife asks 61 K gets 50.7 K

w

F v sr

E

Hamilton v. Hamilton, 2005 CanLII 47744 (ON S.C.)

M

Roy

Partial

Interim motions, 5 K costs

w

M v sr

E

Cunningham v. Lefebvre, 2006 CanLII 5602 (ON S.C.)

M

Rutherford

Partial

Interim motion 3 K costs

w

M v sr

E

Marie Cunningham v. Charles LeFebvre, 2004 CanLII 54630 (ON S.C.)

M

Rutherford

Full

Interim motion for leave to appeal cost ruling denied

w

M v m

E

Marks v. Tokarewicz, 2002 CanLII 2799 (ON S.C.)

M

Rutherford

Partial

Interim motion on support application wife didn’t pay costs of precious order, .75 K costs

w

M v sr

T

Bechler v. Bechler, 2004 CanLII 879 (ON S.C.)

M

Sachs

Partial

Divorce action, wife claims 48K gets 10.8 K

w

F v m

Cs

Butsky-Plekan v. Plekan, 2005 CanLII 25103 (ON S.C.)

M

Scime

Partial

Divorce, wife asks 117 K and gets 75 K, husband asks 306 K

w

M v sr

E

Roberts v. Aasen, 2003 CanLII 2000 (ON S.C.)

M

Sedgwick

Full

Custody and access 60.9 K awaed

w

F v sr

T

Hosannah v. Hosannah, 2004 CanLII 9498 (ON S.C.)

M

Seigel

Partial

Appeal, wife asks for 13.8 K and gets 7 K

w

M v sr

 

A.J.B. v. L.M.R.B., 2006 CanLII 26161 (ON S.C.)

M

Shaw

Partial

Wife gets 3 K on interim motion, asks for 6 K

w

M v m

 

Santos v. Santos, 2006 CanLII 28744 (ON S.C.)

M

Shaw

Partial

Interim motion on sale of home,wife asks 4.5 K and gets 2.3 K, husband asks 5.7 K

w

M v sr

E

Cunningham v. Lefebvre, 2006 CanLII 5602 (ON S.C.)

M

Sheffield

Partial

Interim motion, 2 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Bolentiru v. Radulescu, 2004 CanLII 34775 (ON S.C.)

M

Sills

Partial

Divorce action marriage declared invalid,  wife asks 45.4 K  gets 20.6 K

w

M v sr

Cs

Loebsack v. Loebsack, 2004 CanLII 16872 (ON S.C.)

M

Sills

Partial

Dovorce action, wife gets 5 K costs

w

M v f

 

DeCicco v. DeCicco, 2003 CanLII 2094 (ON S.C.)

M

 Smith

Partial

Wife seeks 73 K for divorce action and gets 20 K. husband claims 45.3 K

w

M v sr

T

Johnson v. Schwalm, 2006 CanLII 13771 (ON S.C.)

M

Spence

Full

Contempt motion, 15.8 K costs, ordered imprisoned if he doesn’t pay

w

F v m

Cw

Lemmon v. Lemmon, 2004 CanLII 24123 (ON S.C.)

M

Sproat

Partial

Divorce action, wife gets 3.3 K

w

M v m

Cw

Benak v. Benak, 2006 CanLII 6906 (ON S.C.)

M

Sproat

Partial

Divorce action,  wife gets 48.6 K costs

w

F v f

Cw

Hobbs v. Hobbs, 2007 CanLII 26282 (ON S.C.)

M

Sproat

Partial

Success on motions divided, wife asks 53.5 K and gets 8 K

w

M v sr

Cs

F.(J.) v. C.(V.) (No. 7), 2002 CanLII 46717 (ON S.C.)

M

Steinberg

Partial

Divorce action with 73 day trial, wife asks 290 K and gets 90 K

w

M v m

Ce

Brown v. Brown, 2004 CanLII 44987 (ON S.C.)

M

Stong

Full

Motion for support, 12.8 K costs

w

F v sr

Ce

Dunn v. Menear, 2003 CanLII 20236 (ON S.C.)

M

Stong

Full

Support variation, 4.3 K costs

w

F v m

Ce

Metter v. Solomon, 2005 CanLII 9673 (ON S.C.)

M

Stong

Partial

Support variatio, 15.7 K costs

w

M v m                                                                                                                                       

Ce

King v. Sutherland, 2005 CanLII 6377 (ON S.C.)

M

Strong

Full

Motion for support, 4.7 K costs

w

F v m

Ce

Munro v. Munro, 2004 CanLII 44992 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Strong

Partial

2 K cost penalty seeking leave to appeaL 1.5 K cost penalty

w

M v m

Cs

Martin v. Blanchard, 2007 CanLII 26611 (ON S.C.)

M

Taylor

Partial

Spousal support 2 day truial, 15.7 K

w

M v sr

Ce

Dvernichuk v. Larouche, 2003 CanLII 2107 (ON S.C.)

M

Timms

Partial

Motion for access and  custody, 4.5 K costs

w

F v m

Cs

Kloosterman v. Kloosterman, 2006 CanLII 35629 (ON S.C.)

M

Turnbull

Partial

Wife asks 45 K and gets 8.5 K in divorce action

w

F v m

Cs

Mitton v. Mitton, 2007 CanLII 4323 (ON S.C.)

M

Turnbull

Partial

Support motion, 7.4 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Pasichnyk v. Pasichnyk, 2005 CanLII 46745 (ON S.C.

M

Turnbull

Partial

Divorce action, husband declares bakruptcy, 30 K costs

w

M v m

Cs

Young v. Staruck, 2006 CanLII 28111 (ON S.C.)

M

Turnbull

Partial

Child support variation, 4.1 K

w

 

 

Simpson v. Miller, 2002 CanLII 2827 (ON S.C.)

 

F

Wallace

Full

Support motion, 11.1 K costs

w

F v m

Nw

G.P.M. v. S.J.F., 2005 CanLII 19840 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Wright

Full

Divorce action 36.4 Kcosts

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix 3    Divided Success

 

 

 

Lawyer Sex

 

Sex of Judge

      Judge

 

                 Description

 

F (f)v m

Moniz v. Santos, 2006 CanLII 20533 (ON S.C.)

 

Swinton

Divided success

L v l

Klein v. Zagdanski, 2004 CanLII 42954 (ON S.C.)

 

Abbey

Interim motion consented before  return

M  v m

Garlough v. Garlough, 2002 CanLII 2845 (ON S.C.)

 

Abbey

Divided success

F v m

Taylor v. Branconnier, 2003 CanLII 2399 (ON S.C.)

 

Hennesey

8 day custody trial, no costs without bad faith

M v m

Janmaat v. Janmaat, 2005 CanLII 25900 (ON S.C.)

 

Misener

Divorce action, husband gets better result

M v f

(m)

Stewart v. Jones, 2003 CanLII 2251 (ON S.C.)

 

 

Seppi

Appealof support, divided success.

L v l

Wright v. Ingham, 2006 CanLII 591 (ON S.C.)

 

Sheppard

Application for access due to police order from DV

M v m

Savage v. O'Brien, 2007 CanLII 3888 (ON S.C.)

 

Sheppard

Divorce  action continuing for 4 years

M v m

Theriault v. Theriault, 2007 CanLII 13519 (ON S.C.)

 

Sills

Divorce action, dfivided success

Fvm (m)

Couture v. Couture, 2006 CanLII 25259 (ON S.C.)

 

 

Whitten

Vary support including retroactive, husband largely successful with offer

Sr v sr

T.P.S. v. K.E.S, 2007 CanLII 17382 (ON S.C.)

F

Aitken

Divorce action, husband claims, 85.7 K, wife claims   72.5 K, both disentitled to  costs

M v m

Lewis v. Lewis, 2003 CanLII 1973 (ON S.C.)

F

Aitken

Interim support,  both partiesacted badly, husband made better offer

M v f (f)

Vanier v. Vanier, 2003 CanLII 2042 (ON S.C.)

F

Blishen

Divorce action, divided success

Fvm (m)

Statham v. Statham, 2003 CanLII 2278 (ON S.C.)

F

DeSousa

Wife successful but committed fraud

M v F (m)

Bautista v. Bautista, 2002 CanLII 46582 (ON S.C.)

F

Desousa

Successful man can’t rely on offer to settle as he didn’t submit proper disclosure

M v m

Fell v. Fell, 2007 CanLII 20101 (ON S.C.)

F

Desousa

Mostly settled on consent

F v m (m)

Pepin v. Jung, 2003 CanLII 31374 (ON S.C.)

F

Desousa

Motion to  vary  supportuccess divided

F v f

Gingo v. Ginglo, 2004 CanLII 1546 (ON S.C.)

F

Greer

Support variation

L v l

Davies v. Davies, 2007 CanLII 2366 (ON S.C.)

F

Herman

Divided success

F  v  f

O'Reilly v. O'Reilly, 2006 CanLII 44279 (ON S.C.)

F

Herman

Wife  claim 32 K costs  and  husband  claims 33.4 K, success divided

L v l

Ferazzutti v. Ferazzutti, 2006 CanLII 44270 (ON S.C.)

F

Herman

Divided success

M v sr (f)

Fantin v. Gillingham-Corkun Fantin, 2003 CanLII 2113 (ON S.C.)

F

Karakatsanis

 

M  v f (m)

Butler v. Butler, 2007 CanLII 17023 (ON S.C.)

F

Mackinnon

Motion for support, success divided

M v m

Kereluk v. Kereluk, 2004 CanLII 45467 (ON S.C.)

F

Polowin

Divided success

M v f

Rawn v. Laviolette, 1998 CanLII 864 (ON S.C.)

F

Rutherford

Divided success

F v m (m)

Dhanji v. Dhanji, 2004 CanLII 30090 (ON S.C.)

 

F

Stewart

Divorce action, husband successful  party

Fv m  (f)

Priolo v. Priolo, 2004 CanLII 7045 (ON S.C.)

 

F

Stewart

Divorce action, divided success

F v f

McDonald v. McDonald, 2005 CanLII 19808 (ON S.C.)

F

Tucker

Wife successful, both parties spent over 75 K

Sr v sr

Cavic v. Carroccia, 2006 CanLII 28554 (ON S.C.)

M

Fragomeni

Mixed resul, no costs

M v m

Guévin v. Scantland, 2007 CanLII 5525 (ON S.C.)

M

Maranger

Wife loses

M v m

Harmsworth v. Harmsworth, 2003 CanLII 1961 (ON S.C.)

M

Aston

Most issues agreed before trial

F (m) v m

Ramdatt v. Ramdatt, 2004 CanLII 4016 (ON S.C.)

M

Campbell

Wife has more success but fails to disclose financial infomation

F v f

Denley v. Denley, 2006 CanLII 1015 (ON S.C.)

M

Belch

Interim motion, no basis for costs

M v sr (f)

Oxley v. Oxley, 2004 CanLII 5070 (ON S.C.)

M

Belleghem

Motion and loco parentis trial

F v f

Nepaul v. Nepaul, 2004 CanLII 5067 (ON S.C.)

M

Belleghem

Divorce action

M v m

Ruscinski v. Ruscinski, 2006 CanLII 19446 (ON S.C.)

M

Cavarzan

Divorce action, divided success

M v m

Surerus-Mills v. Mills, 2006 CanLII 42362 (ON S.C.)

M

Del Frate

Support variation, applicant spent 52 K

F v m (f)

Dent v. Dent, 2004 CanLII 10442 (ON S.C.)

M

Fragomeni

Variation, husband gets  support reduced

mvm

Dafoe v. Dafoe, 2005 CanLII 28536 (ON S.C.)

M

G p smith

No costs

F v f

Wedig v. Gaukel, 2007 CanLII 14349 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Mobility case

M v m

Hunter v. Hunter, 2005 CanLII 47756 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Gordon

Wife failed to make submission in time

M v m

Millen v. Millen, 2004 CanLII 17769 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Application to terminate support, support reduced

F v m(f)

Hunter v. Hunter, 2005 CanLII 34580 (ON S.C.)

M

Gordon

Wifes lawyer requesrs no costs and husbands doesn’t answer

M v sr (f)

Desjardins v. Waters, 2006 CanLII 1203 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Graham

Child support determination, divided success.

Mv m

Wagner v. Ottman, 2003 CanLII 2266 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Divided success, husbands motion for costs dismissed

L v l

Purvis v. Purvis, 2003 CanLII 18186 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

For husband to have to  pay costs on  top of  ruling  would be oppressive

L v l

Roberts v. Roberts, 2004 CanLII 6234 (ON S.C.)

M

Hambly

Divided success

F v f

Hamilton v. Hamilton, 2005 CanLII 2315 (ON S.C.)

M

Maranger

Divorce action, divided success, both parties spent a large amountof money

F v f

Levesque v. Levesque, 2003 CanLII 2166 (ON S.C.)

M

Pierce

Interim motion mostly on consent, husband gets custody

M v f (m)

Lawson v. Lawson, 2004 CanLII 6219 (ON S.C.)

M

Quinn

Wife would of got costs but submitted a false financial  statement

M v  m                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           

Anger v. Anger, 2004 CanLII 7572 (ON S.C.)

M

Quinn

Interim motion to  varycustody and access

M v m

Ellis v. Ellis, 2004 CanLII 33293 (ON S.C.)

M

R MacKinnon

Husband gets custody and asks 42 K

Sr v sr

Lampron v. Lampron, 2006 CanLII 12427 (ON S.C.)

M

R Smith

Interim motion ,  no costs

M  v  m

Paulson v. Lamarre, 2006 CanLII 42380 (ON S.C.)

M

R Smith

Motion to vary support

L v l

Baldwin v. Funston, 2004 CanLII 21282 (ON S.C.)

 

M

Sachs

Wife asks 66 K husband asks 150 K, divided success

M v m

Miller v. Miller, 2006 CanLII 30597 (ON S.C.)

M

Tulloch

Success divided